West Indies tour of Australia, November-December 2009

[TumTum]

I'd say that being given out caught when you don't hit it is a shocking decision.....

If you miss the ball by a considarable margin, than it is shocking. Like a few decisions in the Ind v SL Test.

 

[Dare]

The 3rd umpire had no evidance to over turn the decision. It was most likely not out but none of us will never know.

Guyz don't be childish, you all know how the review system works

ahahah figured you would be the only one in the thread saying something stupid like this.

Chris Gayle all class even in a loss.

 

[MUFC1987]

If you miss the ball by a considarable margin, than it is shocking. Like a few decisions in the Ind v SL Test.

No, it's like being given out bowled when the ball doesn't hit the stumps. Shocking. No matter how you want to dress it up, if doesn't matter if it missed by a mm or a mile, get that into your head.

 

[TumTum]

Anywayz I support the review system, it's only the players that are complicating it by asking for 50-50 decisions.

 

[shravi]

Healy's asking Bollinger if he though Roach hit that. "Smashed it," says Bollinger, who admits they were a bit concerned with the review taking so long.

Ha.

"smashed it" is taking it a little too far, Bollinger.

 

[aussie1st]

Hmmm snicko showed something, so that would have confused matters actually.

 

[pcfan123]

Ha.

"smashed it" is taking it a little too far, Bollinger.

Bollinger is a right fat ugly prick. He will fit in perfectly with Johnson and Watson.

 

[Dare]

it's only the players that are complicating it by asking for 50-50 decisions.

ahahah it just that this wasn't a 50/50. It was another not out going in the favor of the Aussies.

 

[angryangy]

Also Watson only getting a 15% fine is the biggest bullshit decision in the past year. Got to say they dohed that one up really badly.

Again, pleaded guilty, avoided maximum penalty.

 

[McLOVIN]

The flaw is that no evidence = no overturn.

That is NOT a flaw, this is how the system works, to ONLY over turn SHOCKING decisions.

it didnt show up on hot spot ..b/c.. umm... may be...idk.. he didnt NICK IT! hows that no evidence?

 

[OffCutters]

Bollinger is a right fat ugly prick. He will fit in perfectly with Johnson and Watson.

Dougie doesnt deserve to be placed in the same sentence as FailFag Watson.

 

[McLOVIN]

Also Watson only getting a 15% fine is the biggest bullshit decision in the past year. Got to say they fliped that one up really badly.

lol he was jumping up and down like a lil girl with short blonde hair

 

[Dare]

Again, pleaded guilty, avoided maximum penalty.

So he can just keep doing the same ████ and keep pleading guilty and keep getting away from a ban? Weak

Good on Benn for not pleading guilty.

 

[TumTum]

no evidence? it didnt show up on hot spot ..b/c.. umm... may be...idk.. he didnt NICK IT! hows that no evidence?

Hot-spot doesn't pick up faint edges, I am not referring to this decision...

 

[OffCutters]

@McLovin- He is a little girl with short blonde hair.