Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

[gold639]

or maybe they switched their bodies...
that would explain dd screaming "kill me kill me" when he drank the potion in the basin and he also screamed "dont punish them punish me instead"
Is this snape ?

Don't know about this...it seems like a real far-fetched one, but anything is possible..

And does anyone else think Zacharias Smith is related to Hepzibah Smith?

 

[sachin]

Very possible.I've nearly got through reading the series again,and i'm coming to the conclusion that snape isn't really bad(well,you know).There just seems to be alot of things that don't add up to him being truly bad.

 

[ronny_kingsley]

And here we have six missing Death Eaters . . . three dead in my service. One,
too cowardly to return ... he will pay. One, who I believe has left me forever ... he will be
killed, of course . . . and one, who remains my most faithful servant, and who has already
reentered my service.

In "GOBLET OF FIRE" Voldemort said this.

Who are the first two he is talking about because we know that his servant was Barty Crouch Jr. impostering as Mad Eye Moody ???????

Can someone plz elaborate on this. for me

 

[gold639]

The coward is Igor Karkaroff, headmaster of Durmstrang. The one who has left him forever is Snape. However, Voldemort forgave Snape, as he returned one hour after Voldemort said that. Snape returned an hour later so that DD would not be suspicious, and also Voldemort would still have links inside Hogwarts.

 

[icyman]

Snape returned an hour later so that DD would not be suspicious, and also Voldemort would still have links inside Hogwarts.

I believe Dumbeldore told him to return.
if you read the end of the book 4 you'll find that DD says "Severus,if you are ready,you must know what to do. "


Also Zacharias smith theory seems a certainity.Maybe it may show why he's so much bragging about things and all.

 

[sachin]

The coward is Igor Karkaroff, headmaster of Durmstrang. The one who has left him forever is Snape. However, Voldemort forgave Snape, as he returned one hour after Voldemort said that. Snape returned an hour later so that DD would not be suspicious, and also Voldemort would still have links inside Hogwarts.

But i'm sure he was still at Hogwarts an hour later.I'm not convinced he's NOT evil

I believe Dumbeldore told him to return.
if you read the end of the book 4 you'll find that DD says "Severus,if you are ready,you must know what to do. "


Also Zacharias smith theory seems a certainity.Maybe it may show why he's so much bragging about things and all.

He is just a prat,nothing else.

 

[gold639]

I believe Dumbeldore told him to return.
if you read the end of the book 4 you'll find that DD says "Severus,if you are ready,you must know what to do. "

But i'm sure he was still at Hogwarts an hour later.I'm not convinced he's evil

Yes yes, I was just telling him what we KNOW. Snape cleary says in the second chapter of HBP that Voldemort forgave him because he returned an hour later.

Actually, I re-read that chapter, and Snape actually appears TWO hours later, on DD's orders. Here's that section:

'But you didn't return when he came back, you didn't fly back to him at once when you felt the Dark Mark burn-'
'Correct. I returned two hours later. I returned on Dumbledore's orders.'
On Dumbledore's-?' she began, in tones of outrage.
'Think!' said Snape, impatient again. 'Think! By waiting two hours, just two hours, I ensured that I could remain at Hogwarts as a Spy! By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord's side because I was ordered to, I have been able to pass information on Dumbledore and the Order of the Phoneix ever since!'

 

[sachin]

Yes yes, I was just telling him what we KNOW. Snape cleary says in the second chapter of HBP that Voldemort forgave him because he returned an hour later.

Actually, I re-read that chapter, and Snape actually appears TWO hours later, on DD's orders. Here's that section:

'But you didn't return when he came back, you didn't fly back to him at once when you felt the Dark Mark burn-'
'Correct. I returned two hours later. I returned on Dumbledore's orders.'
On Dumbledore's-?' she began, in tones of outrage.
'Think!' said Snape, impatient again. 'Think! By waiting two hours, just two hours, I ensured that I could remain at Hogwarts as a Spy! By allowing Dumbledore to think that I was only returning to the Dark Lord's side because I was ordered to, I have been able to pass information on Dumbledore and the Order of the Phoneix ever since!'

All the books leading up to the sixth,give me the impression that he cana't be fooling DD,but when you look at certain bits of the sixth book,you just can't be sure

 

[gold639]

Couldn't agree more

I believe Snape is not really on anyone's side......if that makes any sense!

 

[sachin]

Couldn't agree more

I believe Snape is not really on anyone's side......if that makes any sense!

You think he's made his own side.He doesn't like anybody,he hasn't got any friends,prolly never had a girl.....makes sense,but i doubt thats the way the book will go.It's gonna be a great but very sad moment when the last book comes out

 

[gold639]

Yes, and Rowling has said that he will redeem himself, which makes it almost certain that he is good.

 

[sachin]

Where did she say that?Or when-is probably more correct?

 

[gold639]

Colin posted about this somewhere in this thread I think.

 

[sachin]

And you can't be bothered to check your sources,and tell me....

Hey gold i need a favour.AI won't you to got to COS forums,and tell me if the server is busy.For me it's been like that for over a week.I have no idea whats wrong?Check it for,mate.

 

[gold639]

And you can't be bothered to check your sources,and tell me....

Hey gold i need a favour.AI won't you to got to COS forums,and tell me if the server is busy.For me it's been like that for over a week.I have no idea whats wrong?Check it for,mate.

Its working fine for me, but its horribly slow...