PlanetCricket First Class Championship

[Chewie]

Use stats to back up your arguments

 

[riz7khan12]

out of the ones that weren't already chosen ofcourse, over the last three years here are the amount of runs and averages of haddin, prior and mccullum.

McCullum played 40 matches with 1692 runs at an average of 45.72 with 4 100's and 9 50's and a high score of 225. While Prior played 47 matches making 1716 runs (4 100's, 12 50's) at a average of 44, so he basically made 24 more runs than McCullum in 7 more matches.

Haddin played 48 matches scoring 1754 runs at a average of 40.79 (3 100's, 8 50's), so 62 more runs than McCullum in 8 more matches.

And if we go by catches then i guess its the opposite order but thats mainly due to mccullum giving up keeping in tests, and we all know that McCullum is clearly the best keeper (athletically) so that settles it.

oh and btw McCullum only has 3 not outs while prior has 5 and haddin has 8 i think.

 

[Chewie]

Those are valid stats but with McCullum his best performances have come against Bangladesh and Zimbabwe, excluding the 225. Prior's record is much more consistent and for the most part better over the past couple of years.

 

[riz7khan12]

dont think nz has played zimbabwe in the last 3 years, and removing test performances against all minnows we get 1395 runs for mccullum (42.27) and 1538 runs for prior (43.94). But Prior has played 7 more tests and made 143 runs more than him.

and over the last 2 years prior has averaged 38.33 while mccullum has averaged 43.77 (excluding minnows) however prior does have 1 more century than him

 

[Bhargav]

Round 1
CG123 - Sachin Tendulkar
Aussie Team - AB de Villiers 
Varun - Dale Steyn
Yudi - Virender Sehwag
bcvstheworld/User2010 - MS Dhoni
rahulkhush - Hashim Amla
Bhargav - Jacques Kallis
riz7khan12 - Alastair Cook
Bevab - Kevin Pietersen
Mohit_dude10 - Jonathan Trott
Dipak - Simon Katich
Iridium - Kumar Sangakkara
Hedger_14 - James Anderson
harrisb - Graeme Swann
p23456789 - Mike Hussey
Prats - Daniel Vettori
Haarithan - Ricky Ponting
Zohaib - Shane Watson

Round 2
Zohaib - Mark Ramprakash
Haarithan - Muttiah Muralitharan
Prats - Zaheer Khan
p23456789 - Morne Morkel
harrisb - Andrew Strauss
Hedger_14 - Shiv Chanderpaul
Iridium - Brett Lee
Dipak - Mahela Jayawardene
Mohit_dude10 - Shane Warne
Bevab - Darren Sammy
riz7khan12 - Harbhajan Singh
Bhargav - Gautam Gambhir
rahulkhush - Rahul Dravid 
bcvstheworld/User2010 - Graeme Smith
Yudi - VVS Laxman
Varun - Thilan Samaraweera
Aussie Team - Ryan ten Doeschate
CG123 - Younis Khan

Round 3
Bevab: Rohit Sharma
Mohit - Subramaniam Badrinath
Dipak: Shane Bond 
Varun - Michael Clarke
Prats - Stuart Broad
---------------
Hedger - Doug Bollinger
Callum - Mitchell Johnson
Riz - Brendon McCullum
Iridium - Chris Gayle
---------------
Haarithan - Matt Prior
Bhargav- Glenn McGrath
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team
---------------
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User

Round 4
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User
---------------
Haarithan
Bhargav
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team
---------------
Hedger
Callum
Riz
Iridium
---------------
Bevab
Mohit
Dipak
Varun
Prats

Round 5
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User
---------------
Bevab
Mohit
Dipak
Varun
Prats
---------------
Hedger
Callum
Riz
Iridium
---------------
Haarithan
Bhargav
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team

Glenn McGrath. Check his stats

 

[CG123]

Yes he's got great stats because he's one of the greats of the modern era, but he's now 41 and he hasn't played FC cricket in over four years.

 

[hedger_14]

Glenn McGrath. Check his stats

lol, yeah. He's one of the best bowlers of the modern era as Callum pointed out. No need to check his stats

 

[Aussie Team]

Round 1
CG123 - Sachin Tendulkar
Aussie Team - AB de Villiers 
Varun - Dale Steyn
Yudi - Virender Sehwag
bcvstheworld/User2010 - MS Dhoni
rahulkhush - Hashim Amla
Bhargav - Jacques Kallis
riz7khan12 - Alastair Cook
Bevab - Kevin Pietersen
Mohit_dude10 - Jonathan Trott
Dipak - Simon Katich
Iridium - Kumar Sangakkara
Hedger_14 - James Anderson
harrisb - Graeme Swann
p23456789 - Mike Hussey
Prats - Daniel Vettori
Haarithan - Ricky Ponting
Zohaib - Shane Watson

