Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

[Bala]

Ok! here are my guesses.



If R.A.B is indeed Regulus Black, he might have taken Kreacher along to the cave and since Kreacher isnt a wizard would have fitted in the boat along with Regulus. He might have also made kreacher drink the potion, which kreacher would have done most willingly as Regulus was acting like a pure blood should do. Only when Kreacher comes to know that Regulas is anti U No Poo, he betarys him to either the Malfoys or the Lestranges, leading to his Murder.

One more little suspicion. JKR has this uncanny knack of building up characters which little detail have been given (or no details) in the previous books. eg., Rufus Scrimgeour (Pathetic portrayal of the Minister of Magic, BTW). So why cant R.A.B be the Amy Benson girl, who Tom Marvolo Riddle lured into the caves and was said to not be the same after. Is R.A.B really R(?) A(my) B(enson)?


Also, I seriously believe that Dumbledore was a Horcrux.

Either I am on the right track or I might be rivalling The Gas for the humourest posts next for year awards

 

[icyman]

Seriously Bala i do believe you.
Dumbeldore was indeed a horcrux and R.A.B may be Reverend Amy Benson.,,,jus jokin though...coz it cant be her ..we have no idea who it is.
But your predictions regarding Regulus Black may be true.Like him taking Kreacher along and etc.
I also believe that R.A.B might have destroyed the remaining Horcruxes as well.He might have hidden them in Grimmauld Place.

i reckon that That place must be checked thoroughly.And yeah harry can ask Kreacher also regarding certain objects in the house as he is his master now.

 

[barmyarmy]

My favourite theory atm is that Harry's scar is the final horcrux. Created accidentally by Voldemort when he tried to kill Harry. This would certainly explain both why Harry has some of Voldemort's powers and can see inside his thoughts. It would also mean that Harry will have to die in order to defeat Voldemort.

 

[barmyarmy]

JKR interview post HBP

 

[Bala]

My favourite theory atm is that Harry's scar is the final horcrux. Created accidentally by Voldemort when he tried to kill Harry. This would certainly explain both why Harry has some of Voldemort's powers and can see inside his thoughts. It would also mean that Harry will have to die in order to defeat Voldemort.

No way! It would become like a silly hollywood flick. Also, if Harry was indeed the Horcrux, why did Volemort use the Killing Curse on him during their duel in GOF?

My other curiosities revolve around the vanishings of Florean Fortescue (Who knew a lot about ancient history of wizards, POA) and Ollivander the wand maker (he left no trace, all the more reasons to be suspicious). They are still alive as per HBP.

 

[sachin]

If all the Horcuxes were already destroyed then it would be a seriously short book,and not very fulfilling.I think that JK has to make this a very long book,so we can saver the last of harry potter.I'm pretty sure it will be long because she'll have to tie up any loose ends.

The JK interview with the Leaky Cauldron and Mugglenet,are very well done and we must send out are congratulations to Emerson and Melissa.It would have been really awesome to be them.

EDIT:Incidentally,Daniel Radcliff(Guy who plays HP in the movies) has bought a home in Toorak.Got swamped by fans after going out for dinner,when the new book has just been released!You idiot!Go out when there aren't to many Potter freaks around!!!

 

[icyman]

I read the interview and have come to the conclusion that the sorting hat is a horcrux ...anyone agrre with me ?

 

[sachin]

No.I hate Harmony shippers!They are so delusional!"Where not going to read it any more,it's to shallow!I've known it all along!Why was hermione replaced so suddenly by Ginny!It not fair!!"
Sad FVCKS!!!!!!
Anybody reckon,JK is awesome!I do!I do!I do!

 

[carl johnson]

but i have to accept that the books are awesome

 

[icyman]

Anybody reckon,JK is awesome!I do!I do!I do!

Forget the shippers buddy.
but,
Yeah, i agree with you.

JKR is awesome.

 

[sachin]

Thanks for agreeing with me,knew you would!I think we should have a contest to see who can come up with the best harry potter related slogan,the one that works best.You could improve yours Iceman.Even though mine isn't harry potter related,it just fits perfect with prety much everything.Ive decided to read the books again.

