puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
No I wouldn't he is a bowler... and was in as nightwatchman, he is a bit of a glorified Hoggard. Has a very solid foward defence, will generally get in the way of anything, but through his career has added a few shots to his armoury that he plays once settled.
Hoggard unfortunately still only has the foward defensive. Obviously congrats to Dizzy, not easy to score a 200 at any time, but much like when Hayden broke the world record, it is in the end a reasonably anomolous statistic, as the opposition on both counts were and are not yet test class.
Had however someone like Gilchrist or Hussey got golden ducks and no runs all series I might have had a wry smile, likewise had Dizzy not taken a wicket, but they did and i didn't
Also, the fact is when England played Bangladesh they often declared well before their lower and middle order got a chance to boost their averages or score maiden tons. Had it been a different captain to Ponting, one who perhaps doesn't believe in nightwatchmen, then Gillespie may never have gotten his chance. However once he got it, with his powers of concentration, reasonably solid defence, and lack of any real quality quick bowler to unsettle him, the stage was set, and full credit to ol' Dizzy he took it with aplomb.
Hoggard unfortunately still only has the foward defensive. Obviously congrats to Dizzy, not easy to score a 200 at any time, but much like when Hayden broke the world record, it is in the end a reasonably anomolous statistic, as the opposition on both counts were and are not yet test class.
Had however someone like Gilchrist or Hussey got golden ducks and no runs all series I might have had a wry smile, likewise had Dizzy not taken a wicket, but they did and i didn't
Also, the fact is when England played Bangladesh they often declared well before their lower and middle order got a chance to boost their averages or score maiden tons. Had it been a different captain to Ponting, one who perhaps doesn't believe in nightwatchmen, then Gillespie may never have gotten his chance. However once he got it, with his powers of concentration, reasonably solid defence, and lack of any real quality quick bowler to unsettle him, the stage was set, and full credit to ol' Dizzy he took it with aplomb.