I remembered Aussie fans a few years ago holding Bird up as one of the unluckiest cricketers in terms of being born at the wrong time and so went looking into historical Shield records. The only modern players (I’ve taken this as since the 80s) with a decent enough sample size and a better record than him are…
Jhye Richardson (20.78)
Joel Paris (21.20)
…
Bird’s average is a frankly ridiculous 21.99. He has more than double the appearances of Paris and nearly four times as many as Jhye. There are individual seasons like Imran Khan’s and Garner’s which were better but let’s be honest, that is already rarefied air. Scour back through history and the significant names you find being better than him include the likes of
Tiger O’Reilly,
Charlie Turner,
Jack Iverson,
Alan Davidson,
Hugh Trumble,
Charlie Macartney and funnily enough underarm specialist
Trevor Chappell. Some of these cricketers played in an era of entirely different conditions. Our protagonist has a better record than the likes of Lillee and Lindwall (of course this doesn’t mean he’s better than them but it’s incredible statistically). His FC average is funnily enough brought down by his County stints where he has been utterly poor which is quite weird for a pacer who relies on swing and seam.
So the next thing I did was look up if he was a home ground bully and… no. He’s got a better average at the SCG (20.30), Gabba (18.19) and MCG (21.15) than at Bellerive Oval (21.49). The latter is considered to be one of the more green surfaces in Australia whilst the MCG’s flat nature is well known by now. He seems to have a fine record at the Adelaide Oval (22.00) and the WACA (24.54) too. The only places he’s struggled in Australia are the secondary grounds in a couple of states.
Even taking into account his county struggles, the Bellerive boost and the standard of Shield batters being poor during his time… this is an outstanding record... especially for a side that isn’t a traditional powerhouse domestically (they’ve made only two finals during Bird’s career and lost both of them). His BBL performances for the Sixers aren’t great in contrast to his stint with the Stars but he’s been just above average economically (let‘s just not speak about his Blast record) and he’s got a thoroughly average List A record. And if you think he is a relic on the wane these are his numbers from his most recent season…
Shield - 25.96 (second best average behind Siddle and the highest wicket taker for Tasmania while being seventh overall)
Marsh Cup - 41.33 (did only play three games though and other than Siddle everyone else conceded at least one run per over more than him)
BBL - 19.75 (only six games but he did the job economically given he was their most miserly pacer)
Quite simply put… the question that I‘m asking is… how on earth was
this guy not picked till now?