The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[Chewie]

Ok that kinda makes sense. But then why is it the veil that prevents Mark from doing his role as cop?

BKB1991
Mark - Cop
Riz7khan12
Yudi - Miller
Aditya
User2010 - Doctor
Varun
Bevab - ?plainclothes Townie?
Meet - Townie
ARay - Bus Driver
Abhas
Chewie - Townie
CG123 - Mafia

There is another Doctor, the squealer, old person "in charge of the business", Tracker, a traitor??, and "number 1 fat man".

I'm guessing there's Lisa, Apu, Bart, Marge, and 3 mafia. Possibly not Marge though because there's only been one woman mentioned, and that's Lisa.

The traitor sounds like someone individually aligned, but we don't know much about him apart from

He wasn?t very well known throughout their business, in fact he was regarded as the ?traitor?, but that?s not what he was and he had to prove it. He?d brought something nobody would ever expect, and now it was in the most unexpected form ever! He placed it on the desk where he knew his target would find it, and walked off with a chuckle.

I'm kinda concerned about this, but I'm wondering whether it could be the same as another of the roles I've already posted. What is this item he's brought with him?

 

[ARay]

I know the traitor role in mafia is someone who comes out as townie when investigated.
Traitor - MafiaWiki
Wasn't Bevab eager to have himself investigated?
Could that be a reason?

 

[Chewie]

That is a good point but that would make too many mafia wouldn't it?

Godfather, Fat Tony, Squealer and now the Traitor. And we've already killed Callum

 

[Aditya]

I know the traitor role in mafia is someone who comes out as townie when investigated.
Traitor - MafiaWiki
Wasn't Bevab eager to have himself investigated?
Could that be a reason?

Good point there. If that's true then we will have 4 mafia's like Chewie mentioned, which is unlikely.

 

[CG123]

Godfather, Fat Tony, Squealer and now the Traitor. And we've already killed Callum

You townies didn't kill me, I was betrayed by my own.

 

[Chewie]

Actually, the description for traitor kinda sounds like Callum's role. And I doubt they'd have 5 mafia out of 13. 4 out of 13 is much better, with 1 of them not knowing who the rest are

 

[riz7khan12]

lol johnny tightlips doesn't sound like a traitor

 

[Abhas]

Bevab has constantly pushed for a lynch, without actually lynching anyone, or providing a lead.
All he's trying to do is getting someone to start a lynch, so that he can follow.
Posts like

Some lynching needs to be done.

Show he's desperate to look like a townie, while at the same time, help the mafia in achieving a kill.

I'm also very interested in BKB's game so far. Knowing he came up as a doc, he attacked him, trying to understand which doctor he actually was, and lynching him.
I agree I asked some questions about his role claim as well, but I got the hint, and stopped. I did not doubt him being either of the docs.

Interesting finds there, ARay, about the mafia roles, and the traitor.

FOS: Bevab - I have my suspicions on him, but not strong enough to lynch him yet. It's his first game, and we can't be sure what is n00bness and what is smart play.

Lynch: BKB1991 - He needs to explain himself now. He has been laying low, and hasn't contributed positively to any townie discussion. Wanted the doc to reveal his identity, or, trying to uncover the other doc.

 

[MaD]

BKB - (3) ARay, User, Abhas

 

[Chewie]

lol johnny tightlips doesn't sound like a traitor

The description kinda does though - being part of the mafia family but not knowing who else is, and the mafia trying to find him

----------

5 votes for a lynch. I don't like voting for players before they've had ample time to explain themselves, so I won't vote for a lynch quite yet. To me, no one stands out as being more mafia than others.

Riz and Bevab are both playing background roles - posting nothing of substance.

 

[Abhas]

Johnny Tightlips, Mafia Goon, Mafia Aligned

You are Johnny Tightlips, Mafia Goon. You do not know who your Mafia associates are and it is their job to find you. Once you are revealed to them, you will find out who they are.
You win when the Mafia win, if you stay alive until the end

According to his role, he could have been the traitor, but, not really sure about how the character behaves in the simpsons.

 

[ARay]

Actually, the description for traitor kinda sounds like Callum's role. And I doubt they'd have 5 mafia out of 13. 4 out of 13 is much better, with 1 of them not knowing who the rest are

I agree 5 out of 13 is way too much.
Probably callum was the Traitor. I presume.
So we have the don killing people and Fat tony killing.
We also have a 2nd bus driver apparently.
So here are the roles out.
Two doctors. Two bus driver. One tracker. Two killers. One Mafia role blocker (squaler). One Vanilla Townie.
Ohhh boy, This does not sound great at all.
We are at a situation where we have to pressure someone. But that means also risking a potential power being found out as well.
Looks like we have game in our hands.
Okay we need to lynch mafia today!
If we get our man, We will have one of us go down at night. We will be in good shape.

 

[riz7khan12]

Riz and Bevab are both playing background roles - posting nothing of substance.

bs, i have posted a few worthy posts i'm kinda busy atm but i'll have something to post later on.

According to his role, he could have been the traitor, but, not really sure about how the character behaves in the simpsons.

He came on the simpsons once, he's a background member of the mafia. He was at a mafia dinner and whenever anyone tried to talk to him all he said was "I aint saying nothing" So he clearly cant have been the traitor, my best bet is one person is both the squealer and the traitor.

 

[Abhas]

Traitor to the Mafia, or traitor to the town?
I believe we're talking about betraying the town here.

 

[riz7khan12]

and when he got shot, another mafia member asked where he got hit and he said his catch phrase lol.

for anyone who understands spanish