hedger_14
ICC Chairman
Not sure what your definition of a few minutes is.
Newbie Ocean's Mafia - Endgame (Town Win)
- Thread starter Haarithan
- Start date
Player reviews
1. User2010 (cult) - Nothing much to say for he was just incredibly unlucky to get killed on the very first lethal night by BKB. Him recruiting Colin over the night without being killed would have made the game really interesting, but oh well.
2. Bevab (Doc) - Played an average game. Made a very good start analyzing the night's write-up well, but otherwise didn't particularly find anyone overly suspicious, and should have really claimed to be the doc towards the end of the game. Without claiming himself to be the doc only made him a little suspicious for other players (Themer, hedger).
3. hedger_14 (vanilla) - Great game. Not a lot of people tend to be cleared easily by claiming to be merely a vanilla, but he just about did that. Fortunately/Unfortunately, his introduction is what got swacker to commit the first real mistake of the game, who thought hedger to be using 'stalling tactics'. Was really confident pushing on swacker's lynch despite the consequences that awaited had he really been a beloved princess.
There you go with the first three, which also has you, Hedger. Will be late by the time I finish all 10.
1. User2010 (cult) - Nothing much to say for he was just incredibly unlucky to get killed on the very first lethal night by BKB. Him recruiting Colin over the night without being killed would have made the game really interesting, but oh well.
2. Bevab (Doc) - Played an average game. Made a very good start analyzing the night's write-up well, but otherwise didn't particularly find anyone overly suspicious, and should have really claimed to be the doc towards the end of the game. Without claiming himself to be the doc only made him a little suspicious for other players (Themer, hedger).
3. hedger_14 (vanilla) - Great game. Not a lot of people tend to be cleared easily by claiming to be merely a vanilla, but he just about did that. Fortunately/Unfortunately, his introduction is what got swacker to commit the first real mistake of the game, who thought hedger to be using 'stalling tactics'. Was really confident pushing on swacker's lynch despite the consequences that awaited had he really been a beloved princess.
There you go with the first three, which also has you, Hedger. Will be late by the time I finish all 10.
hedger_14
ICC Chairman
4. barmyarmy (tracker) - MVP by a country mile. Almost re-defined 'perfection' with his analysis of the write-up, his thoughts on other players, and most importantly the cop saving act he played to deceive the mafias regarding Themer's role. Made it extremely impossible for the mafias to fight back. Like I said earlier, he being recruited by User would have made for a stunning game. All in all, he was an Artemis Fowl in disguise.
5. Themer (Cop) - Brilliant game. Was intelligent enough to react to barmyarmy's act in a subtle manner and the combination of the duo was simply too good to handle for the mafia. He like hedger, was brave enough to push on swacker's lynch despite the consequences that awaited if swacker wasn't lying.
5. Themer (Cop) - Brilliant game. Was intelligent enough to react to barmyarmy's act in a subtle manner and the combination of the duo was simply too good to handle for the mafia. He like hedger, was brave enough to push on swacker's lynch despite the consequences that awaited if swacker wasn't lying.
6. AngryPixel (vigilante) - Funny game. Were it not for his proper analysis of the Night 1 write-up and Colin's witty brain to mark him down as the vigilante, he'd have been all but gone. Was fortunate enough to be unsuccessful in his first mission when an attempted kill on The Rock (now hedger_14) failed, but he made up for his loss and the town's gain by taking down a confirmed double voter in Aditya the following night.
7. Aditya (double voter) - While he didn't contribute anything much of substance to the game, he was just dreadfully unlucky to have been taken down by his own aligned townie in AP on Night 2, especially after being marked down as a confirmed townie.
8. RPHKR (miller) - Poor game. Was more concerned on player's activities than the actual write-ups that had plenty of clues to proceed with. Was really fortunate to have swacker caught suspicious on the other side, when things weren't particularly going well for himself on Day 2, when he almost got lynched off.
9. swacker (mafia roleblocker) - Disappointing debut. Was going pretty well until one stage, where he claimed hedger to be using 'stalling tactics' completely out of the blue. Eventually plotted his down fall. Nothing to feel bad about though, except that he could have conversed a little more with BKB than he'd actually managed to.
10. BKB1991 (mafia godfather) - Good game. Gave it his best shot until his down fall, but his analysis of the write-up (from what I saw in the QT) wasn't particularly impressive, and neither was his interaction with his fellow mafia partner. Did a great job though in preparing an ideal fake claim for swacker that almost got the townies to believe the latter to be a beloved princess. Didn't stand a chance though following swacker's hammer, especially with Colin outwitting every thought of his (most recently the thought that there probably didn't exist a doc).
----------
Ocean's mafia - Mafia discussion space - QuickTopic free message board hosting
What User said. No one's played well on debut and all of them make one mistake or the other. Always converse well with your fellow mafia partner, that's highly essential for your survival. You'll get better with more experience.
7. Aditya (double voter) - While he didn't contribute anything much of substance to the game, he was just dreadfully unlucky to have been taken down by his own aligned townie in AP on Night 2, especially after being marked down as a confirmed townie.
8. RPHKR (miller) - Poor game. Was more concerned on player's activities than the actual write-ups that had plenty of clues to proceed with. Was really fortunate to have swacker caught suspicious on the other side, when things weren't particularly going well for himself on Day 2, when he almost got lynched off.