Round 2
Zohaib - Mark Ramprakash
Haarithan - Muttiah Muralitharan
Prats - Zaheer Khan
p23456789 - Morne Morkel
harrisb - Andrew Strauss
Hedger_14 - Shiv Chanderpaul
Iridium - Brett Lee
Dipak - Mahela Jayawardene
Mohit_dude10 - Shane Warne
Bevab - Darren Sammy
riz7khan12 - Harbhajan Singh
Bhargav - Gautam Gambhir
rahulkhush - Rahul Dravid 
bcvstheworld/User2010 - Graeme Smith
Yudi - VVS Laxman
Varun - Thilan Samaraweera
Aussie Team - Ryan ten Doeschate
CG123 - Younis Khan

Round 3
Bevab: Rohit Sharma
Mohit - Subramaniam Badrinath
Dipak: Shane Bond 
Varun - Michael Clarke
Prats - Stuart Broad
---------------
Hedger - Doug Bollinger
Callum - Mitchell Johnson
Riz - Brendon McCullum
Iridium - Chris Gayle
---------------
Haarithan - Matt Prior
Bhargav- Glenn McGrath
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team - Ian Bell
---------------
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User

Round 4
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User
---------------
Haarithan
Bhargav
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team
---------------
Hedger
Callum
Riz
Iridium
---------------
Bevab
Mohit
Dipak
Varun
Prats

Round 5
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User
---------------
Bevab
Mohit
Dipak
Varun
Prats
---------------
Hedger
Callum
Riz
Iridium
---------------
Haarithan
Bhargav
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team

 

[Haarithan]

I was double minded whether to go for Prior/Bell before I decided to go with the former. Excellent pick for a third round.

 

[CG123]

He's a decent pick, but I wouldn't say excellent. I'm just looking at his stats, and his test average drops by five if you take out his matches against Bangladesh.

 

[WubbaLubbaDubDub]

Round 1
CG123 - Sachin Tendulkar
Aussie Team - AB de Villiers 
Varun - Dale Steyn
Yudi - Virender Sehwag
bcvstheworld/User2010 - MS Dhoni
rahulkhush - Hashim Amla
Bhargav - Jacques Kallis
riz7khan12 - Alastair Cook
Bevab - Kevin Pietersen
Mohit_dude10 - Jonathan Trott
Dipak - Simon Katich
Iridium - Kumar Sangakkara
Hedger_14 - James Anderson
harrisb - Graeme Swann
p23456789 - Mike Hussey
Prats - Daniel Vettori
Haarithan - Ricky Ponting
Zohaib - Shane Watson

Round 2
Zohaib - Mark Ramprakash
Haarithan - Muttiah Muralitharan
Prats - Zaheer Khan
p23456789 - Morne Morkel
harrisb - Andrew Strauss
Hedger_14 - Shiv Chanderpaul
Iridium - Brett Lee
Dipak - Mahela Jayawardene
Mohit_dude10 - Shane Warne
Bevab - Darren Sammy
riz7khan12 - Harbhajan Singh
Bhargav - Gautam Gambhir
rahulkhush - Rahul Dravid 
bcvstheworld/User2010 - Graeme Smith
Yudi - VVS Laxman
Varun - Thilan Samaraweera
Aussie Team - Ryan ten Doeschate
CG123 - Younis Khan

Round 3
Bevab: Rohit Sharma
Mohit - Subramaniam Badrinath
Dipak: Shane Bond 
Varun - Michael Clarke
Prats - Stuart Broad
---------------
Hedger - Doug Bollinger
Callum - Mitchell Johnson
Riz - Brendon McCullum
Iridium - Chris Gayle
---------------
Haarithan - Matt Prior
Bhargav- Glenn McGrath
rahul - Virat Kohli
Yudi
Aussie Team - Ian Bell
---------------
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User

Round 4
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User
---------------
Haarithan
Bhargav
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team
---------------
Hedger
Callum
Riz
Iridium
---------------
Bevab
Mohit
Dipak
Varun
Prats

Round 5
harrisb
Zohaib
p23456789
bcvs/User
---------------
Bevab
Mohit
Dipak
Varun
Prats
---------------
Hedger
Callum
Riz
Iridium
---------------
Haarithan
Bhargav
rahul
Yudi
Aussie Team

Posted via Mobile Device

 

[Zohaib]

Yudi is banned isnt he?

I pick Imran Tahir

 

[Chewie]

Yudi should be back tomorrow, in the meantime I've pmed him on Cricsim

 

[Zohaib]

My pick still counts right?

 

[Chewie]

Well the next round will begin in 10 minutes. Make your pick again then