Newbie Mafia 2: Tennis (End Game) Mafia's win (User & Haarithan)

[barmyarmy]

Just to note that Swirler has been online but chosen to avoid hammering. A bit suspicious...

 

[AngryPixel]

Thats definitely suspicious of him. He better hammer soon or mafia would survive another day

 

[CremerCurrans]

Just to note that Swirler has been online but chosen to avoid hammering. A bit suspicious...

I want to hear what Themer says before I decide whether to lynch him or not. I hammered Dr. Pepper in the last match and regretted it.

Well we know he's lied and has a weak claim so he's probably mafia or SK.
Unlynch: Swirler
Lynch: Themer

Also you mentioned he lied, can you point out where it happened , I must of missed it.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Actually, I think I have enough reasons to go for Themer now.

First,

Unlynch : AngryPixel

But,

I want to hear what Themer says before I decide whether to lynch him or not. I hammered Dr. Pepper in the last match and regretted it.

this is what I would want to do as well. Take it however you feel but, I don't think it is good to go for someone without letting him post his defense especially in a short game as this where one mistake and we're doomed.

Also you mentioned he lied, can you point out where it happened , I must of missed it.

He claimed vanilla. But, Hedger says he blocked him. And, the writeup suggests that he has some role. Town/Mafia is not known.

Massive FOS : Themer

 

[barmyarmy]

There's not a lot to read. He claimed Mardy Fish and vanilla but he was role blocker successfully last night trying to do something.
I'm leaning a bit more towards him being SK than mafia but either way he needs to be lynched.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Thats definitely suspicious of him. He better hammer soon or mafia would survive another day

No, I doubt Aditya will end the day as there's actually some discussion going on. We have the time, so why not just wait.

 

[barmyarmy]

Yeah I agree that it's best to hear a defence before killing him. The only danger is that he claims something like doctor in an attempt to get the real doctor to counter claim.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Well, should I hammer then? I am a little confused.

Also, as much as I'd like to believe Federer to be town, AP just makes me think otherwise.

Thats definitely suspicious of him. He better hammer soon or mafia would survive another day

This seems desperate than anything else given that Aditya hasn't even posted anything about ending the day.

 

[CremerCurrans]

He claimed vanilla. But, Hedger says he blocked him. And, the writeup suggests that he has some role. Town/Mafia is not known.

Massive FOS : Themer

There's not a lot to read. He claimed Mardy Fish and vanilla but he was role blocker successfully last night trying to do something.
I'm leaning a bit more towards him being SK than mafia but either way he needs to be lynched.

That is pretty solid.

Yeah I agree that it's best to hear a defence before killing him. The only danger is that he claims something like doctor in an attempt to get the real doctor to counter claim.

It's good that you mentioned this, It's not worth him doing it now.

 

[barmyarmy]

Well in some ways we don't need Themer to post.
What could he say that would make us change our minds? He could claim doctor but I wouldn't believe him on account of his character claim.
I say hammer him and take a risk - without a cop we can only rely on night info from the role blocker and any other lynch we make will be even less certain.

 

[CremerCurrans]

Lynch: Themer

 

[Gaurav_7]

Alright, so that's the hammer. I just hope Themer turns up SK/mafia. Come on Aditya, get this done already.

 

[Haarithan]

Just hoping we got this lynch bang on, as an incorrect lynch would mean the mafias are just a successful night-kill away from victory.

 

[Bevab]

You won't regret lynching Themer, if I guess correctly.

 

[barmyarmy]

Thank you dead cop