puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Time Alert
There are 27 hours left in the day period. Extensions can be requested.
There are 27 hours left in the day period. Extensions can be requested.
Puddle Mafia 01 - Game over. Town wins.
- Thread starter puddleduck
- Start date
Aditya
ICC Board Member
That's no answer to my question. You're looking for other mafia's, that's good, I'm too. I find Zhourb suspicious and I've mentioned various reasons for my suspicion on him. If you're still persisting with Bevab than that's weird to say the least because you didn't have anything to say about Zhourb even though he has lynched me for no reason and what you have done is, to follow him.
What exactly are your thoughts on Zhourb? I haven't mentioned that Bevab is cleared for me but at the same time, Zhourb's sudden suspicious play has got me more suspicious of him than Bevab. Zhourb says I freaked out when I saw Bevab just about to being hammered and yet he doesn't point out the post where I freaked out. You've got nothing to say about it? Instead, you lynch me because I didn't support your lynch on Bevab. Since when you started playing like this, Colin?
What exactly are your thoughts on Zhourb? I haven't mentioned that Bevab is cleared for me but at the same time, Zhourb's sudden suspicious play has got me more suspicious of him than Bevab. Zhourb says I freaked out when I saw Bevab just about to being hammered and yet he doesn't point out the post where I freaked out. You've got nothing to say about it? Instead, you lynch me because I didn't support your lynch on Bevab. Since when you started playing like this, Colin?
Aditya
ICC Board Member
Correct me if I'm wrong, you're saying that Zhourb saying that I freaked out when I saw Bevab just about to get hammered was true even though he didn't point out the post (because there isn't any) and you also agree that I "requested" PD to take my vote off from PD. Colin, TBH you're a great player and when you are not considering these obvious facts than I've no other option but to be suspicious of you.
I've not tried even once to deflect suspicion from Bevab. I did say that we should give him time to defend himself, once he defended himself I wasn't particularly happy with his defense but with Sedition posting some good facts at the end of the day about why we should wait another day to lynch Bevab, I was convinced not to lynch Bevab. Now coming into day 2, I was ready to lynch Bevab but Zhourb's post changed my mind and it's beyond me how you all don't find him suspicious. He is trying to put pressure on me without any evidence and that's clearly what a mafia will do.
I've not tried even once to deflect suspicion from Bevab. I did say that we should give him time to defend himself, once he defended himself I wasn't particularly happy with his defense but with Sedition posting some good facts at the end of the day about why we should wait another day to lynch Bevab, I was convinced not to lynch Bevab. Now coming into day 2, I was ready to lynch Bevab but Zhourb's post changed my mind and it's beyond me how you all don't find him suspicious. He is trying to put pressure on me without any evidence and that's clearly what a mafia will do.
P
pcfan123
Guest
Adi, getting defensive enough? Sheesh
Varun
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 14, 2009
- Location
- Delhi, India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
TBH, I'm fed up of this discussion over Aditya, and of reading his long posts which essentially repeat the same arguments again and again. I do believe that Zohaib's reasons for Aditya weren't really justified, but I've been suspicious of Aditya because of the way he's been posting. His posts are plenty and long, but have little substance in them, and mostly repeat the same thing over again and again. I feel he's trying too hard to be 'active'. Still, we need to let him be for the day.
Coming to Bevab, his apparent apathy has really put me off. I have really stressed that he needs to post more to let us judge whether he's a miller or a mafia, and even though he should have nothing to fear if he's the miller, he's not responding (Ironically enough he's got more posts than me.). The cop's never going to know at least until Night 2, and anyway could probably have been roleblocked on Night 1. All this makes me believe Bevab is mafia, and coupled with the 'safe' miller claim, isn't bothered about the game.
I'll up for lynching Bevab if we reach a unanimous decision, but before that happens, I'm not lynching anyone.
And yes, BKB needs to post. I see Manly's said he's going to later in the day, but BKB hasn't come online from 8th.
----------
*since 8th.
Coming to Bevab, his apparent apathy has really put me off. I have really stressed that he needs to post more to let us judge whether he's a miller or a mafia, and even though he should have nothing to fear if he's the miller, he's not responding (Ironically enough he's got more posts than me.). The cop's never going to know at least until Night 2, and anyway could probably have been roleblocked on Night 1. All this makes me believe Bevab is mafia, and coupled with the 'safe' miller claim, isn't bothered about the game.
I'll up for lynching Bevab if we reach a unanimous decision, but before that happens, I'm not lynching anyone.
And yes, BKB needs to post. I see Manly's said he's going to later in the day, but BKB hasn't come online from 8th.
----------
*since 8th.
Aditya
ICC Board Member
There ya go, finally someone admits that Zhourb's reasons to lynch me are not justified. I've posted the same thing again and again deliberately because no one has actually put stress on my points but instead repeated the same question again and again rather than actually questioning Zhourb, you guys are actually questioning me and my long posts in my defense which is seriously beyond me. Just like in Zhourb's case, I asked him to put forward some evidence but he didn't. I'd not put forward any defense in my favor now, I've posted enough. If you guys are still not convinced than it's seriously very poor play from the townies.
