PlanetCricket Mafia II - Day 4 (Game Abandoned)

[barmyarmy]

Why on earth would Anish be a mason... ok, I actually want Blitz to character claim now as well.

Why on earth would Anish be town?

 

[CremerCurrans]

Why on earth would Anish be a mason... ok, I actually want Blitz to character claim now as well.

It's true. That's why I didn't see the point in character claiming, it doesn't match with anything logically.

 

[BlitzBerg]

Who the hell did the roles? Its all his mistake. things cannot be right when anish and I are together. And what rubbish it is that I bunked school with him!

To know, I'm the post machine.... I am pallu

 

[puddleduck]

I'm not entirely sold on this whole miller mason thing. Very odd.

It does kind of reek of an intial attempt to save a mafia partner under pressure, and then trying to come up with a reason why one of you would turn up mafia if investigated in an attempt to clear the other.

----------

At the same time, I'm also not sure Pallu and Anish are necessarily mafia... Would expect either banned users or some kind of global moderators seeking to be admins.

 

[Sedition]

Well I doubt any mafia would've tried fakeclaiming those, so the character claims don't hurt if they're true. I can see them being paired together in one way or another.

 

[puddleduck]

I can't help but feel lynching off one of Swirler/Blitz is almost a necessity at this point. It doesn't hurt town too much to do so, in fact it 100% clears or condemns the other. The mafia won't target them either way and it's a waste of an investigative role to check them out.

I almost see this as a necessary evil to lynch one of them. Anyone else agree?

 

[barmyarmy]

Well I think we're being played and would favour lynching off Swirler. Anish and a mason/miller role makes me suspicious. As you say if he comes up mafia we get 2 for 1.

 

[CremerCurrans]

I can't help but feel lynching off one of Swirler/Blitz is almost a necessity at this point. It doesn't hurt town too much to do so, in fact it 100% clears or condemns the other. The mafia won't target them either way and it's a waste of an investigative role to check them out.

I almost see this as a necessary evil to lynch one of them. Anyone else agree?

Well I think we're being played and would favour lynching off Swirler. Anish and a mason/miller role makes me suspicious. As you say if he comes up mafia we get 2 for 1.

I don't see why town members would make this decision? I know I've played badly, and it just sounds like I'm trying to save myself. I'm willing to sacrifice myself, if it proves that at least one of you are mafia. :/

 

[Abhas]

Can anyone give me the link to a spectator / mod QT if you have one?

 

[puddleduck]

My only confusion at the moment is the writeups. It implies the mafia are old members rather than new ones...

 

[barmyarmy]

I don't see why town members would make this decision? I know I've played badly, and it just sounds like I'm trying to save myself. I'm willing to sacrifice myself, if it proves that at least one of you are mafia. :/

How would it prove that one of us is mafia if you've played badly? By definition paying badly means that the town lynch you off when you're a) mafia b) town.

----------

Start​

Earlier, PlanetCricket was successfully saved by the town. The enemies were dealt with severely and all thought they had gone. They had but, no one knew that the new people would be replacing them rather soon. This is PC mafia II.

Nine members were viewing the PC mafia forum when it all began. In these 9, there were some who had it all planned. They wanted to rule PC, they wanted power, they were desperate! After being on the site for some years now, they thought they deserved more. But, they didn't get it. So, they decided to work together.

It was now on the other members to save PC. The problem was no one knew who the other was. Except... Someone had messed up with their usernames. They couldn't even post them. They only had one way out and that was to identify and remove the anti PC group! Will PC be saved again or will the anti PC group prove themselves this time? Let's find out..

PC mafia II begins!
It is now Day 1.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 for a lynch.​

I'd barely even read this before. Nice spot PD.

 

[puddleduck]

Bah, I really don't like first day lynches. I think they always benefit the mafia rather than the town. This is different though.

Firstly, masons who have been revealed within the first day are useless. Mafia won't target them, as they're not power roles, and the town can only confirm their existence by either investigating or lynching one of them. It's basically the equivalent of two vanillas claiming on the first day and narrowing the mafia's night sights.

Secondly, logic would dictate that lynching them on the first day makes most sense, as it clears/condemns the other mason/mafia player without running the risk of getting too deep into the game and being unable to act.

Thirdly, anyone claiming miller on the first day generally gets policy lynched, just because there's no other way to deny or confirm their role.

Fourthly, I've never heard of a miller mason role being used

----------

aaaand finally. Where are the rest of the players. Be nice to get at least some input from somone that isn't Barmy or Me...

 

[barmyarmy]

As a thought we can't even confirm them by means of the cop.

 

[Sedition]

I'd rather lynch Yashdude and if he flips town, lynch Blitzberg tomorrow for bandwagoning. If Yash is mafia, then that confirms Blitz and thus Swirler as town to me. imo.

 

[barmyarmy]

What reasons did we actually have for Yash as mafia?
If he is mafia there's no way Blitzberg could have known it so Yash's status doesn't really change anything.