NILAYSHAH60
Dreamcatcher
Sportsbookie
Fantasy Cricket Team
India
NZ....
PlanetCricket Award Winner
The Boys
I don't think age is that much of an issue when we talk about specialist batsman who performs his role. It's a different thing when we talk about keepers and pace bowlers since their life span as a Cricketer is short.Giving a longer rope to a bastman nearing 35 shouldn't be the main criteria of the team. Rohit has batted well, but is nowhere near 'best'- Yes, 'best' in the current team where no one seems to be scoring. However, that doesnt mean he becomes your best man overnight.
Also I agree with that part that Rohit isn't the best option we can look forward to. He still seems to be going for his shots at critical stages in his innings which is a bit of a worry. But, I wouldn't look at keeping him out just because of his age considering that he is doing well right now and with our non-performing middle order.
Gill is a direct replacement for Rohit but I think Rohit isn't going anywhere atleast for a couple of years. He is just ageing like a fine wine at present.