aussie1st said:Hehe more umpiring luck for the Aussies in particular Hayden. Obviously if Rudi wasn't giving the first one no way he would have given the 2nd one.
Yeah it looked tough to get an LBW yesterday. I counted 6 that could have been given: only Clark to Bell was given.
Of those other 5, 3 of them were definitely out (going off Hawkeye) - Hoggard to Hayden twice, and Symonds got Collingwood on the back pad - I think they were all Rudi's decisions. Hayden obviously has gotten into Rudi's head that he is batting outside his crease and that seemingly any shout is useless.
The other 2 for those interested: Strauss had one from Lee that Hawkeye thought may have hit the very top of leg, and Collingwood had one from Clark which Hawkeye said would have hit the very top of middle. I didn't mind those being not out, as it's a low scoring game.
Also, the 50 by Strauss was a real battle. It's not often that a guy has to fight all the way to 50, but he never really looked in - despite a couple of nice shots. It was nearly an ugly innings. Not sure if he can blame the pitch for that, he just seems very out of sorts at present.