The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[ARay]

That was probably I think doctor hibbert (expensive) protected Mark on Night 1.
Doctor Nick{Cheap} (supposedly User) protected a "female" at night 1.
The reason why I say this is because.
User has stated he protected noone Night 0. Protected "Mark/Yudi" in Night 1. Protected no one on Night 2.
But that story makes no sense because the reference to the cheap doctor in the write up was protecting a female. But both Mark and Yudi are guys. So clearly his actions are not stated in the write up accordingly.

PS- THe reason why I say Yudi as well in Night 1 is because I switched Mark and Yudi around in Night 1. SO if User (doctor Nick) was protecting Mark, he would have ended up protecting Yudi ( Homer = Guy).

 

[Chewie]

Reading through the wikipedia entries for Doctor Nick and Doctor Hibbert, it seems that Hibbert is more a friend of the Simpson family than Doctor Nick, but that would go against the write up.

I'm thinking that either User has done a false role-claim and is either mafia or the good doctor, but doesn't want to be targeted.

 

[ARay]

If he is a doctor, it makes no sense for him to claim being a doctor.
A doctor stays in the background and does not hint his identity at all.
User did agree that saying "Hi everybody" was a strong hint. But he really did not need to give that hint. No one was attacking him or even had him under any sort of pressure.
The only reason why I hinted about my role was because I wanted people to lynch an anti-town member. I had a reason.
Either way, I do not know what User is really trying to do.

 

[Chewie]

He had been revealed by Varun, and so decided to claim as the weaker of the doctors?

 

[pcfan123]

Just to fill you in on Simpsons,

Dr Nick is a "fake" doctor. He has a phony medical degree and has a mal practice.

Dr Hibbert is the Simpsons family doctor and he has a distinctive chuckle.

Just let me know if you want to know about any other characters.

 

[Chewie]

Just to fill you in on Simpsons,

Dr Nick is a "fake" doctor. He has a phony medical degree and has a mal practice.

Dr Hibbert is the Simpsons family doctor and he has a distinctive chuckle.

Just let me know if you want to know about any other characters.

Quite helpful but confusing at the same time.

This line is what is really confusing me:

He wasn’t expensive, much cheaper than the other guy, but some doubted his abilities, however he served the Simpsons family just fine.

 

[pcfan123]

that's Doctor Nick. He is always cheaper than Hibbert (Simpsons always go to him when they can't afford Hibbert) and known to be shady but he had performed a few successful surgeries on Homer in a few episodes.

 

[MaD]

Guys, just figured out that I stuffed the writeups... the expensive doctor is the cheap one, and the cheap one is more expensive, sorry for the confusion, I know it's caused some fuss, and some of you will prbably be pissed, but... soz
I've edited the Night 1 writeup

 

[Chewie]

That sorts out some of the confusion. This leads me to think that the cheap doctor can't heal every night:

He’d decided to use his abilities to help an individual every night

----------

(That was about Hibbert, and so by contrary, it seems like Rivera can't protect every night)

----------

We really need to find a suspect to lynch though, otherwise it's gonna be night and we won't have gotten any more information, and we won't have potentially gotten rid of an extra mafia member

 

[Aditya]

Now, the activity has suddenly gone down from the last 2 days. Sorry for my activity from the last two days, busy with life. I'll have a look at the write ups again and try to help you guys with the lynch.

 

[ARay]

Guys, just figured out that I stuffed the writeups... the expensive doctor is the cheap one, and the cheap one is more expensive, sorry for the confusion, I know it's caused some fuss, and some of you will prbably be pissed, but... soz
I've edited the Night 1 writeup

That clears a lot up
And I was wondering why User was lying about his role?
Sorry User, but I was just basing it on the write ups!

Okay I think its time I lynch someone and start moving back on track.
Lynch: BKB
He had a few theories which I still have yet to hear. Maybe some positive punishment will help.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm also going to go for BKB, the way he pushed at me.

Lynch : BKB1991

 

[ARay]

Don Vittorio DiMaggio - Simpsons Wiki
Guess I found our killer old man.

Springfield Mafia - Simpsons Wiki
This is the entire list of possible mafia that we can be facing.
We have a squealer mafia amongst our midst.
I think he should be found and lynched today!

 

[Chewie]

Well the squealer was the one who tried to role block User but failed

----------

hmm actually since User was still able to do his job, maybe it wasn't a role block? Or maybe Mark got the role block because he was role blocked by someone

 

[ARay]

Well the squealer was the one who tried to role block User but failed

----------

hmm actually since User was still able to do his job, maybe it wasn't a role block? Or maybe Mark got the role block because he was role blocked by someone

Mark did not carry out his role because of my actions. My role not only switches two characters.
But also the people they are targetting.
Which means that Mark has a night role. And Yudi has none.
So After the switch Mark's target is no one because Yudi had no Night role (no target)
Yudi (if he hypothetically had a night role) would have then had Mark's target.
Does that make sense? It did not strike me in the beginning, but it made sense to me later on. This is how a bus driver works in this game.
it switches not only the people but also their original targets with each other.

----------

Just so you guys know, the tracker knows the squealers identity. I hope he does a better job than me in leading a lynch towards that member without getting his identity revealed like I did