I have the wii version.
Offensively it is so much fun, crafting counter attacks by dragging players where you want them to go is about as realistic as you can make attacking, defensively less fun.
Currently in the champions road final of the champions league style cup at the end (on the hardest difficulty) after beating Real madrid 5-4 in normal time in a 10 minute match. I went ahead 3 times, they equalised 3 times, then got a two goal lead with 5 minutes to go, they equalised just as 4 minutes injury time came up, tense as real football.
Got inter in the final, I beat them 6-1 in the group stage, but that was on the second hardest difficulty (I then beat lyon 13-1 (after going 1-0 down!) and decided I was ready for top player)