Puddle Mafia 01 - Game over. Town wins.

[ved_]

Somehow I just do not believe Bevab. I am totally not buying his miller claim.
Lynch:Bevab
I did not find anything substantial in the write-up, which you haven't said. All I read through was just about the same as Varun.
One more thing. Aditya lynched me and Bevab at the start. Then he joked about it. As soon as he saw the bandwagon, he somewhat freaked out and suggested that his vote be taken off. If Bevab shows up mafia, then we can also take it that Aditya is mafia, more or less.

 

[Aditya]

Whenever did I ever freaked out and can you point out the post where I requested my vote to be taken off? Seriously, are you kidding me? You go inactive from nowhere, come back online and put suspicion on me without providing any reason that makes sense. You do know that when you put suspicion on someone in mafia games you need to prove your suspicion on that particular member and you're not doing so. Do point out where I freaked out by my vote on Bevab and you. Also do point out when did I ever suggest my vote to be taken off. I'm not impressed by that post at all, Zhourb. Until you prove your suspicion on me, I'm not gonna remove my lynch on you because your last post clearly looks suspicious.

Lynch : Zhourb

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Zhuorb (1) - Aditya
Bevab (1) - Zhuorb

With 8 it takes 5 to lynch. I'm off out. See you all tomorrow

 

[pcfan123]

Interesting they went after Sedition. You could say that he is the one who "protected" Bevab by not hammering.

 

[Varun]

Sedition was constantly posting about the possibilities of insane/paranoid/naive cop etc and ways of testing out the sanity of cop. Since this is one of the strategies cops usually employ to not give themselves away, the mafia might have thought that it was a good chance Sedition himself was the cop.

 

[pcfan123]

Somehow I just do not believe Bevab. I am totally not buying his miller claim.
Lynch:Bevab
I did not find anything substantial in the write-up, which you haven't said. All I read through was just about the same as Varun.
One more thing. Aditya lynched me and Bevab at the start. Then he joked about it. As soon as he saw the bandwagon, he somewhat freaked out and suggested that his vote be taken off. If Bevab shows up mafia, then we can also take it that Aditya is mafia, more or less.

I don't see the Adi connection.

Miller still makes no sense but I'm less sold on Bevab today than I was yday. I thought for sure it would be Colin or someone leading the charge taken out last night

 

[barmyarmy]

Only just got back from cricket so I've not a chance to read the write-up properly. I suspect it contains some cryptic clues etc.
@Mark - love the sig. Don't love the "if Colin's not dead he must be mafia" insinuation

 

[ved_]

Whenever did I ever freaked out and can you point out the post where I requested my vote to be taken off? Seriously, are you kidding me? You go inactive from nowhere, come back online and put suspicion on me without providing any reason that makes sense. You do know that when you put suspicion on someone in mafia games you need to prove your suspicion on that particular member and you're not doing so. Do point out where I freaked out by my vote on Bevab and you. Also do point out when did I ever suggest my vote to be taken off. I'm not impressed by that post at all, Zhourb. Until you prove your suspicion on me, I'm not gonna remove my lynch on you because your last post clearly looks suspicious.

Lynch : Zhourb

I state a possibility, you get so defensive? Sounds like you are freaking out again, bro.

You do realize I didn't just lynch Bevab but also Zhourb? I lynched them both as they were lynching each other for no reason but then again as we often lynch members for no reason at the starting of the game, I did the same but we do unlynch them later but I didn't got the chance to as I didn't come online yesterday after putting my lynches on them both but it's good that Puddleduck removed my lynch. Jeez, these days whenever I lynch someone for fun on day 1 it is taken seriously.

FOS : Bevab

So, err...what was that eh? Bevab was hammered, but PD took your vote off. I feel that you were somewhat relieved after seeing that and hence this post. Then, to appear towny, you gave the FOS.

There actually is no reason for that post, Aditya. Basically, you see somebody FOS'ing you and are scared, get defensive all of a sudden, but then after 2-3 lines in the post you now get aggresive and counter-attack. Bad play, Aditya.

I still have no reason to unlynch Bevab. BKB has not posted after the write-up yet, so lets all wait for his post too.

Also, I kinda went inactive for the past 2 days because my internet was down, and my ISP wasn't even responding to my messages. I was viewing some threads on my mobile, but it was hard to post through it, just because I was using my mom's phone, and it ain't a QWERTY phone.

That's all I got till now, I'm off to play football on a rainy day. Going shopping for the Sunday, so I won't be back till about 10 hours atleast.

 

[Manly]

Just got in from work, I'll post when I wake up. (Won't be early haha)

 

[Aditya]

I state a possibility, you get so defensive? Sounds like you are freaking out again, bro.

How am I getting defensive? My lynching you is defensive? Me telling you to point out the post where I freaked out on my lynch on Bevab is defensive? I'm telling you to point out the posts to support your suspicion is defensive?

So, err...what was that eh? Bevab was hammered, but PD took your vote off. I feel that you were somewhat relieved after seeing that and hence this post. Then, to appear towny, you gave the FOS.

You "feel" that I was somewhat relived? How exactly do you feel I'm relived? And where in that post was I freaking out? You clearly mentioned in your last post that I freaked out to see Bevab getting just about hammered but yet, you don't show the post where I freaked out and also where am I suggesting PD to take my vote off on Bevab? He did that himself, I never told him to remove my lynch and after playing so many games, wont I know that we're not supposed to lynch two members at a time!

