Review Playtest Review/Preview(Review Links, Updated in First Post)

I'm loving the sound of this game.


Is there going to be a career mode? And how are statistics handled in this game? Are they mentioned at all, do they update themselves with the more you play, are they editable, etc.
 
Great post Dean. It seems myself, Dean, LC and Kamy are pretty much on the same page with the game after having a play of it, which I guess is really promising to the other members on the forum who are looking to purchase the game.
 
Yeah good question mate. Both of you have to run individually, which makes it fun and interesting, so like in real life you have to say "yes" "no" or waiting. It was also funny because me and angry both got run out because we didn't press the button,lol.

Thats a relief. My pal always got me runout when he was batting since he was the one who was incharge of the running when batting.

I really can't wait for the release. Please please please be in July.
 
Anyway here goes my indepth review/recollection:

Walking into Transmission Games was quite exciting. I'll admit, after their last few AFL games, I was very pessimistic about their ability to develop a good sports game, but as I soon found out, bigger budgets are helpful. Meeting a few guys from the forum was quite strange, especially WHM who is a lot less intimidating in real life than in red ;).

The four of us (myself, WHM, stevo and angryangy) started off in the same room listening to Heath and Rob speak about the game and show us around a little. I was the first to try it out, as Australia batting in the Ashes. We all started off on normal (there are three difficulties - easy, normal and hard), which Heath called the more balanced one. Hard is more of a simulation he said, and easy is just "pick up and slog". The batting controls were pretty much the same as the old ones, except for the manual foot selection (automatic, but you can go manual at any time and press both to advance down the wicket, but if you miss the ball remember to get back in your crease!). The good thing about controls for both batting and bowling is that they show up on the screen, with little graphics of what they each do as well as text.

The first thing I noticed was that even on normal, it's much harder than BLIC07 at its hardest. Timing is crucial, and what I thought was good timing ended up being much too slow. Reaction time, like real cricket, is very short, and that adds to the challenge. The better the ball is, the quicker your time to hit the ball is, and if it's a poor ball, you get more time to hit it sweetly. If you hit it too late or early, you get an edge, but these edges are more realistic - they don't all go straight to keeper or slips cordon, they are much thinner and usually go straight down, unless your timing is terrible. Unlike in previous games, terrible ones aren't the most difficult to play - you genuinely feel the difference. WHM even tried bowling Andrew Strauss to see if terrible medium pacers were still surprisingly good, and I smashed him to all corners, really feeling the difference.

We split up after a little bit to try out co-op. I played against WHM in a Twenty20 (Australia v England, fully licensed) and quickly learnt that he was pretty awful at it. I bowled first and dismissed him for about 39 (he blamed it on being England), which I chased down in about 5 or so overs. This gave me my first taste of bowling as well. Bowling is a major improvement in the game from BLIC07. No longer is it just send the ball down ball after ball and wait for a mistake to come. There are two parts to bowling a good delivery - the first is landing the ball on a colour co-ordinated area of the pitch that is considered good for the type of delivery, and then you had to also make sure the power meter was in the good zone. Too early, and the ball is poorly delivered, too late and it's a no ball. Certainly against Matt, the only thing I needed to do was aim for the stumps and watch him miss.

The other thing is the range of deliveries. Rather than choosing swing in mid-air, there are two "menus" of deliveries - swing, seam and reverse swing (which doesn't work until the ball is old enough). In each there is your standard delivery, your two movement balls and the slower ball. Unfortunately Australia's lack of spinners in the team meant I didn't get to explore much of the spinners - I only bowled one over of Michael Clarke and he wasn't too good obviously. Also, for each delivery you can see a quick summary of what it does, and how fast it can be for a particular bowler.

Bowler speeds are more realistic than previous games too, not necessarily in the realism from bowler to bowler, which is good but a little off sometimes, but there's less of the old BLIC 90km/h deliveries from a pace bowler if you press it too early. You'll get decent speeds for most normal balls, although the slower ball did seem too slow at one stage (Harmison gave me one at 105 km/h).

