End Game Contract Killer Mafia II - Contract Killer has Performed his Kill!!

[RUDI]

Something consider here:

After reading Villains post were he played the VIP it became clear that the bodyguards didn't involve him in the game, no lynches, no questioning him or anything.

Guys please be more proactive, silly games like I am the killer is just frustrating the rest of us into thinking you are not for us, but against us.

Let's put some thought into our posts, questions should be ask in a way to try and catch the killer out. Secret codes can only work if we were allowed to communicate via PM'es. So please let's drop this idea as its just going to sow confusion and us lynching our own.
Try and narrow down your aliances by POE (process of elimination)

So far I can say Villain and Cereal Killer are likely real bodyguards. Villain giving helpful info on how to catch the killer and CerealKiller (most active poster in game so far) is actively try to push around to do his own POE.

Players I am not to trusting about are asprin, AliB, Master Bates and Ashutosh. Yash should post more in order to analyse if he is for us or trying to kill the VIP.

@PresidentEvil , can we have regular updates on the lynch Tally's please. I would hate for us to hammer one of our own due to insufficient updates.

 

[CerealKiller]

Villain giving helpful info on how to catch the killer

Which can be a very good ruse, if he is the Killer.
My reads so far
@Villain - could be either way, for aforementioned reasons
@RUDI - only a couple of meaningful posts, excluding RVS posts, but so far looks genuinely as if he’s trying to hunt the Killer, although the part about the last game was mentioned a thousand times already, so could be a way to look like helping Town, coupled with call for more posts? Although I concur on the latter
@AliB - looks Bodyguard to me, put in a good effort, even if his idea wasn’t that effective
@asprin - either general analytical posts, which honestly anyone can make, or reacting to other posts. No active scum hunting. This can look like the approach of the Killer waiting for clues to appear
@Yash. - not much to judge him on, but he twice says something like "there’s not much discussion, don’t know how to take the game forward", but he doesn’t really try to generate discussion or take the game forward himself, but his response to AliB’s code proposal does give Town-ish vibes
@Master Bates - really dude? What is claiming Killer gonna accomplish other than completely confusing the Town? Don’t think you’re stupid enough to actually be the Killer though
@Ashutosh. - buddy, you just need to post more[DOUBLEPOST=1586305627][/DOUBLEPOST]@Villain

 

[Targaryen]

Lynch Count:

AliB - Master Bates
asprin - Yash
CerealKiller - Ashutosh
asprin - Yash
Master Bates - AliB
Ashutosh - Rudi, CerealKiller

With 8 alive, it takes 5 votes to reach the majority.

@CerealKiller @Master Bates @AliB @asprin @Yash. @Ashutosh. @RUDI @Villain

 

[Yash.]

I don’t know why, but @Ashutosh. just seems really fishy at this moment. The way he posted about the game mechanics of the last game, even after @Villain posted it earlier, and also, after everyone in the game getting a lynch, just doesn’t seem right.

Unlynch
Lynch Ashtuosh.

 

[Villain]

If that demotivates the town (is it really that easy?), then god help the VIP

I mean your post is in no way helping the town, you also missed my question about how should we go forward in the game.

Then I don't see anything here. Are we just supposed post meaningless posts?

I am going to try and make this interesting (might result in getting me lynched but I won't be bored)
I am making a claim that I'm the killer and I am going to kill @AliB if I die!

I don’t know why would a VIP/bodyguard claim that, “might result in getting me lynched” this will only make it easier for the Killer. I have least expectations of you being town now. I know it got a bit frustrating but don’t really think any townie would take the step.

Lynch: Master Bates

 

[asprin]

I mean your post is in no way helping the town, you also missed my question about how should we go forward in the game

I think it's pretty obvious that the only way forward is to have people keep posting. Given that we cannnot have consecutive no-lynch days, it becomes imperative that we have as much discussion as possible.

As far as reads go, I'm leaning town towards CK and Rudi. The others, I'm not quite sure yet.

But Ashutosh looks the most vulnerable at the moment.

 

[Ashutosh.]

