Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[BKB1991]

Lol, thanks for putting it that way Varun, I looked back at the post on Day 2, but the disappearance was said to be just for the sake of the story, nothing related.

I know Matt is silent, but I think I know his character, the only thing I want to know is that whether it was the role that made him act stupid or was he just being himself. Cuz if it was the role it makes sense.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Ok, forget that he vanished. Still, he was immune to a lynch or kill, and Dumbledore is the only townie in that case who could possess that kind of power.

Also, I don't believe there are any individually aligned players. Like, who can be the enemy or HP and Voldemort both? Or anyone who is not concerned with anybody?

Who's to say he is a townie? Just because my investigation said that he's mafia, it doesn't mean the investigation is wrong. A mad cop will always get the result to be mafia, no matter who he investigates, whether they be mafia or townie.

Unlynchable could also be You-Know-Who because of his horcruxes. Individually aligned could include Reeta Skeeter or Umbridge.

 

[BKB1991]

Who's to say he is a townie? Just because my investigation said that he's mafia, it doesn't mean the investigation is wrong. A mad cop will always get the result to be mafia, no matter who he investigates, whether they be mafia or townie.

Unlynchable could also be You-Know-Who because of his horcruxes. Individually aligned could include Reeta Skeeter or Umbridge.

If you are the insane cop, you get inverted results. Town comes up mafia, mafia comes up town. Although If Mats is indiviual he will come mafia (ie town)

 

[Papa_Smurf]

If you are the insane cop, you get inverted results. Town comes up mafia, mafia comes up town. Although If Mats is indiviual he will come mafia (ie town)

I got the roles mixed-up. I meant paranoid cop. Trelawny would be perfect for the role.

http://mikeburnfire.sitesled.com/mscumB.swf

 

[Varun]

Unlynchable could also be You-Know-Who because of his horcruxes. Individually aligned could include Reeta Skeeter or Umbridge.

I doubt he'll be voldemort, since the godfather is always an experienced member.

 

[ARay]

Looks like a lot has happened since I have left.
Going to re read the entire thread and find my person to.
At the moment Unlynch: Varun
I lynched you because you were too quite for my liking. I did give a reason for my vote.
Anyways lets start reading.

 

[Aditya]

I doubt he'll be voldemort, since the godfather is always an experienced member.

Not really. It's not necessary that the god father will always be a experienced member.

 

[BKB1991]

No, but if Matt turned out to be Voldy, it will me a stupid way to play. I think I know what his role is, but I am not sure if I reveal it?

 

[Varun]

I think Toughguard/Bulletproof.

 

[Aditya]

Is there any good reason to lynch me? I've been lynched and the reason give is "putting pressure on him". I'm ready to answer some questions because I know that I'm not a mafia.

 

[The Spin]

Varun: 1 (Papa Smurf)
Aditya: 1 (Varun)

7 required for a lynch.

 

[Varun]

Unlynch : Aditya

I trust him ATM, can't say much.

 

[ARay]

I agree. If he does not have anything to say in his defence then he needs to be lynched we have no other option. We might not lynch him due to his inexperience but then I'm sure he will not help the townies throughout the game.

No lynch: 2 (p23456789, Varun)
Matt121: 2 (User 2010, MaD)
User2010: 1 (Matt121)
Paki007: 7 (Chewie, BKB1991, Mark, Papa Smurf, CG123, ARay)

9 to lynch, so Paki007 is two votes away.

Good start for us, now Matt needs to post something in his defence or else he's the next one to be lynched.

Lynch : Matt121

Reason : Has been acting weirdly and not saying anything in his defence when he knows that he can be lynched if he doesn't prove that he is not a mafia.

I am suspicious of Bevab due to his role claim but then that could be either his inexperience or maybe he tried to act over smart by false role claiming so that no one is suspicious of him. We don't need members who are inactive and are not at all contributing to the game ( I'm talking about Matt). His last post in this thread "lynch me, lynch me, lynch me". That's all he wanted to say in his defence, if he doesn't care about him being lynched then there is no point of him being part of this game for any longer. My lynch stays.

Is there any good reason to lynch me? I've been lynched and the reason give is "putting pressure on him". I'm ready to answer some questions because I know that I'm not a mafia.

These are your posts aditya.
Random, really not much helpful. You did not take part in the paki lynch either
As, I go through them, I see that you have been less active than PNumber even.
To be honest with you I cannot find one thing good about any of these posts.

Lynch:Aditya
Aright now as I have been rereading this thread.
I have a few people who make me feel uncomfortable:
1) Chewie: something about his game just does not seem right.
2) Mark: Quite happy to bandwagon

 

[Chewie]

I don't think Aditya is suspicious at the moment - following the Matt lynch doesn't really mean too much, especially since most people wanted him gone. Though post 559 does make me a bit suspicious - he is trying a bit hard to seem town-aligned. There's not any need to discuss Hagrid's death really. It's sad that we've lost a town member, but that's not much need to post about it. Really, I'd be more suspicious of the people that did post - mafia members wouldn't want to not post because they may think that that wouldn't be blending in. ARay does bring up some decent points though.

With regards to p23456789, I'm suspicious of him, but at this point in time I'm thinking it's more to do with newbness than anything else. His posts haven't really been helpful at all, but at least he is here and makes attempts to post and analyse stuff. Granted, it's basically a re-hash of things other people have said, but I think it's safe to leave him for today.

Re Varun's post 560 (I'm not quoting because I can't be bothered and I've got this open in two different windows), ARay's post I don't think is suspicious - he's outlining what his views on strategy are.

Re Matt's role, I still doubt that if he had an important town role that he'd be acting like he did. Similarly, if it was something like you think it is, it'd probably be more a hidden role; Matt wouldn't know about it and therefore wouldn't be attracting attention as he did. I have no idea why he was silenced though.

@ Varun's post 569, Mark is saying the cop is useless because he hasn't managed to secretly bring up the names of those he has found are mafia-aligned.

An individually aligned player... Rita Skeeter? Don't really buy it though. (I've been reading through the thread sequentially and saw Papa Smurf's post about Rita just now)

@ Aditya, don't role claim unless it looks like you are going to be lynched, or you feel it will help the town - if you are a townie, then role claiming helps narrow down who are key roles for the mafia.

@ ARay, could you please try and explain what you think is not quite right about me?

 

[Varun]

I feel there are three more mafia, and one self-aligned (can't be cult). So it seems we have to lynch someone, and put pressure now.

Lynch : ARay

Whaddya say?

----------

One lynch won't affect you much, but maybe we can elicit some replies?