Running between the wickets now features sliding in and diving, and third umpire referrals are much more exciting. Action replays too are great, a good mix between slow motion when the ball comes off the bat and speeding up as it goes into the crowd.

The stadiums are also incredible. We played in Melbourne, which is incredibly authentic, and then we played in Karachi and really felt, saw and heard the difference. There is background music from the crowd, posters around the ground (hit it to me, Go Aussies etc) and the ground surfaces are fantastic - Karachi's was very worn, much less green than Melbourne's. Karachi also had these army guys standing on the boundary. The crowd is not perfect but better than most sports games too, so it looks good. The electronic scoreboards even work! The pitches were also quite good - Cardiff on day 3 showed a lot of cracks.

Ball and bat physics look a lot better than in the videos and screenshots, the ball comes off a lot more nicely. WHM said that when he last played it it was a lot like BLIC07 but now it's its own game for sure.

I'm sure I've missed plenty but I'll leave it there for now. Any questions or queries, happy to answer them. As I said before, I'm very optimistic about this game after playing it, and it will definitely be the best cricket game so far, by far.

thanks for the great review.though some input on the spinners would have been great.I hope they are not spinning the ball 10xMurali as in BLIC 2007.;)
 
great review mate,thanks to all testers and thanks to codies and transmission games for making such a good cricket game,after 1999:clap
 
Last edited:
Is it possible to move the batsman around the crease after you have seen where the ball will pitch?

In test matches is each session timed ie 2 hours a session or is it fixed at 30 overs a session?

Last question is do you see the ball land in the crowd when u hit a six? i havnt played 07 so i dont know if its been fixed from 05.

Both of these need to be in the game.

Yes all of those graphs are present. Don't think there is instant replay.

Do they appear as popups, or are they hidden away in a menu?


That's exactly it. It just felt like cricket.

There are some bits in AC2009 that do 'just feel like cricket' and it's really satisfying.

That's great news! This is shaping up to be a good summer: the long wait for a decent cricket game looks to be drawing to a close and even Fifa 10 PC looks to be shaping up well!

Being able to defend the ball in certain directions is pretty huge. It's such an integral part of cricket - pushing the ball into the gap or dropping it short of cover and running through for the quick single. Not only does it keep the scoreboard ticking over, it's a handy way to get off the mark!

So you can just drop the ball and take quick singles.

That's the part I am mostly interested in, i.e in AI. I hardly play against real ppl so for me to have the AI playing good solid would be of the main concern. I think this is exactly where BLIC2007 failed. I would have rated the game highly if it wasn't for the AI.

Agreed. I have heard a lot about how good it is v another person, but what about against the AI, both batting and bowling? Also, has work been done on making it less easy to get wickets with spinners?
 
Did any of you try the sweep shots, and also flicking the ball through mid wicket from outside off stump?

And also, did you find that every third ball or so, you'd see something cool (like a fumble, a realistic overthrow, a new animation, etc.) and be all impressed and stuff? That's certainly what happened when I was playing it - I just kept seeing new cool stuff and being like "ah, did you see that?"

Actually I've thought of a few more as I'm writing this:
- edges going short of slips
- thinking you'd hit a good shot so pressing run, then seeing a fielder about to probably run you out, but he fumbles the pick-up slightly and you're safe
- ball swinging after it's gone past the bat (first time this has been in any game, I think).
- wicket-keeper running me out when I'd dropped the ball short on the leg side trying to pinch a single.
 
great review mate,thanks to all testers and thanks to codies for making such a good cricket game,after 1999:clap

The wait looks to be over. I can't wait to get my hooks on a demo!

Thats a relief. My pal always got me runout when he was batting since he was the one who was incharge of the running when batting.

I really can't wait for the release. Please please please be in July.

That's going to make playing with a friend super, super fun!

I'm loving the sound of this game.


Is there going to be a career mode? And how are statistics handled in this game? Are they mentioned at all, do they update themselves with the more you play, are they editable, etc.

EA, are you worried yet?

MasterBlaster76 added 0 Minutes and 58 Seconds later...

