Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[BKB1991]

What did you get Papa Smurf?

 

[pcfan123]

I decided to change to Varun and check whether his roleclaim was true. The result I got was false.

Lynch: Varun

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I'm pretty sure he's the last one. And your response makes me feel you were indeed approached. So, if after Hedger's lynch the town hasn't won, then I'm going after you User.

I might actually struggle to be online later, so to avoid confusion, I'll post my reasons. Like I mentioned earlier, everything made sense to me when Chewie role-claimed. And he actually managed to save himself from the mafia last night because of it (indirectly, anyway).

There are 2 cops in this game - one real and one paranoid. There is no doubt that I'm the paranoid. Every target of my investigation (even myself) turns out to be Death Eater aligned. The real is Aditya. His results make total sense. And Hedger (originally Matt) came out as Death Eater aligned. That's strike 1 for Hedger.

When we tried to lynch Matt, he turned out to be unlynchable. And as already discussed, the only unlynchable character in HP is Voldemort because of his horcruxes. The existence of Bevab as Nagini the horcrux confirmed thos. That's strike 2 for Hedger.

The only who's really accused Hedger so far has been Chewie. So, naturally Hedger has feel threatened by him. Now, when Chewie role-claimed, he revealed that he could swap the targets of two people during the night. This is where I come in. As a paranoid cop, I will always have a target during the night. But as my investigations are rather pointless, I am the perfect fodder for Chewie to use his powers.

So what happened last night? As Chewie was so suspicous of Hedger, I felt that he wanted me to target him. And I did. However, the result I got was 'Chewie is Death Eater Aligned'. This means that Chewie swapped my target with someone else's. And the other person wanted to target Chewie. As I've already said, Hedger is the only person to be threatened by his existence. My guess is that Hedger, as Voldemort, wanted to kill him during the night. But since his target got swapped to himself, as since he wouldn't kill himself, no one died during the night. And that's strike 3 Hedger. You're out.

As to User, his defence of Hedger makes me feel that Hedger recruited him last night. User is Kakarof, a rogue Death Eater. His character would be perfect for the recruitable mafia role. Plus, User claimed before that he does not have an allegiance, until someone finds him.

Now if Chewie can confim that he indeed swapped the targets of me and Hedger's, then well, what more evidence do you guys need?

----------

The first senetnce was a reply to User. Should learn to quote

 

[Gaurav_7]

I decided to change to Varun and check whether his roleclaim was true. The result I got was false.

Lynch: Varun

Interesting, I always had a feeling Varun was lying. Maybe Smurf is lying as well. That is the only way they could have made up that thing.

----------

Lynch - Varun.

This is if there wasn't any swapping done. Chewie needs to confirm. I'm almost sure now Smurf is mafia as well the way he is pushing for Hedger lynch.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I decided to change to Varun and check whether his roleclaim was true. The result I got was false.

Lynch: Varun

Now that is interesting. Just read back and Varun did try to lynch Chewie as well.

FOS: Varun

----------

This is if there wasn't any swapping done. Chewie needs to confirm. I'm almost sure now Smurf is mafia as well the way he is pushing for Hedger lynch.

I've given a convincing argument against Hedger. And Chewie swapped me and p-number during Night 3. That's how he found out about p-number as being the Imperius caster.

Now, how does the above make any sense if I'm not the paranoid cop?

 

[Gaurav_7]

This is if there wasn't any swapping done. Chewie needs to confirm. I'm almost sure now Smurf is mafia as well the way he is pushing for Hedger lynch.

I'm going off for now. Don't at all lynch Hedger, we will waste a day. He is Voldemort most certainly. Varun and Smurf are my two prime suspects for now.

 

[BKB1991]

Waiting for Chewie to confirm Papa Smurfs story. If he does its pretty straightforwards

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Weird, User says that he is Igor Karkaroff, Hidden Cheat, Unknown but when I followed him he came up as a team hogwarts aligned.