Pointing out game mechanic stuff that someone else already mentioned, and no other contribution so far

What else do you want? I didn't know how to start discussion in this game. Yash has been more inactive than me but still you lynched me. Why? Yash took advantage of this and lynched me which made him suspicious.

FOS : Yash.

 

[Yash.]

Yash has been more inactive than me but still you lynched me

I have posted 6 times since the game started, while you only did thrice, with 2 of them being RVS stuff. How come that makes me more inactive than you?

Answer the question, why you posted about game mechanics and all, when Villain had already posted the same, and all the people had been lynched

 

[Ashutosh.]

I have posted 6 times since the game started, while you only did thrice, with 2 of them being RVS stuff. How come that makes me more inactive than you?

@Yash. watching the thread but not posting?

Answer the question, why you posted about game mechanics and all, when Villain had already posted the same, and all the people had been lynched

I saw posts of Contract Killer I and thought to aware the bodyguards not to repeat the same mistake.

 

[CerealKiller]

@Yash. - not much to judge him on, but he twice says something like "there’s not much discussion, don’t know how to take the game forward", but he doesn’t really try to generate discussion or take the game forward himself, but his response to AliB’s code proposal does give Town-ish vibes

@Yash. any response?

@asprin - either general analytical posts, which honestly anyone can make, or reacting to other posts. No active scum hunting. This can look like the approach of the Killer waiting for clues to appear

@asprin

What else do you want? I didn't know how to start discussion in this game. Yash has been more inactive than me but still you lynched me. Why? Yash took advantage of this and lynched me which made him suspicious.

FOS : Yash.

I’ve questioned Yash as well, but you just posted about the mechanics and nothing else at that point. Any reads on anyone?

 

[Master Bates]

I mean your post is in no way helping the town, you also missed my question about how should we go forward in the game.

I don’t know why would a VIP/bodyguard claim that, “might result in getting me lynched” this will only make it easier for the Killer. I have least expectations of you being town now. I know it got a bit frustrating but don’t really think any townie would take the step.

Lynch: Master Bates

Do you think if I was the killer, I would claim so and get me killed on first day itself? Many people do understand that what I did was silly but I was doing everything pro-town. Maybe you are the killer and have realised that I was lying and you feel I am either the VIP/bodyguard so there is nothing at loss here for you to lynch me and will only harming the Town in terms of members.

FOS: Villain
Unlynch AliB

 

[Villain]

Do you think if I was the killer, I would claim so and get me killed on first day itself? Many people do understand that what I did was silly but I was doing everything pro-town. Maybe you are the killer and have realised that I was lying and you feel I am either the VIP/bodyguard so there is nothing at loss here for you to lynch me and will only harming the Town in terms of members.

FOS: Villain
Unlynch AliB

I saw no post of you explaining what and why you did that neither did you accept you were bluffing. Do you have any explanation about why you did that? You were bored is what are you saying? The line that got me lynch you was “I don’t mind getting lynched.” You cannot have any explanation for it, in no way it can help the town.

 

[RUDI]

Unlynch
Lynch: Master Bates

Do you think if I was the killer, I would claim so and get me killed on first day itself? Many people do understand that what I did was silly but I was doing everything pro-town. Maybe you are the killer and have realised that I was lying and you feel I am either the VIP/bodyguard so there is nothing at loss here for you to lynch me and will only harming the Town in terms of members.

Terrible defense on making a silly mistake. Not helping us at all!

 

[Yash.]

Yash. - not much to judge him on, but he twice says something like "there’s not much discussion, don’t know how to take the game forward", but he doesn’t really try to generate discussion or take the game forward himself, but his response to AliB’s code proposal does give Town-ish vibes

I posted that because I didn't get a clue what to post by that time.

 

[Yash.]

Do you think if I was the killer, I would claim so and get me killed on first day itself? Many people do understand that what I did was silly but I was doing everything pro-town. Maybe you are the killer and have realised that I was lying and you feel I am either the VIP/bodyguard so there is nothing at loss here for you to lynch me and will only harming the Town in terms of members.

FOS: Villain
Unlynch AliB

This behaviour does seem a little fishy to me now. At that time, I thought you were joking, but by your defenses, you look a little weird