Overall a good squad for the tour of West Indies. Gotta try a few youngesters. I am not in favour of exclusion of Razzaq from the T20 format. I guess his hard-hitting is very beneficial as far as T20 games are concerned but there is no doubt on the other hand that Razzaq has lost his energy in cricket. It appears to me that his heart is not there when he bats and bowls because he appears so lazy in the field while batting, bowling and even fielding.
But I guess Razzaq's replacement is tough to find for sure. As far as Openers are concerned, Its a good decision to retain Ahmed Shahzad, that guy has the potential to prove the world that he is the most talented batsman in the world currently. Imran Nazir should be selected for the T20 format. You can't judge him on the basis of his domestic performance because our domestic matches are usually a three or four day games and Imran Nazir is not a kind of player of test cricket. However, He always has extra-ordinary performance in the domestic T20s. But I would be surprized if he would be selected anytime soon because he is not that favourite in the eyes of selectors for some personal reasons. The personal liking/disliking you know