Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[Gaurav_7]

Ok, wait until Spin tells you that himself. I received the PM just after I posted that I didn't get my PM.

Let us forget that for a moment but, I feel you and Smurf are actually trying to portray what you both are telling is right.

First Smurf said, he got the result as 'Callum is a death eater'. But, he immediately said he got 'Smurf is a death eater'. How can that happen? Smurf isn't likely to make such sort of a mistake.

Abhas described it before - they can make you say what they want you to say

So, you mean Callum said something which p wanted? I mean why you feel he has that role? I just want to know what you're thinking. I'm at the moment very clear that there is something wrong between Varun and Smurf.

Mark claimed as Dumbledore, just saw that. Not good really, we're claiming when there's no need for it.

----------

Ok, here I come back again.


I have replaced Matt due to his Inactivity


Now let's just hope I don't die as soon as I come back...

You come back as Matt, that automatically makes you a suspect.

 

[Chewie]

He read the pm, expecting to get a message saying Callum is so and so, and saw that it said death eater but didn't check the name. He thought it was suspicious though because Chez had written that note underneath. Later he checked it again and saw that it was actually his name there.

Abhas was saying that if you are under the imperious curse you cannot post in this thread unless the person who put you under the curse tells Chez who tells you to post a certain statement.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Still, I don't tend to believe Smurf. I haven't seen a game where the mod says he has given the right info or not. Especially when the person is a cop as that would mean mod actually tells to the person whether that person is a normal cop or an insane one.

Also, I doubt Callum is a mafia. That claim of Callum is pretty interesting but, I don't think any of the mafia will dare to put forward such a role claim.

 

[Chewie]

He was saying it is correct because the pm says

"Papa Smurf is death eater aligned"

 

[Gaurav_7]

Alright, I might have interpreted it wrong but, the way Varun and him have been trying to prove their happenings right makes me suspicious of them. Can't really tell.

 

[hedger_14]

Well Chez asked me if I wanted to replace him cause I was active and he wasn't posting at all in the thread.

Anyway, I'm really suspicious of Papa Smurf firstly. His game looked like a solid townie game at the start but now it's looking like he's mafia. If we look back, I was killed after suspecting Bevab who turned up mafia and then ARay said Papa Smurf was mafia and he turned up dead the next night. Looking at his posts since being suspected, he's been trying to act like he can't play this awesome game cause he's not that good quoting one post, 'Damn you guys with your compliments. Makes me not want to deny it ' and then saying that it was no surprise that ARay was killed. And of course, he's been mainly posting the same stuff as Bevab has so I think he's mafia.

Lynch: Papa Smurf

I'm also suspicious of p23456789. He's really posted nothing helpful, while trying to make himself look like a townie. Also the imperious curse that Chewie was under, maybe p23456789 wanted to place that there to take all suspicion away from himself by placing it on himself.

Other than that, Aditya has been really quiet, I don't remember him contributing much to the discussion either and hasn't posted much either. He's normally a quiet player but he's yet to be a mafia. He did roleclaim, but was also reluctant. Don't know what to make of that but I'd still have him in my suspect book.

Of the other members, I'm pretty sure User, BKB, Chewie and Abhas are townies. Mark claimed Dumbledore and noone has countered that claim so you can be pretty sure he is townie too although I did suspect him earlier in the game due to his consistent change in lynches. Varun, I'm also slightly unsure of. He's been trying to put the idea of a bus driver into our minds but I'm pretty sure there isn't one but his role makes me think he is a townie. He's still not clear though. Callum looks pretty clear to me as well but there is still a hint of doubt in my mind although I don't think he is mafia. So:

FOS: p23456789, Aditya, Varun

 

[Gaurav_7]

Matt was non lynch-able so that means now Hedger is non lynch-able. Certainly not a town role given how Matt acted first day. Or was it to do with the role?

 

[hedger_14]

No, it was a one time only thing. I (Well Matt) would survive one lynch. Who knows why Matt acted like he did. Maybe he thought that it would be awesome to not be killed but didn't realise that he could be killed later. And certainly didn't take into account that the mafia would be able to kill him at night but I guess they've kept him around cause he hasn't helped the town anyway.

Still, he's wasted the role and now I'm a vanilla townie. (Just so you know, normally an unlynchable role goes to a townie and an unkillable role goes to the mafia or as long as I've known it, it has been)

 

[Gaurav_7]

Umm, one lynch survival. Who in HP can have that role who has to be a good person too? Anybody?

 

[hedger_14]

Ok, well there's not much point in hiding what character I am since I have no certain role and the mafia will either kill me or not kill me, and I doubt revealing who I am will make a difference.

I am Ginny Weasley, Team Hogwarts aligned Harry's Lover Girl

And as I already said, I can survive one lynch and am otherwise a vanilla townie.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Well, why the hell did Matt act that way then? He simply wasted an opportunity of making town strong. What an idiotic play!

 

[Varun]

Alright, I might have interpreted it wrong but, the way Varun and him have been trying to prove their happenings right makes me suspicious of them. Can't really tell.

I tracked Papa Smurf because I was suspicious of him. Even I was perplexed when I came to know he had used the role on himself. But why would he investigate himself? Is it even possible?

Also, Chewie has been acting pretty weirdly today, especially with p-2345..., that puts up my suspicion on him.

FOS : Chewie, Smurf

Also, can Mark clarify if he used his role on night 1? That'd corroborate for my role.

 

[hedger_14]

Just like I said, he played idiotically and that is probably why Chez wanted to replace him. And since he has played in no previous mafia games, there's not much we can read into this game.


And Varun, I think Chewie said he was under the imperious curse but then again, I didn't think he was unable to post unless directed to.

And Chewie and Abhas, post as I can see you are viewing the thread

----------

tracked Papa Smurf because I was suspicious of him. Even I was perplexed when I came to know he had used the role on himself. But why would he investigate himself? Is it even possible?

I think so unless there's a note saying, 'You cannot investigate yourself' but I still believe he isn't what he is but what role might he have as a mafia that he can only use on himself, or would you on himself.

----------

sorry, that should say 'would *use* on himself'

 

[Varun]

Ok, well there's not much point in hiding what character I am since I have no certain role and the mafia will either kill me or not kill me, and I doubt revealing who I am will make a difference.

I am Ginny Weasley, Team Hogwarts aligned Harry's Lover Girl

And as I already said, I can survive one lynch and am otherwise a vanilla townie.

So my trust on Matt's role actually gets proved. It was easily comprehensible from his posts that he was town, but the mafia confused others up to lynch him.

FOS : P234556677

Was constantly labelling Matt as voldemort. Effective trick.

 

[hedger_14]

Yeah, all of his posts have been either pointless or saying Matt was/could be Voldemort.