Puddle Mafia 04 - Endgame Mafia (barmyarmy, BKB, RPHKR win)

[Varun]

No discussion only helps the mafia? You sure about that, Colin?

Yes, it does. And excessive discussion helps the mafia as well. But why are we debating about this yet again?

Haven't seen RPHKR as well in the last few pages.

 

[Manly]

All I'm saying is that treva is always quiet when he is mafia and we've not heard from him in a while....

 

[barmyarmy]

I've said it many times before. Check back through other games.
No lynch should ultimately be the result on day 1 unless someone does something really stupid but there are too many people here who are prepared to add nothing to the discussion and then stick a no lynch in.
That tells us the total sum of nothing.

There isn't nothing to discuss on day 1; it's a good chance to pressure some people, see how they react, see who supports them - all info you can use later.
Just giving up on discussing anything or pressuring anyone only benefits mafia players.

----------

Yes, it does. And excessive discussion helps the mafia as well. But why are we debating about this yet again?

I don't think we're in any danger of that...

----------

All I'm saying is that treva is always quiet when he is mafia and we've not heard from him in a while....

Lots of people are staying under the radar but for some reason Aditya is happy with that.

 

[Manly]

Who else is? I guess having roped him into the game I'm more aware of Jack's silence and probable play.

 

[Aditya]

We all know who are under the radar although if not pointing it out means that someone is happy with it, then perhaps I am.

 

[barmyarmy]

Who else is? I guess having roped him into the game I'm more aware of Jack's silence and probable play.

I'm glad you asked
Posts since game started (not including sign-up etc)

barmyarmy 27
User2010 15
Manly 11
Aditya 9
Sedition 6
BKB1991 6
thedon5 3
Varun 3
Zhuorb 2
ste_mc_efc 2
Abhas 1
Papa Smurf 1
Treva 1
RPHKR 1

FOS: Abhas, Papa Smurf, Treva, RPHKR

 

[Manly]

In addition: FoS: don, Varun, Zhuorb, ste

 

[barmyarmy]

Very uneventful day.

No Lynch

What do you want me to say? Repeat the same observations others have made several times? Say "I'm here, but I have nothing productive to say, oh and btw I'm going to lynch this guy for no real reason"?

There's been very little other than the usual back and forth from you and Sedition, as well as some useless lynches here and there. The same could be about pretty much everyone in the game.

What about Mr. Meme?

Especially as these were thedon's two posts.

 

[Abhas]

Right, apologies for being inactive (again!). Been a hectic week with festivals in our part of the country, and work commitments requiring a majority of my time. I should be relatively free tonight onwards.

Not sure what to make of the quick lynches on User after mine, but definitely something that I'll keep in mind.
His response was a bit too weird for his standards. Looks like he's trying to be neutral towards me than get into a duel.
Definitely FOS worthy, and I'd like to keep my lynch on him for the time being.

@Sedition, Good try, but you are unlikely to get much from my posting style.. It's still day 1 and there is nothing to start upon.

 

[thedon5]

I don't understand what's so suspicious about my posts? Anyway, as I said, the same could be said about most of the players in the game so far.

With ste, you don't want to give him a free pass, but still, he's new. Can't be expected to be posting detailed analyses of the write-ups when he doesn't know what SK means.

 

[puddleduck]

Vote Count

User (3) - Abhas, Manly, Barmy
Manly (1) - Sedition
No Lynch (4) - thedon, User, Aditya, BKB

With 14 alive it takes 8 to lynch. There are 2 hours left in the day.

 

[Manly]

We'd better hope for the best then.

 

[barmyarmy]

Danger is that with time limits like this in place mafia players can get off the hook and survive the day phase.
Hopefully we'll have enough night role info to get someone tomorrow.

 

[RPHKR]

Sorry, I haven't been in home since a while. So couldn't post.

@Barmy - My post had a lot more detail than many others. Quality matters. Haven't had much opinion since that.

No discussion only helps the mafia.

We haven't got anything to add up now since it's day 1. Though, I agree discussion helps us a lot.

What about Mr. Meme?

Ste doesn't know what's SK, we can't expect him to post a lot(in day 1)

2. PD giving the vote count every other post is really annoying.

Not really. If it does, then just ignore it.

Is it possible that KP is a SK and when Matt Prior 'cures' him they become sort of masons?

A possibility. But it isn't 'essential'. The mod would have got this idea only after your post.

 

[Varun]

I am having trouble following the game with so many people and so little information and it has been a long time since I played such a large game so I am up for no lynch, which is what we're inevitably going towards it seems.

No Lynch