PlanetCricket Mafia II - Day 4 (Game Abandoned)

Explain to me how it's wrong about Varun. It's not enough to say "it's wrong", you have to construct a plausible alternate narrative (i.e. why he's not jailkeeper or town or dead).
 
I see Ste is around, was viewing the thread earlier too.. clearly the game is on hold until we get the last claim.
 
playing multiple tables of online poker currently so haven't be able to give full concentration, also been trying to sell some equity in other tournaments to friends.

I'll claim now though. I'm bullet proof. reluctance to claim stems from Colin tearing me a new one in my debut game in the role and half-holding out that i can still burn up a night kill.

Character is highlander, former mod, can't be gotten rid of.
 
Bulletproof and commuter sounds pretty weird too.

I was attempting to investigate Ste last night. Not the greatest evidence here, but if Varun was the jailkeeper and also targeted Ste, thereby giving me the no result, then we can clear him of the killing and roleblock at least.

Varun wasn't suspicious of me as far as I can tell, but maybe he was just trying to use the protective side and was actually targeting me, so it's hard to say, but does kinda favour Ste a little imo.

I don't think PD has posted anything since his claim, and virtually everyone has claimed since, so maybe he has something else to add.
 
yeh i'm going to put a FOS on PD I think.

colin said BD can be anti-town role and it seems possible that claimed early and supported the mass claim theory to clear himself and just has bailed thinking he is fine.
 
Assuming Yash is the mafia RB we can control the night activity to some extent. PD needs to not use his role as the mafia could use it to stop themselves being investigated etc. Without the mafia RB I can't be blocked and can protect sedition who can then get a result on PD or ste.
Tomorrow we know who to lynch and then if Manly is telling the truth it's game over and if he's not we lynch him the next day.
 
I used my role on the first night, targeted Barmy and Swirler. So I can't even use it again till the 3rd night anyway. Was unable to use my role, so Yashdude is likely to have targeted me in either town or mafia form.
 
So?
We need a decision here. If we mislynch we lose and no-one is as clear-cut mafia as Yashdude. We'll worry about who his partner(s) are tomorrow.
 
My only worry is that Colin is mafia, Yashdude is town and we have zero chance of stopping a kill by lynching the RB. The other times Colin was mafia, he gave me worse vibes than I'm getting now, so screw it. If Yashdude is town then apologies, but he really hasn't taken much of a role in trying to find mafia, nor have our masons, who should be finding it easier having one extra clear.

Lynch: Yashdude
 
Lynch: Yashdude

As I said before I'm willing to support a lynch against him. Would like to avoid following Barmyarmy, :p but he's done the research and It all makes sense. Looks like the best way to go.

----------

My only worry is that Colin is mafia, Yashdude is town and we have zero chance of stopping a kill by lynching the RB. The other times Colin was mafia, he gave me worse vibes than I'm getting now, so screw it. If Yashdude is town then apologies, but he really hasn't taken much of a role in trying to find mafia, nor have our masons, who should be finding it easier having one extra clear.

Lynch: Yashdude

Haven't been anywhere near as active as I would of liked to be. Can't guarantee that I'll be any more active during the rest of the game. Will do my best to give clear opinions, and help the town in scum hunting when I can. :)

Don't know if that's genuinely your opinion or if you just used that sentence to get us to post. :p
 
I reckon that's the hammer.

Vote count

Yash (5) - Sedition, Colin, Manly, Ste, Swirler
 
That's it.

Yash is dead. He was Fenil - Mafia Aligned.

Night 2 now.
Send your roles to me within 24 hours, thanks.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top