Tomorrow, I'd look through the thread and try to analyze everyone's gameplay so far.
Tomorrow, I'd look through the thread and try to analyze everyone's gameplay so far.
P
pcfan123
Guest
BKB and Manly being quiet. Manly just checked in with a useless post and has no heat on him.
FOS a few right now. Manly, BKB, Bevab, Zhurob and possibly Adi. Although I remember last game I played Adi pleaded his innocence the same way and was innocent.
FOS a few right now. Manly, BKB, Bevab, Zhurob and possibly Adi. Although I remember last game I played Adi pleaded his innocence the same way and was innocent.
Had a quick read through and it's interesting to see, as has been pointed out, how defensive Adi got when pressure's been put on him, as well as jumping to Bevab's side. Right now I'm thinking those two are mafia.
I've got a decent role this time round, wasn't mentioned in the write-up but then again I didn't get a result. (Note: my role was used successfully however.)
I'm at work tomorrow so I think the deadline will have expired by the time I can log on again.
Therefore lynch: aditya. - For the excessive (in my opinion) defensiveness despite the absence of any substantial pressure.
I've got a decent role this time round, wasn't mentioned in the write-up but then again I didn't get a result. (Note: my role was used successfully however.)
I'm at work tomorrow so I think the deadline will have expired by the time I can log on again.
Therefore lynch: aditya. - For the excessive (in my opinion) defensiveness despite the absence of any substantial pressure.
puddleduck
Chairman of Selectors
Vote Count
Zhuorb (1) - Aditya
Bevab (1) - Zhuorb
Aditya (2) - Barmyarmy, Manly.
With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
Zhuorb (1) - Aditya
Bevab (1) - Zhuorb
Aditya (2) - Barmyarmy, Manly.
With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.
BKB1991
Panel of Selectors
sorry for the delay busy days.
Aditya I agree with Varun, you are basically saying the same things again. Try using points would help everyone.
I cant read too much from Adityas posts, when hes pressured he always demands hard core proof, which in mafia you pretty much never have.
Its the case of choosing between Bevab and Aditya. Bevabs simply gone missing and I think he posted in other parts of the forum, so hes probably deliberately hiding himself. And if hes town he shouldnt have the reason to do so. Furthermore I believe the cop should be smart enough to go and investigate Bevab so lynching him should clear whether hes insane or normal.
Also Colins mentioned it, and I will state again there seems to be two mafia, the godfather + roleblocker (strip club hint - hooker in epic mafia).
Lynch: Bevab
Aditya I agree with Varun, you are basically saying the same things again. Try using points would help everyone.
I cant read too much from Adityas posts, when hes pressured he always demands hard core proof, which in mafia you pretty much never have.
Its the case of choosing between Bevab and Aditya. Bevabs simply gone missing and I think he posted in other parts of the forum, so hes probably deliberately hiding himself. And if hes town he shouldnt have the reason to do so. Furthermore I believe the cop should be smart enough to go and investigate Bevab so lynching him should clear whether hes insane or normal.
Also Colins mentioned it, and I will state again there seems to be two mafia, the godfather + roleblocker (strip club hint - hooker in epic mafia).
Lynch: Bevab
Aditya
ICC Board Member
Haha yeah, I realize I've posted the same thing again and again. 
As far as asking for "hard core proof" is concerned, when Zhourb pointed out the "freaked out" thing and me asking PD to remove my vote, I just told him to point out the post which he didn't, I don't think this can really be called asking for "hard core proof/s".
I'm still hesitant to remove my lynch on Zhourb, he hasn't been active throughout this game but then that's the case with Bevab too. If anything, I'd request PD to maybe contact them via pm and ask them whether they want to be replaced.
After reading the thread all over again, it's between Zhourb and Bevab for me. These two have been very inactive, Bevab has been poor with his defense whereas in Zhourb's case you might call me selfish but considering that he's not posting anything at all after putting some pressure on me, does make me suspicious of him. Though, I can switch my lynch to Bevab as he's not posting at all.
@Colin - What do you make of Zhourb's gameplay so far?
As far as asking for "hard core proof" is concerned, when Zhourb pointed out the "freaked out" thing and me asking PD to remove my vote, I just told him to point out the post which he didn't, I don't think this can really be called asking for "hard core proof/s". I'm still hesitant to remove my lynch on Zhourb, he hasn't been active throughout this game but then that's the case with Bevab too. If anything, I'd request PD to maybe contact them via pm and ask them whether they want to be replaced.
After reading the thread all over again, it's between Zhourb and Bevab for me. These two have been very inactive, Bevab has been poor with his defense whereas in Zhourb's case you might call me selfish but considering that he's not posting anything at all after putting some pressure on me, does make me suspicious of him. Though, I can switch my lynch to Bevab as he's not posting at all.
@Colin - What do you make of Zhourb's gameplay so far?