9. swacker (mafia roleblocker) - Disappointing debut. Was going pretty well until one stage, where he claimed hedger to be using 'stalling tactics' completely out of the blue. Eventually plotted his down fall. Nothing to feel bad about though, except that he could have conversed a little more with BKB than he'd actually managed to.
10. BKB1991 (mafia godfather) - Good game. Gave it his best shot until his down fall, but his analysis of the write-up (from what I saw in the QT) wasn't particularly impressive, and neither was his interaction with his fellow mafia partner. Did a great job though in preparing an ideal fake claim for swacker that almost got the townies to believe the latter to be a beloved princess. Didn't stand a chance though following swacker's hammer, especially with Colin outwitting every thought of his (most recently the thought that there probably didn't exist a doc).
----------
Ocean's mafia - Mafia discussion space - QuickTopic free message board hosting
What User said. No one's played well on debut and all of them make one mistake or the other. Always converse well with your fellow mafia partner, that's highly essential for your survival. You'll get better with more experience.
Last edited:
Game summary
Winners: Town (barmyarmy, Themer, hedger_14, Bevab, AngryPixel and RPHKR)
Town finally got off the mark in a newbie game, and in some style. The game's MVP in barmyarmy made the crucial breakthrough for the town by revealing his true identity (tracker), whilst also pulling off an amazing cop saving act, that eventually led the mafias to presume Themer (cop) to be merely a vanilla. swacker (mafia roleblocker) on debut committed the first real mistake of the game, in what proved to be the beginning of the end for the mafias. One comical moment throughout the game stood out in AngryPixel, the vigilante, taking out a confirmed double voter in Aditya on Night 2, in what could have otherwise seen a perfect win for the town.
Last edited:
Player analysis
1. User2010 (cult) - Nothing much to say for he was just incredibly unlucky to get killed on the very first lethal night by BKB. Him recruiting Colin over the night without being killed would have made the game really interesting, but oh well.
2. Bevab (Doc) - Played an average game. Made a very good start analyzing the night's write-up well, but otherwise didn't particularly find anyone overly suspicious, and should have really claimed to be the doc towards the end of the game. Without claiming himself to be the doc only made him a little suspicious for other players (Themer, hedger).
3. hedger_14 (vanilla) - Great game. Not a lot of people tend to be cleared easily by claiming to be merely a vanilla, but he just about did that. Fortunately/Unfortunately, his introduction is what got swacker to commit the first real mistake of the game, who thought hedger to be using 'stalling tactics'. Was really confident pushing on swacker's lynch despite the consequences that awaited had he really been a beloved princess.
4. barmyarmy (tracker) - MVP by a country mile. Almost re-defined 'perfection' with his analysis of the write-up, his thoughts on other players, and most importantly the cop saving act he played to deceive the mafias regarding Themer's role. Made it extremely impossible for the mafias to fight back. Like I said earlier, he being recruited by User would have made for a stunning game. All in all, an Artemis Fowl in disguise.
5. Themer (Cop) - Brilliant game. Was intelligent enough to react to barmyarmy's act in a subtle manner and the combination of the duo was simply too good to handle for the mafias. He like hedger, was brave enough to push on swacker's lynch despite the consequences that awaited if swacker wasn't lying.
6. AngryPixel (vigilante) - Funny game. Were it not for his proper analysis of the Night 1 write-up and Colin's witty brain to mark him down as the vigilante, he'd have been all but gone. Was fortunate enough to be unsuccessful in his first mission when an attempted kill on The Rock (now hedger_14) failed, but he made up for his loss and the town's gain by taking down a confirmed double voter in Aditya the following night.
7. Aditya (double voter) - While he didn't contribute anything much of substance to the game, he was just dreadfully unlucky to have been taken down by his own aligned townie in AP on Night 2, especially after being marked down as a confirmed townie.
8. RPHKR (miller) - Poor game. Was more concerned on player's activities than the actual write-ups that had plenty of clues to proceed with. Was really fortunate to have swacker caught suspicious on the other side, when things weren't particularly going well for himself on Day 2, when he almost got lynched off.
9. swacker (mafia roleblocker) - Disappointing debut. Was going pretty well until one stage, where he claimed hedger to be using 'stalling tactics' completely out of the blue. Eventually plotted his down fall. Nothing to feel bad about though, except that he could have conversed a little more with BKB than he'd actually managed to.
10. BKB1991 (mafia godfather) - Good game. Gave it his best shot until his down fall, but his analysis of the write-up (from what I saw in the QT) wasn't particularly impressive, and neither was his interaction with his fellow mafia partner. Did a great job though in preparing an ideal fake claim for swacker that almost got the townies to believe the latter to be a beloved princess. Didn't stand a chance though following swacker's hammer, especially with Colin outwitting every thought of his (most recently the thought that there probably didn't exist a doc).
Bevab
Staff Member
My second win. All of my wins have come when I'm town. I should've won 2 more, but I pulled out in the middle of the game due to inactivity so lost 2 victories easily.
Interestingly all of my official and unofficial wins were when I was town. Not mafia. I'm a lucky town player.
Interestingly all of my official and unofficial wins were when I was town. Not mafia. I'm a lucky town player.
swacker
Chairman of Selectors
- Joined
- Sep 27, 2011
I still have no idea what he meant by that
Because the scum -me- benefit from the day going longer
Similar threads