Did any of you try the sweep shots, and also flicking the ball through mid wicket from outside off stump?

And also, did you find that every third ball or so, you'd see something cool (like a fumble, a realistic overthrow, a new animation, etc.) and be all impressed and stuff? That's certainly what happened when I was playing it - I just kept seeing new cool stuff and being like "ah, did you see that?"

Actually I've thought of a few more as I'm writing this:
- edges going short of slips
- thinking you'd hit a good shot so pressing run, then seeing a fielder about to probably run you out, but he fumbles the pick-up slightly and you're safe
- ball swinging after it's gone past the bat (first time this has been in any game, I think).
- wicket-keeper running me out when I'd dropped the ball short on the leg side trying to pinch a single.

Have they included the cheeky 'lap shot' that everyone was trying in the Twenty/20?

And I hope the tests can now actually go on for five days. You wouldn't have had enough time to tell us if that's the case, but are there options to maybe change how many overs are bowled in a day? That would solve that little problem.

MasterBlaster76 added 3 Minutes and 22 Seconds later...

Did any of you try the sweep shots, and also flicking the ball through mid wicket from outside off stump?

And also, did you find that every third ball or so, you'd see something cool (like a fumble, a realistic overthrow, a new animation, etc.) and be all impressed and stuff? That's certainly what happened when I was playing it - I just kept seeing new cool stuff and being like "ah, did you see that?"

Actually I've thought of a few more as I'm writing this:
- edges going short of slips
- thinking you'd hit a good shot so pressing run, then seeing a fielder about to probably run you out, but he fumbles the pick-up slightly and you're safe
- ball swinging after it's gone past the bat (first time this has been in any game, I think).
- wicket-keeper running me out when I'd dropped the ball short on the leg side trying to pinch a single.

It sounds as though 'attention to detail' has been the team's watchword or motto this time round...
 
Last edited:
Sorry if this has been asked before but will the stats of the players get updated match by match??....and all the reviews were good....thanks for the reviews guys....i hope the game is as good as its looking like from all the reviews and if they have got stats update match by match then this COULD MAY WELL BE THE BEST CRICKET GAME SO FAR...
 
I have a question for they guys who played AC 2009

You say you have to bowl in the ?good area? to pick up wickets but what I want to know is can you pick up wickets from bad deliveries? For example bowling a half volley outside off stump and the batsman hitting the ball straight to cover or cover points throat or the ball is bowled down the leg side but the batsman gets a faint edge and the ball goes to the keepers glove, as we see in real cricket.

Have any of you guys experienced this in the game?
 
I'd say "Is TAOC worried?" LM has been trying for so long to create a gun cricket game and now it looks like we're very close to getting what we want in a cricket game and all his hard work may go to waste.

I'd forgotten about that. It would truly be a shame if his hard work was wasted. :(

MasterBlaster76 added 0 Minutes and 33 Seconds later...

I have a question for they guys who played AC 2009

You say you have to bowl in the ?good area? to pick up wickets but what I want to know is can you pick up wickets from bad deliveries? For example bowling a half volley outside off stump and the batsman hitting the ball straight to cover or cover points throat or the ball is bowled down the leg side but the batsman gets a faint edge and the ball goes to the keepers glove, as we see in real cricket.

Have any of you guys experienced this in the game?

I've seen that happen in lots of cricket games.
 
:hpraise
Did any of you try the sweep shots, and also flicking the ball through mid wicket from outside off stump?

And also, did you find that every third ball or so, you'd see something cool (like a fumble, a realistic overthrow, a new animation, etc.) and be all impressed and stuff? That's certainly what happened when I was playing it - I just kept seeing new cool stuff and being like "ah, did you see that?"

Actually I've thought of a few more as I'm writing this:
- edges going short of slips
- thinking you'd hit a good shot so pressing run, then seeing a fielder about to probably run you out, but he fumbles the pick-up slightly and you're safe
- ball swinging after it's gone past the bat (first time this has been in any game, I think).
- wicket-keeper running me out when I'd dropped the ball short on the leg side trying to pinch a single.
:hpraise super cool
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top