I think that was a good response from the board . So what if the team is losing , why would the board bring you in ?? It was he who wanted to retire at a mere age of JUST 35 , when he could have just after the WC .
Everyone his/her own its self-respect & the board just displayed it perfectly . And I pretty liked this gesture & also believe in it .
And wouldn't it be a disrespect to the player whom AB would replace ?
Duminy is 35 and has done
nothing since forever. Rassie himself is 30, but his spot was never a question. Miller has done practically nothing of note in ages, but then again his spot isn't a question. Amla?
I think even as a die hard AB fan, the decision is not something I detest or feel malice about but I also don't think everything lies in AB's court. What I have made of the whole scenario is that de Villiers wanted a break after the two test series he played against India and Australia, both of which were fiercely competitive and mentally exhausting to watch, let alone be a part of and have played a winning role in. He had quit tests and was persuaded by Gibson and co to return. If you cannot then give him respite from those meaningless bilaterals, well, this is the position you find yourself in (South Africa cricket). Kohli didn't play the Asia cup. Dhoni only plays limited overs but his wishes for rest are respected and granted, rightly so. Dhoni doesn't even play LIST A anymore. The amount of cricket that is played these days is bananas. Personally, I feel the English, Australian and Indian boards have done a superb job in managing their marquee players. It not only helps them develop bench strength, but also keeps their gun players energised. Even Pakistan now have started adopting this strategy as seen with the rest given to Sarfaraz.
If there is any doubt whether AB would/could have influenced the results of SA this World Cup, rewind to the IPL this year.. he's not in the PlayStation mode he was in, in 2015 but he would
EASILY still be the top 5 batters in the world and
EASILY the best in South Africa! Have South Africa needed it? Jesus Christ they have!
This actually completely explains his sudden retirement announcement. It is clear now that he was driven into it rather than him choosing to do it. Too religious to fake injury, honest catholic, patriotic.. it all makes sense.
Who's lost out? South Africa and cricket lovers. He would have been a sight to behold on these tracks.