PlanetCricket Mafia II - Day 4 (Game Abandoned)

[Sedition]

He could work for both which wasn't in his control.

This is the main part that implies Jailkeeper to me. Inadvertently helping the mafia by blocking town PRs, or stopping anyone from looking up the JKs target.

Varun didn't seem suspicious of me, so I kinda think we targeted the same person, hence my no result. That person could somewhat be cleared since he couldn't be the killer or roleblocker.

Think we should still hear from Ste and PD and how things might fit together before we lynch Yashdude.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Vote count

Swirler (1) - Ste
Blitz (1) - Manly
Yash (2) - Sedition, Colin

With 8 alive, it takes 5 for a lynch.

@ BB - Please bold your lynch/unlynch!

 

[Manly]

Yet again Colin comes up with the goods!

Unlynch

Lynch: yash

 

[barmyarmy]

This is the main part that implies Jailkeeper to me. Inadvertently helping the mafia by blocking town PRs, or stopping anyone from looking up the JKs target.

Varun didn't seem suspicious of me, so I kinda think we targeted the same person, hence my no result. That person could somewhat be cleared since he couldn't be the killer or roleblocker.

Think we should still hear from Ste and PD and how things might fit together before we lynch Yashdude.

Yes but there are (probably) 3 mafias.

 

[Sedition]

Unlynch: Yashdude

Don't trust Manly at all either. Man, how tweaked am I if Colin, PD and Ste are mafia

----------

I didn't claim just to appease everyone, I did it for answers. A claim from Ste and who PD attempted to switch would be good for starters.

 

[Villain]

Unlynch: Sedition
Major reason: He unlynched me.
Not sure about anyone except PD.

 

[barmyarmy]

@sedition - can you explain how, under any circumstances, yashdude could be town rolelblocker?

 

[Sedition]

I'm pretty sure my lynch will be going back down on him, considering you know, I've been pointing him out for 2 days while no one else has done much. Just not giving the mafia a chance to quick hammer and all but win the game without hearing from at least PD and Ste first.

 

[barmyarmy]

Ste needs to claim really.

 

[Villain]

Don't know how/why you guys can follow Colin blindly? And you guys still remember there are still 8 alive?

 

[Sedition]

That's what makes me wonder about Manly.. has barely mentioned Yashdude as far as I can remember, then is ready to throw the game on the line as soon as Colin says he's mafia. Just as weak a reason as Blitzberg had, if not worse, the guy Manly's been targeting most of the game.

 

[Manly]

I'm following Colin because I literally cannot remember a time he's been wrong about this sort of thing. I'm merely playing the averages!

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm not concerned about who the other mafias are right now although as you say there are clues from the voting.
To be perfectly honest I'm not 100% on Puddleduck anyway. BD can be a mafia role and he's certainly smart enough to claim early to look town.

I wouldn't be confident lynching off anyone except yashdude.

----------

I'm following Colin because I literally cannot remember a time he's been wrong about this sort of thing. I'm merely playing the averages!

Not wrong but I've certainly been mis-leading and got townies lynched as mafia.
If you believe I'm town then you ought to lynch yashdude.

I'm yet to see anyone explain how with Varun as town jailkeeper there could be a town role blocker as well. I'm also fairly confident he wouldn't have claimed town RB if I'd advanced that argument in my post yesterday.

 

[Manly]

Actually if he's mugging us off and has sold me an absolute doozy then I will hold my hands up and change the way I play these things! But I am happy to go with him until such a time. Also I need his help tonight so I better stay on his good side!

 

[Villain]

So sure about me? Can't your judgement be wrong about Varun? Anyways,I don't think anything I do would make you believe me.Go ahead and lose!
Firstly you guys lynch me 'coz was inactive.Then you trust people who roleclaim except me.Anyways,no one trusts me here...