 

[sachin]

I've started to read he book again,and noticed at the end of chapter wo 'Spinners End',Snape saying he knew what the 'Plan' was,when we already know(if you've read the bok),that he didn't.Why was he lying?Why didn't the Dark Lord tell him if he was a trusted advisor?When Narcissa Malfoy is ending the Inbreakable Vow with:
"And should it prove necessary.......if it seems that Draco will fail...."Whispered Narcissa (Snape's hand twitched within hers,but did not draw away),"will you carry out the deed that the dark lord has ordered Draco to perform?"
Why does snape feel uncomfortable?He doesn't know what this means he has to do,and if you cast your mind back to the middle of the book(Slughorns christmas party),you will remember Snape asking Malfoy what he has to do,and how he could help.He seems urgent,and who wuldn't when in a situation like that.If he did find out what the whole plan was,he would be able to figure out an action,that would make it easier on him and on Draco.

Lets just say that Snape is still DD's man,if he knew what the plan was he could have told DD what he had commited too,and together,they could have masterminded a action in which DD has to die. I can see DD giving his life away,he isn't as good as he used to be,and Snape's mission is much more important than DD's life-Remember that DD said something like this "Death is only another journey"(I can't rmember it exactly),so it is possible that Snape is still DD's man.And at the end of the book when he tells the DE's to leave Harry to the Dark Lord,we know that the Dark Lord just wants Harry dead,and it has never come up that Voldie has to be the one to kill him.Of course he'd prefer to kill him himself,but if Harry was killed by Snape or Bellatrix,then he'd just be happy.Maybe he'd regret not getting the chance to kill him,but when you've got rid of somebody that important,then it doesn't really matter who kills him.
Snape doesn't know the True Prophecy,right?So, it would be a hard thing to kill someone who you think is your only chance of getting rid of Voldie.But then again,maybe DD has told him,and Snape understands that even if DD dies,it won't be that big a deal,as it would be if the Prophecy weren't true.Maybe DD trusts Snape because he's told him the true Prophecy,and he knows that he hasn't told Voldie.

I think there are some very good arguments for Snape being DD's man,and i hope that he is.But then again,there is the simple evidence that he did kill him,and he seemed to only have hate for DD when he commited the deed.

Its all rather confusing,and a bit depressing.
The last book isn't even going to be as long as OOTP!What a pity,think of all the possibilities,that could open up with a book where Harry isn't at school.Pity she's not going to take advantage of it.
One thing i hope doesn't happen in the last:
It doesn't turn it to some lame morally charged soapie,with everyone crying,and dieing,and coming back to life from a spell that we never knew existed......Voldie turns out to be good,and the ministry has been leading everyone along,and they are the ones who killed harry's family!Please nothing like this, and i'll be happy!
Thank you for your time-
DRE

 

[gold639]

Good post mate,you've got some good points there.

The last book isn't even going to be as long as OOTP!

Where does it say that?

 

[sachin]

Good post mate,you've got some good points there.

I knowI want REPS!

Where does it say that?

THERE YOU GO!Where are my reps!

In the Interviews she's done with The Leaky Cauldron,and Mugglenet.But she doesn't seem to think that Snape is a good guy in disguise,ruins all my points
LINKS:
www.mugglenet.com/jkrinterview.shtml -Part one!

www.mugglenet.com/jkrinterview2.shtml -Part two!

www.mugglenet.com/jkrinterview3.shtml -Part three!

 

[gold639]

I knowI want REPS!

Remove that line from my quote and I might give you some..

My favourite theory atm is that Harry's scar is the final horcrux. Created accidentally by Voldemort when he tried to kill Harry. This would certainly explain both why Harry has some of Voldemort's powers and can see inside his thoughts. It would also mean that Harry will have to die in order to defeat Voldemort.

I don't really like this theory.A Horcrux is very dark magic,and I'm sure it would be impossible to create accidentally.