Newbie Mafia 01 - Endgame

[Dr. Pepper]

What? That doesn't even make sense...

 

[RPHKR]

Basically the cop needs to claim right now.

Why you need him to claim ? Results can be indirectly conversed ...

 

[Dr. Pepper]

So he can give his results and then we have a better idea of who is mafia! Yes I accept that there can be a Godfather but it helps so much more knowing who the cop is. Also the doc needs to know who to save at night!

 

[RPHKR]

Unlynch : Dr.Pepper

I don't want to lynch him now . But I'll put him on suspicious list .
FOS : Dr.Pepper

----------

Hmm ...
Dr.Pepper's idea looks fine , No objection

 

[Dr. Pepper]

Can the cop just hurry up please? I really hope they investigated Great India as well...

 

[RPHKR]

I guess it's Bevab/Haarithan .

 

[Haarithan]

Dr.Pepper is either playing a really smart game as mafia or playing a normal game as townie. Really can't deduce his alignment. I'm unlynching him though.

Unlynch: Dr.Pepper

 

[Dr. Pepper]

Lynch: Haarithan

 

[AngryPixel]

And your reason for that?
Blind lynch without any reason smells like mafia to me.

FOS: Dr.Pepper

 

[Dr. Pepper]

Pretty obvious what my reason is. Didn't think it needed spelling out.

 

[Haarithan]

Okay, so my trick's worked and I believe we have our first confirmed mafia in Dr.Pepper.

So he can give his results and then we have a better idea of who is mafia! Yes I accept that there can be a Godfather but it helps so much more knowing who the cop is. Also the doc needs to know who to save at night!

Dr.Pepper is either playing a really smart game as mafia or playing a normal game as townie. Really can't deduce his alignment. I'm unlynching him though.

Unlynch: Dr.Pepper

Lynch: Haarithan

I was merely waiting on Mani's response following my post, and his response was immediate and pretty much what I expected off a mafia.

I'm a civilian, town aligned for the record.

And I'm fairly sure as to who the Cop is by now, analyzing the last few posts of the thread did fetch me a clue on that. Which is why I was constantly against Pepper while he wanted the cop to revealing his role.

Now I really hope RPHKR can spot the clue as me, to carry out his doc save on the cop for the night. That cop can meanwhile investigate me (if he's under suspicion of course) during the night.

If I'm proven wrong here in my theory behind Dr.Pepper being mafia, then all of you should well know whom to go for the following day.

Lynch: Dr.Pepper

 

[AngryPixel]

Harrithan's reasoning sounds fair enough. Pepper better come up with a decent defense. For now, i'll go with Haarithan.

Lynch: Dr. Pepper

 

[Dr. Pepper]

Haarithan is clearly mafia and Angrypixel is very likely to be his partner.

----------

sigh, I think that's the hammer.

----------

Oh wait it's only on 3, good. So anyway, obviously I counter claim civilian. I was waiting to see if Haarithan claimed cop, which he didn't which confirmed to me that he's mafia.

Just waiting for Bevab now.

----------

Harrithan's reasoning sounds fair enough. Pepper better come up with a decent defense. For now, i'll go with Haarithan.

Lynch: Dr. Pepper

No it doesn't, and that's terrible play if you're mafia. Explain where the reasoning is good in that post. All he does is attempt to turn the tables onto me without giving a proper reason. He was against cop being outed. Why? It's pretty obvious who the cop is anyway, it was just to confirm one mafia.

 

[Haarithan]

I easily figured out Bevab to be a Cop from this post, though I realized it only after posting my response to that post:

Yeah, its good to have Swirler back, especially with him a confirmed townie, he can play freely without any pressure.

Not sure as to how your so confident on him being town aligned. RPHKR's the only confirmed townie in my book, 'cause his claim seemed damn legit.

Who else but a cop would use 'confirmed' so daringly? Obviously he's played very cleverly and left behind a clue for us to work on in a rather subtle manner.

The very next post that followed was yours, badly wanting him to claim.

I didn't post as when I got onto PC it was Night in the game, and obviously you don't post at Night.

Basically the cop needs to claim right now.

Obviously me being town aligned immediately yelled at him to not claim the obvious and present it to you through this post.

Yeah, 'cause the mafia are already aware of a couple of townies and a doc? Never ever should the cop claim! Definitely not now at the least.

The things that followed are pretty much in this page for the others to read. Pretty much proven that Mani's mafia now, though its upto Bevab, RPHKR and Swirler to draw the conclusion.

----------

* In case my grammar's got anyone of you confused:

The very next post that followed was yours, badly wanting him to claim.

Here, 'yours' refers to Dr.Pepper.

Obviously me being town aligned immediately yelled at him to not claim the obvious and present it to you through this post.

Here, 'him' refers to Bevab and 'you' refers to Dr.Pepper.

 

[Dr. Pepper]

If it was obvious, what difference would it make if he claimed? Everyone knew he was cop, I just wanted him to confirm it, so I could confirm who was mafia.

You haven't given a valid reasoning for not wanting the cop to claim. It proves absolutely nothing and you're clutching at straws.

And Angrypixel's blatant buddying with you sums up that you're both mafia. Haarithan, you played a good game but I think one of you should've claimed cop and AP wasn't very subtle at all.