If I and Bevab were actually working together, wont I unlynch him before going offline so just in case, if other members lynch him, he isn't hammered. You say something in one post and say otherwise in the other, you're clearly confused. TBH, you're playing like a "typical" mafia or simply very very badly as a townie.

----------

In that case, I will have only 1 vote on me.

That's Zhourb's post after my lynch on him was removed and put on Bevab instead. At that time, he didn't mentioned anything at all about me lynching two members at a time because he was now having no lynches on him.

Bevab, you are only 1 vote away from the hammer. And yet you don't want to role-claim? Seems like you are buying some time... That is a very scummy thing to do bro.

Here Zhourb is asking Bevab to role claim. I agree with him, taking too much time for a defense is scummy but when that post was posted it had not even been a day since the game had started but him asking Bevab to role claim, was the right thing to do.

Somehow I just do not believe Bevab. I am totally not buying his miller claim.
Lynch:Bevab

Here, considering that Zhourb asked Bevab to role claim, I expect a much detailed post from him, stating why doesn't he believe Bevab's claim. Simply because he is a miller? If this was so easy, then I would have lynched him just after he role claimed. The thing is, in the last few games we've had millers and in this one, we can have one too but why doesn't Zhourb think this way is beyond me. Bevab's timing of role claiming was wrong but we need to discuss about it before blindly lynching him.

Zhourb is posting very less and yet trying to be very smart and getting from any suspicion at all. I expect a good defense from him or else I'm not putting off my lynch on him because I've provided enough reasons for my lynch on him.

----------

Meh, that's a pretty long post but we need a few to get some discussion started. We need to go beyond Bevab too but at the same time, he needs to be more active or else he is the one who has been under suspicion since day 1.

 

[barmyarmy]

He had made preparations during the day, whiled away lazily eating expensive capicola and enjoying the panic. This was his doing. There was no going back, and now it was getting late. The silent embrace of darkness bestowed upon him the comforting cloak of anonymity and fed the ravenous appetite of his devilish machinations. It was time to head to the strip club for the real work. Sitting in the back office of Duckton's premier female exploitation venue, he makes a phone call. It rings just once before cutting off. The gentleman smiles briefly to himself. Shortly, it will be time to strike. It begins.

This must refer to the godfather. As far as I can tell he is ordering the kill rather than doing it himself.

Camped out in the top floor of a dilapidated and run-down building his night was a success.

Sounds like a watcher or tracker.

It was still pouring outside, but he knew he'd have to venture out. He locked up his desk and made his way towards the building's car park exit. He thought back to his last good holiday, boating near Paris in the north of France with his partner. Those were the good times. Those were the memories that still shined. He got into his well travelled vehicle and switched on the radio. Pink Floyd soothingly greeted him... ?Remembering games and daisy chains and laughs? he sang along blissfully before stopping abruptly. "Strange" he thought as he switched it to the right frequency, ?I could have sworn I filled her up.?

Locked his desk suggests an investigative role to me. Tank empty implies role blocked. Not sure about the other stuff.

He had spent the day mobilising the town against the new threat. This town was important to him, he'd lived in it for his entire life. He remembered learning to ride his bike in the community park that he was currently meandering through, the rush of feeling unstoppable, the wind flying in his face, and his proud father beaming a smile at him from behind a camera. The warm recollection caused his neck to gently tingle in the present. His oversized Dunlop umbrella was doing a good job of sheltering him from the rain, and his thoughts again drifted pleasantly backwards as he passed the children's playground he had spent many a summer evening drunkenly abusing in his teenage years. Tomorrow was a fresh day with new hope, and with the town's forces all in action he had high expectations of as rapid a resolution to the situation as possible. The rain continued to drive down hard around him, maybe it had even got harder, and as he exited the park and turned into the side alley that led to his house, he felt a sharp and sudden pain pierce precisely into his back and through into his heart. The man turned to see his killer, but nothing more remained other than a shadow fading into the nothingness. His eyes closed, and then he felt the ground hit his knees, ?perhaps I'll rest here for a minute? he struggled to think as he lay down on the drenched concrete. His body relaxed into the claret bed that rapidly formed around him. This town was important to him, and he'd lived in it for his entire life.

This refers to sedition but I would assume such florid prose has more meaning than just that

Looks like we have a cop, a roleblocker and a tracker. Role blocker is probably mafia so mafia team is likely to be Godfather, goon (who does the kill) and godfather.

 

[barmyarmy]

Right I've re-read the whole thread and, aside from bevab who I still think is mafia, I'm also suspicious of Aditya.

He was careful to accuse bevab and FOS him but not actually hammer him. Also I agree that he is being over-defensive about a nothing allegation which is often a mafia tell.

So, in the interests of moving the game along, lynch Aditya.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

Vote Count

Zhuorb (1) - Aditya
Bevab (1) - Zhuorb
Aditya (1) - Barmyarmy.

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

 

[Aditya]

I'm being over defensive? When someone provides a defense in a much detailed manner it's an issue when someone doesn't provide a defense at all then also it's an issue. Help me understand, I'm being lynched for what? For stating that I believe a miller could be in this game or for simply defending myself. If defending myself gets me lynched then why should I even bother providing a defense when you guys clearly have got no evidence whatsoever against me.

----------

Also Colin, if you're still suspicious of Bevab why are you not lynching him but me instead? If you look through the thread he has looked more suspicious than me and yet I'm the one who you lynch.

 

[barmyarmy]

I'm pretty sure he is mafia. I'm just trying to find other mafia as well. Having failed to get him lynched off yesterday I'm trying a different tact today.