Recess Mafia - Mafia (Hedger & IceAge) Win!

[themusketeer]

Oh and wait, @shoaibakhtar it a part of this too....
.

No, I replaced Shoaibakhtar.


As Most of the Guys Here thinks that My posts looks Scummy and I am Mafia alingned. I guess I will be lynched Soon.

I know I am Defending Myself very poorly,but it will get better when I gets more experience in Mafia games.

So I have to say just one thing to My Fellow Townie that If I gets Lynched today then You all will surely Lose Your eye.

 

[Sulaiman7]

So I have to say just one thing to My Fellow Townie that If I gets Lynched today then You all will surely Lose Your eye.

What are you trying to say?[DOUBLEPOST=1419863229][/DOUBLEPOST]@themusketeer, who are you most suspicious of rather than Joe?

 

[Varun]

Anyway, joejoe is a much better lynch than musk in my honest opinion, merely based on team reads. I think Varun has a good chance of flipping scum, which I think he would push more on joejoe than bus in this situation, or just wait for them to claim before putting more pressure on.

And since I don't think both varun and thedon are town, and if thedon is mafia, I think his entrance in agreement with musk makes them look like a non-team, thus would lean on joe being more likely scum (I can see thedon busing the way he did, with only very slight pressure on joejoe).

How is joejoe a much better lynch based on team reads? Not getting your logic there. The second sentence of the first paragraph doesn't even make sense.

Have to say, I love that logic. 'I feel that Varun and thedon5 are scum, therefore joejoe is scum because they're not lynching him'[DOUBLEPOST=1419867752][/DOUBLEPOST]

What are you trying to say?

Do you think he's implying what I think he's implying. As bad a defense that is though. He lynched El Loco, right?

 

[Sulaiman7]

Do you think he's implying what I think he's implying. As bad a defense that is though. He lynched El Loco, right?

Wait..he lynched Loco? Am I missing something here? can someone please quote that post where he did that. I can't find it.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Vote count:

joejoe (3) - hedger, themusketeer, thedon
themusketeer (3) - IceAgeComing, El Loco, Varun

With 10 alive, it takes 6 for a lynch


I will extend the day till Jan 2 as most people will be busy till then and maybe you guys can reach a majority before that.

 

[El Loco]

Wait..he lynched Loco? Am I missing something here? can someone please quote that post where he did that. I can't find it.

He put a finger of suspicion on me lol, not a lynch. I still agree that his play has been scummy, but let's be careful not to exaggerate how scummy his play has been, or we'll start getting misconceptions.

After going through all this, i get scummy behavior from EL loco's posts.
I think he is most likely to be mafia alingned.

FOS : EL loco

Don't think I can add anything else at this stage.

 

[El Loco]

So I have to say just one thing to My Fellow Townie that If I gets Lynched today then You all will surely Lose Your eye.

I'm not cyclops so I think I'll be fine

 

[Sulaiman7]

it doesn't change the fact that themuskateer is equally suspicious since he lynched El Loco and later said that it was random.

Okay, so since musketeer just FOSed Loco, he shouldn't be equally suspicious to you now, right?

 

[Varun]

But then his FOS was random as well. And I don't feel it was random. Wtf I'm just too confused atm

 

[Villain]

I'm not convinced enough to lynch any of the two but if I've to then would be Joe for me, my reason for that is pretty clear as they do appear a bit suspicious to me especially Joe as he's even yet to reply whereas Musk has at least tried to defend himself which isn't solid enough anyway. But if we go through the votes it's unlikely of both of them to be mafias as half the players are against them. What concerns me now is Joe could possibly be a mafia as we witnessed a failed kill on Night 1, could be a newbie not knowing what is he supposed to do? Musk knows what a mafia is supposed to do as he seems to be a bit experienced. I'll wait for Joe's last call.

 

[Sulaiman7]

Joe for me, my reason for that is pretty clear as they do appear a bit suspicious to me especially Joe as he's even yet to reply whereas Musk has at least tried to defend himself which isn't solid enough anyway.

Exactly, that's what I've been saying all day about this situation.[DOUBLEPOST=1419947730][/DOUBLEPOST]

I'll wait for Joe's last call.

You mean claim?

 

[IceAgeComing]

I'm still reading the thread. As much as I've moaned about other people saying this, I have nothing more to add at this time. Nothing has changed IMO; I still have a scum read on themusketeer and more of a newbie read on joejoe although that doesn't mean that I'm holding him up as innocent. Everyone else is still indistinguishable at the moment: I'm getting town vibes off of El Loco but its hard to tell about lots of the game partially because of the way discussion has gone (sporadic and IMO not very useful day 1 and early day 2; and then this argument over two players; it allows people to hide easily) and partially because of limited activity during the holidays...

Although giving @joejoe018 a prod might be a good idea: I'm aware that its still around the festive period and so forum access isn't something that is particularly easy. Just a note: this may be my last post before a 2nd January deadline: I may be able to check in tomorrow afternoon if anything changes but its hogmanay so I'll be very busy that evening and I have family commitments (and a mega hangover, most likely) on New Years Day. I'll try to check to see if anything changes before then and react to that of course: but I only see three results at the moment: a musketeer lynch; a joejoe lynch or the town being equally divided and having yet another no lynch which would be bad for the town because it means that we'll most likely have a NK Night 2 and unless we get something revealing from a role claim we end up where we are now... None of those bar the second one would cause me to act in any particular way: and it'd take something big for me to change my vote in that sort of way.

 

[Sulaiman7]

I don't know if that 'lynch on Loco by musk' was an intentional thing to get joe off the radar or just a misread by Varun. Probably a misread since he was the one to make sure of what happened else I was going to go on the wrong way (thinking that Musk did lynch Loco). Lynching and having a suspicion on someone are two totally different things, we can't just say that a random lynch is equal to a random suspicion. I'd like to hear more from Varun. Both Musketeer and Joe are newbies and have no idea about what's going on but at least musk is trying something meanwhile Joe's sitting and eating popcorns, I don't know how you guys are getting newbie (scum) reads off Joe and not off Musk. Not trying to defend him but trying to make things fair.

 

[Varun]

I'd like to hear more from Varun.

I was just trying to entertain the possibility that themusketeer might be a cop, if you must hear.

 

[Sulaiman7]

I was just trying to entertain the possibility that themusketeer might be a cop, if you must hear.

Yet you lynched him?