Makes sense. Kakaroff was a reformed Death Eater. So, he would be on the good side, until Voldemort tried to recruit him. User's defence of Hedger, and his baseless suspicions of me, makes me believe that he was indeed recruited last night.

So, I guess he was recruited after your investigation. Which is why he came Hogwarts-aligned. But this is only my guess.

 

[Chewie]

I'm pretty sure he's the last one. And your response makes me feel you were indeed approached. So, if after Hedger's lynch the town hasn't won, then I'm going after you User.

I might actually struggle to be online later, so to avoid confusion, I'll post my reasons. Like I mentioned earlier, everything made sense to me when Chewie role-claimed. And he actually managed to save himself from the mafia last night because of it (indirectly, anyway).

There are 2 cops in this game - one real and one paranoid. There is no doubt that I'm the paranoid. Every target of my investigation (even myself) turns out to be Death Eater aligned. The real is Aditya. His results make total sense. And Hedger (originally Matt) came out as Death Eater aligned. That's strike 1 for Hedger.

When we tried to lynch Matt, he turned out to be unlynchable. And as already discussed, the only unlynchable character in HP is Voldemort because of his horcruxes. The existence of Bevab as Nagini the horcrux confirmed thos. That's strike 2 for Hedger.

The only who's really accused Hedger so far has been Chewie. So, naturally Hedger has feel threatened by him. Now, when Chewie role-claimed, he revealed that he could swap the targets of two people during the night. This is where I come in. As a paranoid cop, I will always have a target during the night. But as my investigations are rather pointless, I am the perfect fodder for Chewie to use his powers.

So what happened last night? As Chewie was so suspicous of Hedger, I felt that he wanted me to target him. And I did. However, the result I got was 'Chewie is Death Eater Aligned'. This means that Chewie swapped my target with someone else's. And the other person wanted to target Chewie. As I've already said, Hedger is the only person to be threatened by his existence. My guess is that Hedger, as Voldemort, wanted to kill him during the night. But since his target got swapped to himself, as since he wouldn't kill himself, no one died during the night. And that's strike 3 Hedger. You're out.

As to User, his defence of Hedger makes me feel that Hedger recruited him last night. User is Kakarof, a rogue Death Eater. His character would be perfect for the recruitable mafia role. Plus, User claimed before that he does not have an allegiance, until someone finds him.

Now if Chewie can confim that he indeed swapped the targets of me and Hedger's, then well, what more evidence do you guys need?

You interpreted perfectly what I wanted you to do. I did indeed swap Papa Smurf and Hedger. This does put beyond doubt that Hedger is Voldemort, especially as no one was killed last night. I had a feeling that I might be the one targeted, but now it is impossible for anyone to die at night. Well actually, Papa Smurf now controls who dies, but we can hopefully use that power in the correct way. I have nothing that stops me targeting the same two people every night.

Varun I feel is most likely mafia. I don't think User is, but I don't believe his role claim. I think there's a reason he wants us to lynch him though

----------

Take me out, seriously guys, such a disgusting role this. 'Unknown' ? Oh no, I feel like killing Chez. I'm more than sure that my death will help the town more than my life.

----------

It is such a pain to go through the pages and am kinda bored.

Well, you guys know whom to vote off during the day, I hope.

Well, maybe he forgot. I'll believe you as of now. I'm bored. Can I vote myself off?

Unlynch : Abhas
Lynch : User2010

Take that, now does that make me a mafia?

You guys can do what you want. I'm confused about myself and can't even post about my character.

I have a feeling I know who User is. And why he doesn't want us to lynch Hedger.

Lynch: User2010

----------

Oh and I think User can't actually role claim as the person he is.

I'm still quite wary of Abhas. He has proven to be incredibly tricky in previous games. But I think Varun and Hedger are the two mafia members left. Varun has always been going after me.

----------

Varun = Pettigrew?

 

[BKB1991]

Maybe. Mad Eye Moody is a good claim tbf, hes one of the good characters, but not as important. Plus someone is lieing about their claim, because we havent found Harry.

