....I’ve already agreed with your point about Malan deserving a game given that he has previous international experience and has been much better in English conditions at the moment. Not sure why you have quoted my erroneous response again.
As for Marnus, I was initially against him being picked purely on the basis of second division stats but he has proven me wrong and shown that there is a quality player in there after all who was aided by the county experience. The point is that county stats aren’t a true indicator of a player’s ability at all times, Pujara for example couldn’t buy a run last year in county cricket while he was decent in England and the star in Australia later. Similarly, Bancroft was good in the same second division and yet was very poor with the bat in the Ashes.