Potential Reasons of why Pakistani players were not picked by the IPL Franchises
1. Volatile relations- A franchise wouldn't like to shell out money for a player, if they are themselves not sure whether the governments will allow them to play in the IPL or not.
2. Availability- This is a subjective term. And it includes not only the period of 45 odd days of the IPL but also the issue of visas.
Both of these points indicated are arguing the same facts. Our government
did everything we could to insure that our players could participate in this tournament. Leaving the ball clearly in BCCI's court. I still dont get why the Indian government are having problems giving visas to cricketers. I can understand why ordinary Pakistanis may have troubles getting the visas. But
Do you expect Shoaib Malik to take out guns and suicide bombs?
3. Competition- Given the popularity of the format, the franchises thought people like Parnell & Morgan were decent, if not better picks, than Aamer & Umar Akmal.
Even though Aamir and Akmal are better than Parnell and Morgan, for a minute lets accept your comparison. Even if
Parnell is as good as Aamir in the T20s is he
better than Umar Gul? Remember Gul has lost touch only in the longer versions of the game. Parnell is good at bowling at the depth, but Gul is proved himself in
both the
T20 World Cups. Ask South Africa who knocked them out in the World Cup. It wasnt Afridi, it was Gul's depth bowling.
4. Franchises aren't idiots- The franchises invest significant amount of money on players. They obviously do not want players with severe complications attached to them, when they can get equally, if not more talented players at cheaper prices and lesser hassles. Pakistan sadly does not provide cheaper prices nor lesser hassles.
Well certain franchises have proven themselves as idiotic. Lets assume that franchises actually signed the Pakistani players and they couldnt get their visas done. Would they have had to pay out those Pakistani players? No. They could have then ripped the contracts apart and taken the players then available. Also Chennai's picks clearly showed them stupidity. Players like
Thissara Perera, Justin Kemp, Adrian Barath, Yousef Abdullah, Adam Voges are representing IPL sides over the likes of
Shahid Afridi, Shoaib Malik, Imran Nazir, Mohammad Aamir, Umar Akmal, Misbah.
Clearly if IPL teams didnt want to get involved in "potential hassles" then they could have terminated the Pakistani players contract as soon as it became a liability and bought out those ones mentioned above. I dont think most of them would have been sold anyways
5. They can spend their money the way they like- Really childish of the Pakistani Foreign Minister to phone his Indian counterpart and complain about no player getting picked. Even more childish was Shahid "Big Bash is tougher than IPL" Afridi to link this to national insult. Look guys, it is the franchises' money. No one will like to spend money on you if you can't provide a hassle-free environment for them.
Afridi's indiviual comments seemed to have pissed some Indian fans. Here is what Afridi had actually said,
Shahid Afridi said:
?Compared to IPL and all the other Twenty20 tournaments I think this (Big Bash) tournament is very tough,?
Link:
Indian Cricket Fever - Afridi Rates KFC Big Bash T20 Higher Than IPL
As far as I can read he hasnt mentioned Big Bash being tougher than the IPL
Dont you agree that the Bash has more competition than IPL? I would agree. Lets not argue about this now as this merely our different opinions. Anyhow, Afridi was right (regardin the insult). The only country that had no players playing for IPL teams was Bangladesh. And the fact that no players of the
World Cup Winning Team were taken clearly indicates a conspiracy. This was what was
"insulting."
6. Franchises' are not Modi's puppets- Do you really think a person who has bought a team for millions of dollars and spent $750,000 on players like Kemar Roach actually cares a crap about what Lalit Modi has to say? All that matters to them is profit. They really don't care about what Lalit Modi says or "instructs" them to do. It is their money, their team and their choice with the players. Blaming Modi is really naive.
They may not be Modi's puppets, but the fact that they have to follow rules and are part of the league clearly indicates that they have to listen to him.
More importantly your Reasons dont answer:
1) Why the IPL franchises actually asked to get these players,(remember they were shortlisted according to the demands) The situation regarding their visas were same for the past year, and this didnt come out yesterday.