Yep, discovered the fielding catching was up by process of elimination. I'm not sure, but think there have been a couple of times I've arrived at the circle for a really high skied catch and held up right away and due to the ball coming down some time later my player dropped it. Or it's that I started holding it down before I touched the circle. I'm unsure.
Probably best that people experiment and see if you must wait until you're touching the circle before pushing up, or if you have to be careful not to have it down too long for skied catches whilst in the circle.
The only way to test that is with really high ones, but yeah I'm catching 95% of my outfield catches and about 20% of my close in ones.
As for caught and bowled, it is really hard, maybe it'll get easier. To make it a little easier, maybe if a bowler has really high catching stats and it's hit directly back at you and you didn't push up fast enough, that sometimes it'll get batted up, like we do see sometimes with real life caught and bowleds and there's a little bit more time to push the right stick up again?
Just a suggestion.