The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

[ARay]

Traitor to the Mafia, or traitor to the town?
I believe we're talking about betraying the town here.

Traitor to the town. He comes up as townie and helps mafia win.

 

[Aditya]

Bevab really hasn't contributed at all. Rest members at least post something useful at times but he really hasn't posted anything useful. All he posts is "we need to lynch someone". What's new in that? We all know that we need to lynch someone but we need to have a reason to lynch someone. He is not getting lynched because this is his first game but we need to keep in mind that he can be a mafia as well - acting like a townie and getting away from getting lynched because this is his first mafia game.

 

[riz7khan12]

Traitor to the town. He comes up as townie and helps mafia win.

If we're talking about characters then this sounds like Mr Burns to me, he'll sell anything for a price, and there are two old men in the write-ups one of them the godfather and the other (traitor) could be mr.burns.

 

[Chewie]

Why do you think there are two bus drivers? Having Mr Burns as a traitor makes even more mafia members which I think is starting to get too unlikely...

 

[Varun]

Bevab's behaviour has seemed really uncanny to me.

No! And I'm not interested in role-claiming or character claiming ATM.

I have no special role.

I'll role-claim at the time most needed.

FOS:Riz, Aditya

Reluctant at first?

The tracker and doctors know much about the game. But instead of speaking out, they're keeping shut, you need some more knowledge to pass info you know without leaking out your role. That is what these players need to exactly do.

Trying to extract some information?

Then he confessed he was just a plain townie.

If he was, why was he reluctant at first? It's common sense that the mafia would try to kill the people who they suspect have some special roles that are fatal to them rather than killing vanilla townies. (which I can conclude from the killing of mark)

He either has a big role or he is anti-town.

FOS : Bevab

----------

Also from the aforementioned discussions, it can be concluded that he is constantly pushing on for 'Lynch'. That is unusual.

 

[riz7khan12]

^well, i posted the exact same theory a few pages ago.

 

[Bevab]

I know the traitor role in mafia is someone who comes out as townie when investigated.
Traitor - MafiaWiki
Wasn't Bevab eager to have himself investigated?
Could that be a reason?

I'm sick of telling you that I'm a vanilla townie.

Bevab has constantly pushed for a lynch, without actually lynching anyone, or providing a lead.
All he's trying to do is getting someone to start a lynch, so that he can follow.
Posts like


Show he's desperate to look like a townie, while at the same time, help the mafia in achieving a kill.

I'm also very interested in BKB's game so far. Knowing he came up as a doc, he attacked him, trying to understand which doctor he actually was, and lynching him.
I agree I asked some questions about his role claim as well, but I got the hint, and stopped. I did not doubt him being either of the docs.

Interesting finds there, ARay, about the mafia roles, and the traitor.

FOS: Bevab - I have my suspicions on him, but not strong enough to lynch him yet. It's his first game, and we can't be sure what is n00bness and what is smart play.

Lynch: BKB1991 - He needs to explain himself now. He has been laying low, and hasn't contributed positively to any townie discussion. Wanted the doc to reveal his identity, or, trying to uncover the other doc.

I lynched Riz, you all have forgot it. And if you don't lynch, it'll just end as a no lynch which won't much help the town at this crucial hour.

And I did not ask for any protection okay, I'm just a townie and I only asked a cop to investigate me if you have doubts. And I don't even know that there is a role called Traitor.

Dr.Nick can protect tonight I think.

After some tough conversations you have decided to lynch BKB. Nice reason there Abhas. So,

Unlynch:Riz

Lynch:BKB1991

 

[Chewie]

Bevab just following the crowd as usual.

Now we are just one vote away from a hammer vote on BKB and he has not had enough time to defend himself. For all we know he could be the good doctor.

 

[Bevab]

Nobody hammer votes BKB for the moment, or you'll be the next guy to get the lynch in line.

----------

Bevab's behaviour has seemed really uncanny to me.





Reluctant at first?




Trying to extract some information?

Then he confessed he was just a plain townie.

If he was, why was he reluctant at first? It's common sense that the mafia would try to kill the people who they suspect have some special roles that are fatal to them rather than killing vanilla townies. (which I can conclude from the killing of mark)

He either has a big role or he is anti-town.

FOS : Bevab

----------

Also from the aforementioned discussions, it can be concluded that he is constantly pushing on for 'Lynch'. That is unusual.

I did not have any special role, and who would role-claim without purposes?
I have no big role okay.

I still do not wish to character claim, but there is no use in it. You want me to character claim?

 

[Chewie]

Nobody hammer votes BKB for the moment, or you'll be the next guy to get the lynch in line.

A post like this makes me inclined to believe you may be mafia... A bit too quick to jump on the lynchwagon, and then warning others not to.

----------

I did not have any special role, and who would role-claim without purposes?
I have no big role okay.

I still do not wish to character claim, but there is no use in it. You want me to character claim?

I think the mafia may well be taunting you into role claiming

 

[Bevab]

If I have no special role, what do you expect me to do?
False role-claim? Lolz.

Also when my role itself is known to you, there is no use in character claiming.

 

[Aditya]

This is not the first time Bevab has posted something like that.

Don't anybody cast the final lynch. If you do, you'll be the mafia.

^Bevab posted this when Yudi was getting lynched.

 

[Varun]

It's rather true that BKB has been shady in his way of posting.
Bevab lynching him and that quote (the hammer vote guy gets lynched) is something kind off signifying noobness. (though I myself have caused major blunders).

It's either him or Bilal. I think I should go for Bilal in that case.

Lynch : BKB1991

 

[Chewie]

Now he's dead. What if you've just killed the other doctor? Or the tracker who knows a mafia member but now cannot post

Will be justified if he turns out to be mafia, but I don't believe in hammer voting someone without giving them an opportunity to explain themselves

----------

Well I'm off to bed. Hopefully I wake up to find that you've just killed a mafia member.

 

[Aditya]

Will be justified if he turns out to be mafia, but I don't believe in hammer voting someone without giving them an opportunity to explain themselves

This.