Not great, I grant you - he averages just under 38 with the ball in Shield cricket (and just over 30 in the recently concluded season) compared with Fawad's 28 (and 25 last season). On those grounds, Fawad is the logical pick. If Lyon was unfit, then it would make sense to look at Fawad as more of a strike bowler.Doesn't Agar have an abysmal First Class average? Like I know it's Bangladesh and average spinners can do well but I'm sure sure that Agar is international quality as a pure bowler.
I'd stick with Fawad Ahmed but that's because I'm a sicker for leg spin
But, as Agar is the second spinner, I think his batting and fielding give him an edge over Fawad, as does the fact that he's 15 years younger than Fawad, who is a 36-year-old pretending to be 33 in the hope it lengthens his cricket career.