I watched a bit of todays play and I must admit Yasir Shah is a genius. Mohammad Amir performed how I expected him to, good but nothing out of this world. I don't know what Ballance is doing in the line-up, honestly he's such utter crap I'd rather chuck Liam Dawson, Scott Borthwick, Zafer Ansari or any other decent batting all rounder and drop Ali for Anderson and Ball for Stokes. My line up for the second test (I don't know if everyone is fit or not):
Cook
Hales
Root
Spinning all rounder
Vince
Stokes
Bairstow
Woakes
Broad
Finn/Ball/Whoever
Anderson
Also do you guys think Bairstow can bat at 3? Purely on batting (not taking his wicket keeping duties into consideration) I think he could be a good shout but I have a feeling his technique wouldn't hold up against the new ball...
Balance was very lucky to get picked. People like hildreth and borthwock can be rightly annoyed.
The 3 spinners you mentioned are all cry different. Borthwick is a batsman these days. But I think his spin is as good as the majority so he could play as the spinner and bat 3/4 , allowing an extra proper batsman.
Ansari I really like and have seen a lot of whilst at Cambridge, and he will be going to India, but while surrey have shifted him around the order. He would bat 7/8 with Woakes for England. Dawson is Niles behind ansari with bat and ball in red ball, but slightly ahead in white ball formats as far as I can see. But I'd be tempted to pick ansari or even Rashid over Mo if England's top order was working properly
Vairstow isn't a top order player end of, although I'd like in the ling run him to give up the gloves for a proper keeper and bat 5
Vince hasn't done anything for me and shouldn't be there. Hales although cemented for the short term is still a long term issue. But I do like root at 3
For the next test I'd go
Cook
Hales
Root
Borthwick
Hildreth
Bairstow
Stokes
Mo
Woakes
Broad
Anderson
Ali is lucky to stay , but I'd share his overs with borthwock and if borthwock bowls well/better than mo , for the third I'd drop mo for a keeper who can actually keep , which would probably be foakes
The issue for England is that is also basically the team that plays in India. Although I can see moeen sliding up the order for a batsman and the spinner/s coming in that way. All the main spin options bat too, so you'd have a lot of bowlers and a lot of batting if you went something like this , so I'd be picking the best keeper as they can bat 9
Cook
Hales
Root
Borthwock
Bairstow
Stokes /Woakes
Ali
Woakes/ansari/Rashid
Flakes/keeper
Broad
Anderson
India will prepare turners , and if borthwock is playing I'd rather ansari over Rashid for the variety in the spin attack