Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[Gaurav_7]

I tracked Papa Smurf because I was suspicious of him. Even I was perplexed when I came to know he had used the role on himself. But why would he investigate himself? Is it even possible?

Let me make it clear, didn't you post on page where ARay was mentioned dead that you haven't got any results because you think some one is swapping things? Wasn't it done during this night?

 

[hedger_14]

He said he thought he must have been roleblocked but mentioned later that Chez forgot and gave him the results then so he got the results during the day.

 

[Varun]

I tracked Mark and Hedger on the first and second nights respectively and got results as 'didn't do anything significant' for both.
But since I was still not sure of Mark, I thought it MIGHT be a bus driver switching things around, but after that role-claim of Mark, I pretty much trust him.

I was intent on Hedger (Snape) having no other role because he just didn't use it.

I investigated Papa Smurf on the third night (i.e. last night) and got the result as 'Papa Smurf was seen around Papa Smurf'.

 

[hedger_14]

'Papa Smurf was seen around Papa Smurf'

lol, nice message to get.

But yeah, Mark is certainly townie which makes him a likely target for the mafia tonight since he's definately townie. Somebody would have certaintly counter claimed as Dumbledore or at least put suspicion on Mark so their role as Dumbledore wasn't revealed.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm confused with all the happenings really. Smurf investigated Callum, he says. So, someone switched Callum and him? That is the only reason, Varun could have got that result. Also, that is the only reason Smurf would have got himself as mafia. So, we do have a bus driver. Aw man, he whoever he is needs to use his role wisely.

 

[Varun]

Hmm, went through the last two pages again.

@Papa Smurf that means you are a paranoid cop I guess.

FOS: p23456789, Aditya

@Chewie:As you are fingering me,again.Ask me anything you like and I will answer it for my defence.I guess,this is the best way to keep the discussion going

Why were you targeting Papa Smurf?

----------

oh and btw guys, Papa Smurf is actually Trelawny.

Why are you so defensive of Papa Smurf? To me, he's suspicious as well.

Also, how do you infer he is a paranoid cop?
And, is there any evidence he's Trelawny?

His first post after the writeup did it for me.

@Chewie:I fingered Papa Smurf at that time because he posted "Can't we lynch them all?"which seemed to me that he didn't care about the townies and was good with all of them being lynched.I still suspect him infact he makes the pefect partner for Bevab.If we take Bevab's claim of not having much HP knowledge at full value and Papa Smurf being our HP encyclopedia.He could have told Bevab to role-claim as Flitwick and Smurf did make a few people roleclaim although I didn't get anything at all for Aditya's one.And how do you know he is Trelawny?The way you posted it sounded like that you are the cop

I meant, why did you target him during the night.

Totally confusing. Chewie came out of nowwhere to be sure of P-number being a mafia, and enforcing him too much, thus acting weirdly.
Also, he is too sure of Smurf being townie, though others are FOS'ing him.

p-number's behaviour seems nervous too, but I can't say if that's because of intense pressure from Chewie.

What do you mean?The way you sound like it feels that you know I am mafia for sure and that I have some kind of role at night and I targeted Smurf with it.Then let me ask you this"How do you know I targeted Smurf?I think you are making this up cause if you knew this.I don't think you would finger me,I think you would lynch me

Answer the question

Target him for what?I don't think Professor Sprout is supposed to target anyone

Lynch: p23456789

As you are lynching me.I will ask for two things:
Reason for the lynch
Proof of me targeting Smurf.Which I doubt you do

This, Chewie do you have a proof?

You don't deny it, you just avoid the question



This is hardly a denial. Just a poor role claim

Isn't avoiding a part of denying a claim?And me asking"What do you mean?"Isn't that denying?

You targeted Papa Smurf last night. You claim you are Professor Sprout and that you did not target him as you have no role. Professor Sprout is an even less well-known character than Professor Flitwick. You did not deny that you targeted Papa Smurf (well at least not emphatically at all). Therefore I think you did target him, as a mafia and therefore cannot role claim properly.

