The PlanetCricket.org Mafia - End game

I just thought I will analyze this again -

Hey come on, do it!
mafia-1

I thought you knew how to do it. I can't.
mafia 2.

This person not have the killing abilities.

Whatttt? I can't either. Wtf!
mafia 1

theory 1- Either this realized now, he was role blocked ( I don't think that is possible to get to know at night itself. So....) OR
theory 2- even this person doesn't have killing abilities.

So now what?
mafia 2

Do what you know, I will do what I know.
Does this hint that these two mafias have different role ? That is, they cannot kill maybe ? But some other roles.

Done.

Done. Now sleep!

So, they both performed their roles.

He knew he was an important one but played it safe for the night.
This from what I understood, is a person with night kill role. He chose to play safe because he is with townies. He didn't wanted to risk killing someone. So, he played it safe.



Now. I have a feeling we have serial killer or something like that.

From the looks of it-

1- mafias didnt kill anyone.
2- pro town vigilante who didn't kill anyone.

But one player died.

So,

3- Does this hint there is a serial killer ? Because one person died and mafias didnt kill nor the vigilante. So, someone else killed him !

Also, can anyone tell me what are the other roles in the mafia game which has a power to kill in night ?
 
Two mafia guys with no killing power seems too far fetched. But, you never know what the game setup is like. So at the moment, I'll concur with Z's analysis pending any new developments.
 
I just thought I will analyze this again -


mafia-1


mafia 2.

This person not have the killing abilities.


mafia 1

theory 1- Either this realized now, he was role blocked ( I don't think that is possible to get to know at night itself. So....) OR
theory 2- even this person doesn't have killing abilities.


mafia 2


Does this hint that these two mafias have different role ? That is, they cannot kill maybe ? But some other roles.



So, they both performed their roles.


This from what I understood, is a person with night kill role. He chose to play safe because he is with townies. He didn't wanted to risk killing someone. So, he played it safe.



Now. I have a feeling we have serial killer or something like that.

From the looks of it-

1- mafias didnt kill anyone.
2- pro town vigilante who didn't kill anyone.

But one player died.

So,

3- Does this hint there is a serial killer ? Because one person died and mafias didnt kill nor the vigilante. So, someone else killed him !

Also, can anyone tell me what are the other roles in the mafia game which has a power to kill in night ?

Two mafia guys with no killing power seems too far fetched. But, you never know what the game setup is like. So at the moment, I'll concur with Z's analysis pending any new developments.
Yupe, that what user2010 also told think out of box.

3 Killing roles won't be good + if there is a Vigi.

So the setup could be like this ;

1 Mafia(killing role), 1 Mafia(none killing role) and 3rd Party(killing role) [If this is the setup and there is also a Vigi. than it sums up as 3 killing roles]. But we saw one death, means either Mafia or 3rd Party were able to perform their role. Most probably there could be a Role Blocker.

The chat log. that User posted, suggest that two anti-townies were talking. I suspect 2 Mafias were talking as because 3rd Party normally dose not talk with Mafia or Townie. This sums up that 1 Mafia or 3rd Party was unable to perform there role (Most likely role blocked). [Hence : we got 1 kill on Night 1] But if there is a Vigi. this means he was also unable to perform his night kill? My feeling is that, Vigilante didn't perform his night kill.
 
And you don't think that there is a pro-town vigilante ?

Also, I did not understand what you said. Do you mean to say that two mafias are - 1st mafia-one without killing powers and 2nd mafia- an anti-town third party
Yeah, didn't think about that. Could be the case as well.
 
This sums up that 1 Mafia or 3rd Party was unable to perform there role (Most likely role blocked).
After re-reading the chat log of night 1, it does make sense to think that both the mafias do not have a kill role but perhaps sort of a nomination role.

I'm thinking along the lines that each of them nominate one person but the final decision rests with the godfather. He may accept the nomination or take his own pick.

So many possibilities.
 
After re-reading the chat log of night 1, it does make sense to think that both the mafias do not have a kill role but perhaps sort of a nomination role.

I'm thinking along the lines that each of them nominate one person but the final decision rests with the godfather. He may accept the nomination or take his own pick.

So many possibilities.
Yeah this could be the the case. There could be a GF Mafia.
 
Sorry for not posting, didn't have a perfect picture to be fairly honest. User's write-up gives a clue that there are two mafia members but no one has the banning/killing power, but I feel it's highly unlikely to have a game of mafia without mafia being able to kill.
 
I just thought I will analyze this again -


mafia-1


mafia 2.

This person not have the killing abilities.


mafia 1

theory 1- Either this realized now, he was role blocked ( I don't think that is possible to get to know at night itself. So....) OR
theory 2- even this person doesn't have killing abilities.


mafia 2


Does this hint that these two mafias have different role ? That is, they cannot kill maybe ? But some other roles.



So, they both performed their roles.


This from what I understood, is a person with night kill role. He chose to play safe because he is with townies. He didn't wanted to risk killing someone. So, he played it safe.



Now. I have a feeling we have serial killer or something like that.

From the looks of it-

1- mafias didnt kill anyone.
2- pro town vigilante who didn't kill anyone.

But one player died.

So,

3- Does this hint there is a serial killer ? Because one person died and mafias didnt kill nor the vigilante. So, someone else killed him !

Also, can anyone tell me what are the other roles in the mafia game which has a power to kill in night ?

Finally someone who gets it :cheers
 
Rudolph is acting all strange again. Plus i think it's time to get something going.

Lynch : Rudolph
 
Vote count:

Rudolph (2) - Simon, CerealKiller
AliB (1) - Jack Ryder
Simon (1) - Rudolph
 
Rudolph is acting all strange again. Plus i think it's time to get something going.

Lynch : Rudolph
I'm acting strangely, that's the best you can come up with :facepalm Looks like you are jumping on the Simon bandwagon. FFS our site is in a mess and you guys are playing around. I'm removing Simon from staff & CerealKiller from the fantasy Cricket team once my site is restored.

If you guys care about Planetcricket.org at all let's get rid of this F@[HASHTAG]#8ng[/HASHTAG] scum. You do not have to give your alliance , just say what you did last night (Those who have a power role / can perform night actions)

I blocked Simon last night !!!
 
I see Jack Ryder has a lynch ion me still. @Jack Ryder why have you lynched me? Elaborate.
 
Yeah, didn't think about that. Could be the case as well.
I had posted it just 2 posts above the message you had posted. Also, even Simon had raised doubt on this. So, you are saying you didn't read both the posts ?

Thus Simon is one of the following:
  1. The Third Party (Anti Planetcricket)
  2. Mafia scum
  3. Vigilante (Town aligned)

You are role claiming ? Again ?
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top