The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[Bevab]

The tracker and doctors know much about the game. But instead of speaking out, they're keeping shut, you need some more knowledge to pass info you know without leaking out your role. That is what these players need to exactly do.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Well, I though I might actually post what I know (not much). I actually know nothing. On Night 0, I didn't use my role, on night 1 I protected Mark, and night 2 didn't use my role. The renowned doctor, I am. Not sure about any hidden role. Other doc now needs to be very careful not to reveal himself.

I'm actually gutted, Varun has given out my role. Hi Everybody!

 

[Bevab]

Welcome doc. Better protect somebody now.

 

[BKB1991]

Well, I though I might actually post what I know (not much). I actually know nothing. On Night 0, I didn't use my role, on night 1 I protected Mark, and night 2 didn't use my role. The renowned doctor, I am. Not sure about any hidden role. Other doc now needs to be very careful not to reveal himself.

I'm actually gutted, Varun has given out my role. Hi Everybody!

I am surprised at this development. Surely we needed some revelations but not this. So you used your role alternate nights? Why would you do that? This is very a strange move on your part.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Because, night 0 was obvious I had no idea whom to protect. Night 2 was where I was very confused as I forgot Yudi was a miller or would have protected Ray. Also, I've a feeling I might be insane.

 

[ARay]

This is absolutely disgusting as a game. Why would you reveal the doctor in this game varun?
He is a part of the town with a power role
This game is as good as nearly over with so many roles being found found out.
Unlynch: Varun
I guess my lynching you has made you discuss all the wrong points.
I wanted you to start finding mafia, not power roles!
Meh, I am reaching the point where I am getting quite frustrated.

----------

Unlynch: Varun

----------

Well, I though I might actually post what I know (not much). I actually know nothing. On Night 0, I didn't use my role, on night 1 I protected Mark, and night 2 didn't use my role. The renowned doctor, I am. Not sure about any hidden role. Other doc now needs to be very careful not to reveal himself.

I'm actually gutted, Varun has given out my role. Hi Everybody!

Okay Explain this bolded point to me. I am pretty sure you did not protect Mark on Night 1.
What game are you playing?

 

[Gaurav_7]

I actually protected Mark, fat man in blue who you swapped with Yudi or Abhas? (man in white shirt?). Game? Ha ha, Ray. I'm as frustrated as you or even more. Off to bed!

 

[Abhas]

I was out for a day, come back to see the doctor's been revealed! I hope he's the insane one, and the other doc knows what to do. We need to protect important people of the town, and now that a few roles are out in the open, they definitely need protection.

I'll be posting a few questions in the morning. Mind's tired.

FOS: Bkb, Aditya, Varun

 

[ARay]

I actually protected Mark, fat man in blue who you swapped with Yudi or Abhas? (man in white shirt?). Game? Ha ha, Ray. I'm as frustrated as you or even more. Off to bed!

I swapped Mark and Yudi, both of whom were guys in Night 1.
But if you read the write-up. The cheap doctor protected a female.
Either you have confused who you targeted or the 2nd bus driver switched your target to someone else. However there seems to be no mention of a switch in the write up.

So either you are confused or you are lying for some reason. If you are townie, I do not think lying is a really good option.

 

[BKB1991]

Afaiac User seems to be shitting. Why? Because as a doctor a normal townie person would try and protect ANYONE at night. I mean whats tthe worst that can happen if you protect someone whos not town? If I was a doc, I would have taken the risk and in all previous games doctors have randomly protected people from the start.

I believe he is a doctor that can protect someone on alternate nights, what he does on the other night is debatable. Simply, I have a strong feeling that he is cult and maybe by protecting someone at night he can maybe find a member of his cult?

Either way FOS: User2010 and I am pretty inclined to lynch him now.

 

[Bevab]

Some lynching needs to be done.

 

[ARay]

Afaiac User seems to be shitting. Why? Because as a doctor a normal townie person would try and protect ANYONE at night. I mean whats tthe worst that can happen if you protect someone whos not town? If I was a doc, I would have taken the risk and in all previous games doctors have randomly protected people from the start.

I believe he is a doctor that can protect someone on alternate nights, what he does on the other night is debatable. Simply, I have a strong feeling that he is cult and maybe by protecting someone at night he can maybe find a member of his cult?

Either way FOS: User2010 and I am pretty inclined to lynch him now.

I think his argument is that he is insane. So It means that he has chance of killing his patient instead of protecting them.
However what I am interested to know is how is it that he protects Mark/Yudi (both guys) on night 1. When in the write up it clearly states that he protected a female.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm actually not a cheap doctor. That is what I wanted to know from the people who know about Simpsons. That is why I was posting, whether Dr. Nick is a cheap doc or Dr. Hibbert. From the writeups, I'm the renowned doctor.

 

[Abhas]

On Night 0, it is impossible for him to know if there was an insane role in the game. We came across the 2nd doctor only on Night 1.
Not protecting anyone on the first night is a bit odd.

He's definitely lying about something.
He has written "Hi Everybody" every day, and I think he's trying to push himself off as Dr Nick Riviera, as someone pointed out earlier.
I don't know much about the roles, so can't confirm if he's supposed to be the insane doc or the normal doc.

Anyway, I believe him to be either of the two docs, but instead of lying now, I think he should explain himself.

----------

Ok, just saw your post above. Clears a bit of the doubt.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Afaiac User seems to be shitting. Why? Because as a doctor a normal townie person would try and protect ANYONE at night. I mean whats tthe worst that can happen if you protect someone whos not town? If I was a doc, I would have taken the risk and in all previous games doctors have randomly protected people from the start.

Random protection? What if I protect a mafia? I protected Mark as I was sure enough. I would have protected Ray had I remembered about Yudi.

He was an extremely renowned doctor, known for his amazing feats and he decided to use his skills for best, to help his town. Tonight he had a target in mind; someone who he believed was helpful, he decided to guard the fatty with all his skills. He had kept his eyes on his target, and knew where he was tonight. As he followed his target, he tripped over cracked glass, he knew he had no time to play detective right now, so he got up, however he couldn’t find sight of the fat man in blue. He walked around searching and searching, until he found him, however it seemed as though he’d changed into a white shirt, and lost some weight. He continued to do his job, and protected the man for the rest of the night.
“Ooh a flower, and what a wonderful smell it has!”

Here, I protected Mark.

The town had identified his role, and they knew he loved creating confusion, but he always knew what he was doing, there wasn’t any confusion in it for him... or was there? He was Springfield’s (only?) main bus driver, school bus driver... that is. He’d planned his swap tonight, what a crazy idea he had he thought to himself! SO CRAZYYYYYYYYYY!!! AHahahashasdhahahahahaha!! He decided to check on his targets, but they were nowhere to be seen, so he went in the last place he’d thought he’d find them... WTF! They were fast asleep, both of them... but WHY!!

Me and Aditya were swapped but I didn't use my role. Sleeping...

The dark doctor approached his target and saw him crying on the ground...
“Why, what’s the matter here?”
“They’re sleeping!! Both of em!! It’s so not cool dude!”
“Well don’t worry, i’ll keep you company”
“It’s not about the company!! It never is!”
“Okay then, i’ll just stand here”

This is the other doc, dark doc. Not me.

----------

On Night 0, it is impossible for him to know if there was an insane role in the game. We came across the 2nd doctor only on Night 1.
Not protecting anyone on the first night is a bit odd.

I still don't know whether I'm insane or not. It is just I didn't want to protect any mafia on night 0 so decided not to use my role.