If he targeted Smurf last night, how was it related to his getting the result 'Papa Smurf is a death eater'? Is he possessed as to say that? That makes me conclude that either you are the possessor or p-number is, thus my suspicion on both.

Oh, and check this.I gave you guys a hint about my role the first time I posted about Hagrid's death.Surprisingly nobody noticed at all.

That doesn't mean anything. You could have decided what you would role claim as early on so that you could leave hints.

Because he is who he says he is.

@p-number - If you are the death doctor (or whatever that role is), did you use your role? Tell us the results.

@Chewie - How do you know he is who he says he is?

----------

I'm confused with all the happenings really. Smurf investigated Callum, he says. So, someone switched Callum and him? That is the only reason, Varun could have got that result. Also, that is the only reason Smurf would have got himself as mafia. So, we do have a bus driver. Aw man, he whoever he is needs to use his role wisely.

or maybe Smurf is possessed? quite possible.

 

[hedger_14]

Ok, this is confusing me as well. p23456789 has been really suspicious and avoiding answering Chewie's question.

And I'm lost now, I'm tired as well so I can't be bothered reading over the last few pages to work out what's really happened.

 

[ARay]

Ok, here I come back again.


I have replaced Matt due to his Inactivity


Now let's just hope I don't die as soon as I come back...

Meeh you fellow Why not meeeeeee

 

[Gaurav_7]

Ray, you're dead. Stop posting.

 

[Abhas]

Alright, having gone through the last few pages of discussion, the interesting thing that came across was "papa smurf targetted papa smurf", and he got a death eater result.

Papa Smurf, I'd like to know whom all have you investigated till now.
Varun, I want the same from you.
Aditya, you also claimed as a tracker. Whom all have you investigated?

And, I would like to have Aditya's answer before Varun's. There is something shady in these two guys. One of them has to be lying, if not both.

Dumbledore, on your role, I am posting some statements, decide which one you'd like to investigate for the night.

p23456789 is mafia
varun is mafia
aditya is mafia
chewie is mafia
abhas is mafia
cg123 is mafia
papa smurf is mafia
user2010 is mafia
bkb1991 is mafia
matt121 is mafia

Just send any one of these to chez and he'll confirm.

----------

oh, and those getting confused on the imperious curse, I don't think they can force a person to post more than one post.

You are given one post, and that's it.

Chewie, how were you so confident that Callum was possessed?

 

[Gaurav_7]

user2010 is mafia

You need that still? Wow, you think I could be a mafia.

 

[Abhas]

I've included everyone's name in it. I don't see a problem with that, why should it worry you? my name's in the list as well.

----------

He read the pm, expecting to get a message saying Callum is so and so, and saw that it said death eater but didn't check the name. He thought it was suspicious though because Chez had written that note underneath. Later he checked it again and saw that it was actually his name there.

And you know all that, how?
You seem to have insights into everything smurf does. Not funny.

 

[Gaurav_7]

FOS : Abhas

Not for my name being there but, he's pushing Chewie from a while now. And, he's a very cunning player. Potentially a mafia maybe.

 

[Abhas]

I agree I've been pushing for Chewie, but that's because I've not got answers to any of my questions, or have I missed something?
To me he's as suspicious today as he was on Day 2.

And regarding the names.. You guys do understand I'm not accusing anyone. I'm just trying to help the lie detector role by providing quotes to be queried.
It might just clear you if you are being falsely accused of being mafia.

I'm trying to help the town uncover some clues, obviously with the help of people with roles. Having played the lie-detector before, I know how frustrating it can be not to find a suitable statement that can be queried.

Regarding Chewie, I have a feeling I know what role he might have, or claim to have. I'll wait for some of my questions to be answered, and until then, I have no accusations on him, just suspicion.

I'm not in the favour of pressuring people into revealing their roles yet, considering we still have a large number of people in the game. There was a reason Chez did not reveal the roles of the people on death. I'm assuming there is a strong mafia and to balance that, they would not know the roles of the people existing, or dead.

 

[pcfan123]

I have not used my role on any night. couldn't find a quote worth investigating