Wait, its possible that Varun could be Barty Crouch jnr. That would give him the fake identity of Mad Eye Moody? So we lynch Hedger then? And what about Abhas for good measure too You never know which side he is..

 

[Chewie]

Maybe. Mad Eye Moody is a good claim tbf, hes one of the good characters, but not as important. Plus someone is lieing about their claim, because we havent found Harry.

Wait, its possible that Varun could be Barty Crouch jnr. That would give him the fake identity of Mad Eye Moody? So we lynch Hedger then? And what about Abhas for good measure too You never know which side he is..

I mentioned that possibility when Varun first role claimed. Likewise Voldemort was controlling Ginny to an extent in the second book.

I still don't think Hedger can be lynched, because Harry is a horcrux as well.

I don't think Harry is able to role claim as Harry. (part of his role possibly)

 

[Papa_Smurf]

You interpreted perfectly what I wanted you to do.

Lucky for you I did. Otherwise, you would've gone It was a risky move you did when you role-claimed, but it paid off. So you deserve the more than I do.

I have a feeling I know who User is. And why he doesn't want us to lynch Hedger.

----------

Oh and I think User can't actually role claim as the person he is.

I think I know who you're implying. No point in beating around the bush, you mean Harry. While that would correspond pefectly with everything that's happened in the game, the only thing that puts me off is how did User pull the role-claim? As for someone who claims to have very little HP knowledge, Kakaroff is a hard character to know. Add that to the fact that the allegiance he claimed made sense (to Kararoff).

Wait, its possible that Varun could be Barty Crouch jnr.

That would make perfect sense. Finally, the jig-saw fits. I say we get rid of Varun, kill User at night to get rid of Hedge's last defence, and lynch Hedger tomorrow.

Unlynch: Hedger_14

Lynch: Varun

 

[BKB1991]

Yea User obviously fits the puzzle. But I think we could be better of trying to lynch Hedger for good measure first. If he lynches and dies, great. If not, then we may have to lynch User and then back to Hedger. But that would mean two town deaths, as well..

----------

btw I dont get the part about you getting the killing role, as you say kill User at night?

 

[Chewie]

Remember that no townies can die unless there is a role blocker.

I don't think there is one, or if there was it was Bellatrix though because I don't recall anyone being role blocked recently.

----------

I think it's best we get rid of the other mafia members before we lynch User because he is another town vote.
Unlynch: User2010
Lynch: Varun

Varun: 4 (User2010, Mark, Papa Smurf, Chewie)

6 required for a lynch.

I don't think you should lynch him yet BKB, see what he has to say in his defense.

----------

User probably just read up about him on wikipedia or something. Quite easy to do, just he was more convincing about it that Bevab and p23456789

----------

An even if you didn't understand what I wanted, I still wouldn't have died, it would have been whoever you targeted.

----------

The last two parts are to Papa Smurf

 

[Papa_Smurf]

I wasn't surprised that no one died last night. I was expecting either that, or the death of Voldemort, as can be proven by this quote.

If things go tonight like I hope they do, then there won't be any need for Day 5.

I expected that Chewie switched me and Hedger. While I didn't know who would be saved because of this (in this case Chewie himself), I did think that Hedger might die because he target himself, essentially. It's apparent now, obviously, if that does happen, then no-one dies.

As for how I can control who dies. I can only control it if Hedger decides to kill. And all this is thanks to Chewie. As long as he can swap the targets of me and Hedger, then the one who dies is the one I target.

Pretty cool that Voldemort's being thwarted by the Trelawny and the Weasly twins Who needs Harry?

----------

User probably just read up about him on wikipedia or something. Quite easy to do, just he was more convincing about it that Bevab and p23456789

----------

An even if you didn't understand what I wanted, I still wouldn't have died, it would have been whoever you targeted.

True true, to both those points. I was trying to be humble at the same time as trying to praise myself