Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

Which is your favourite book in the series?

  • The Philosopher's Stone

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • The Chamber of Secrets

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    17
we did not hear much about peter pettigrew aka wormtail did we?
snape shoves him off in spinner's end when he has visitors.

i think DD's death was well planned out by him and snape and snape might have also made an unbreakable vow to DD with pettigrew's witness.

by the way barmyarmy...i dont think harry's scar is a horcrux...it could have been DUMBELDORE'S london underground scar..
is it not possible ..maybe thats why he was finished off by snape?
thats why DD pleaded for his death.

and also when harry calls snape a coward,snape's face turns as if he was a mad dog.
so DD definately asked snape to finish him off.

anyhowe is aberforth dumbeldore a squib(he was punished for practising inappropiate charms on a goat) or is he the barman at the Hog's head.didnt see him at the funeral of his brother though.and he's not dead is he?
 
Colin,can you please post the links to some of those forums?

sachin said:
It does look like snape really hated dd when he kills him,so that puts alot of doubt in my mind,plus the when he and Narcissa make the unbreakable Vow.hat doesn't make him look great either.

Exactly.And after I re-read that chapter,I'm starting to think that Snape has indeed joined Voldemort...because Dumbledore just can't be pleading for his death...its just silly...

Ofcourse,JK might be fooling us all...
 
OI!Go to school!Thats where your meant to be right?lol
Theres alot of information on mugglenet, and it's official forums ''COS forums'.They actually have a thread on cricket,most of my posts are on it!I do think there is a big possibilty that snape and dd did set it up,but with all the trickery that JK spins inher novels,it's hard to tell.
 
DD might even be asking for snape to help him out.
it is snape who knows that dd has destroyed the ring as the horcrux coz he helps DD after DD destroys the horcrux...if snape was indeed on the death eaters side he wud have told bellatrix and narcissa that DD has destroyed one of the horcruxes of lord voldemort instead he said that DD sustained the injury to his hand during the fight in the ministry.

snape has something in him that would eventually end the series.i know its silly for Dumbeldore to plead for his death but he must know something.
JKR has mentioned that the last word of book seven is scar(maybe dumbeldore's)
anyhow ,really looking forth to book seven,maybe Sirius is still out there.
 
You know he isn't mate,so just give it up.It will be something about how wonderful the scar is( the last few sentences of the seventh book).You do make a good point about how doesn't tell Bllatrix about dd's hand.But when did he actuall get the blackend hand?
 
we know that he got the black hand during the holidays for sure..

one more thing,who owns Grimmauld Place now?
Cause one of the horcruxes is in there...the locket which none of them could open.

With Dumbeldore dead,will Snape tell Voldemort where the HQ of the order were?
 
The house is harry's,haven't you read the book!It goes into a fair amount of detail to prove it is harry's house.And why have you suddnely gone cold on snape?i THOUGH YOU SAID HE WAS DONE WITH VOLDIE AND KILLED DD,BECAUSE HE HAS A HORCRUX INSIDE HIM.Can't be bothered rewriting it,sorry!
 
sachin said:
OI!Go to school!Thats where your meant to be right?lol
Theres alot of information on mugglenet, and it's official forums ''COS forums'.They actually have a thread on cricket,most of my posts are on it!I do think there is a big possibilty that snape and dd did set it up,but with all the trickery that JK spins inher novels,it's hard to tell.

OI!Shut up!And stop dissing me every post! lol


I finished re-reading it,and now I'm sure that Snape has joined Voldemort.I don't believe that he and DD set it up.

And regarding the Horcrux in Grimmauld Place....this is interesting,because if RAB is indeed Regulus Black,then he must have hidden the Horcrux there,right?But he must've been killed before he could destroy it.

Also,how did RAB manage to get the horcrux single-handedly?Even DD wasn't able to do it..

Finally,I wanna know how the hell Harry is going to find 4 Horcruxes AND kill Voldemort,in a single book?;)

Assuming he will indeed kill Voldemort in the end.........

iceman_waugh said:
With Dumbeldore dead,will Snape tell Voldemort where the HQ of the order were?

He probably will,but I think the HQ has moved,so it wouldn't make much of a difference.
 
Last edited:
barmyarmy said:
The one I use is Potterskeys.com. I find COS too big.
You want to be known,huh? :rolleyes:

gold639 said:
OI!Shut up!And stop dissing me every post! lol
Don't worry Gold,i'll only diss you when,you oppose me in an argument!lol

I finished re-reading it,and now I'm sure that Snape has joined Voldemort.I don't believe that he and DD set it up.
I've only read it once,but when i had just finished it,i was quiet sure that Snape had changed sides,but with a little convincing by Iceman,i'ver changed my tune a bit.

And regarding the Horcrux in Grimmauld Place....this is interesting,because if RAB is indeed Regulus Black,then he must have hidden the Horcrux there,right?But he must've been killed before he could destroy it.
I'm not sure if JK would make the person wwho stole the Horcrux so obvious.It would be someone a fair bit more powerful than Regulas Black,who wasn't even killed by Voldie!

Also,how did RAB manage to get the horcrux single-handedly?Even DD wasn't able to do it.
Maybe there's some different sort of magic that will open the cave door mor easily,and because dd was getting older,he didn't see it.But then again,if the greatest wizard of all time can't find it,who can.

Finally,I wanna know how the hell Harry is going to find 4 Horcruxes AND kill Voldemort,in a single book?;)
He'll have his friends,and i think he''l have some help,from other people,that might not be an obvious friend to harry.Plus some much needed luck,which he hasn't had,in it''s true form(Felix felicis),for a long time.

He probably will,but I think the HQ has moved,so it wouldn't make much of a difference.He may have made an unbreakable Vow with DD,so that he couldn't tell the whearabouts of the HQs.Maybe he made an UBV with DD on other things,and thats why DD trusts him mso.


Assuming he will indeed kill Voldemort in the end.........
People would be ****ed if Volide won,so that wouldn't be the best way to go.

barmyarmy said:
I also recommend reading this if you want a laugh...
These guys are taking it a bit to far!They do come up with some Plausible examples/ideas,but in the end,how many of these sort of things have been right?
 
Last edited:
I feel that snape might just be the one who will end up killing voldemort.....
you never know

snape is a very powerful wizard as we have seen in book six.He is also Half blood.so , .so....on..
 
barmyarmy said:
That or I don't have time to read every post on CoS.
Knowone read every post on COS!You just read the ones you need to,or the most important/funny/interesting ones.I'm a second year now,hopefully not to long before i move up to third year. :)

iceman_waugh said:
I feel that snape might just be the one who will end up killing voldemort.....
you never know

snape is a very powerful wizard as we have seen in book six.He is also Half blood.so , .so....on..
In the Prophecy,i can't remember it saying that harry has to kill him,it just says something about them not being able to live together. :cheers <like these two ;)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top