Recess Mafia - Mafia (Hedger & IceAge) Win!

[Varun]

I never considered the possibility before he posted "surely you'll lose your eye". You'd notice that I tried to keep it subtle first. Did I forget to unlynch him? If yes, Unlynch: themusketeer.

 

[Sulaiman7]

I never considered the possibility before he posted "surely you'll lose your eye". You'd notice that I tried to keep it subtle first. Did I forget to unlynch him? If yes, Unlynch: themusketeer.

That's why I believe Joe's a better lynch. And ye you did forget.

We're waiting for claims, right?

 

[El Loco]

Forgive me, but I'm going to be honest and say I don't think I'm totally convinced. There's a bit of time still left in this day, so I'd like @joejoe018 to come back and and try and save himself from being lynched as there is greater pressure on him.
Although I guess could be swayed from my lynch now, which is more than could be said before.

However...If Muskateer is as he says "our eye", well, I was the first one he placed a FOS on after this day began. So what does that suggest? That's why the lynch stays for now. Apart from me, Joejoe is the only other player he has knocked on, and that started on Day 1. So it'll take a lot more than that to win me over, personally.
I'd like to also point to that Muskateer has actually posted to lynch Joejoe twice: Once for not having posted, and the second time for FOSing him.

 

[joejoe018]

Sorry I thought this was held off over Christmas.

 

[thedon5]

My lynch on joejoe remains. This is one of the slower games I've seen...

 

[joejoe018]

My lynch on joejoe remains. This is one of the slower games I've seen...

I don't run this what do you want me to do about the pace of the game?

 

[hedger_14]

How is joejoe a much better lynch based on team reads? Not getting your logic there. The second sentence of the first paragraph doesn't even make sense.

Have to say, I love that logic. 'I feel that Varun and thedon5 are scum, therefore joejoe is scum because they're not lynching him'[DOUBLEPOST=1419867752][/DOUBLEPOST]

Do you think he's implying what I think he's implying. As bad a defense that is though. He lynched El Loco, right?

I feel dumber after reading that.

What I'm saying is I can't see both you and thedon being town. If you are scum, then I don't think you are scum with musk because your interactions are TvM or possibly TvT but your play suggests otherwise. I still fos joejoe the most which is along with my read on you makes him a better lynch than musk in this situation. What don't you understand by that logic?

Same goes with thedon. thedon lynched joejoe so not sure on that logic? but the way in which he agreed with themusketeer and then proceeded to lynch joejoe just doesn't seem like something thedon would do if musk was his partner especially as he had barely said anything all game.

I was just trying to entertain the possibility that themusketeer might be a cop, if you must hear.

The way you replied to sulaiman is absolute bullshit. "If you must hear", adding something that you know better than to let the mafia know of your possible pr reads. There's no reason for a town to be doing that unless they're commenting on a claim but since nobody has claimed no reason to out those reads, especially towards the end of a day when mafia are about to have another shot to kill. That reply is forced and given the forced nature if you were trying to reply with all your thoughts surely you'd have more by this stage of the game.

I'm really tempted to flip my lynch to you but I still think joejoe is a better lynch, and the fact half of the game has ignored you means even if I wanted to lynch you it'd be hard to flip this at this stage but for the moment a strong:

FOS: Varun

 

[Gaurav_7]

Okay, you have 24 hours for the day to end! No extension will be provided.[DOUBLEPOST=1420086350][/DOUBLEPOST]Vote count:

joejoe (3) - hedger, themusketeer, thedon
themusketeer (2) - IceAgeComing, El Loco

With 10 alive, it takes 6 for a lynch

 

[Villain]

Lynch: joejoe018
No lynch won't help at all and I've already stated the reasons above for lynching him. His last few posts aren't much of help either.[DOUBLEPOST=1420100960][/DOUBLEPOST]

You mean claim?

Not particularly.

 

[Villain]

The way you replied to sulaiman is absolute bullshit. "If you must hear", adding something that you know better than to let the mafia know of your possible pr reads. There's no reason for a town to be doing that unless they're commenting on a claim but since nobody has claimed no reason to out those reads, especially towards the end of a day when mafia are about to have another shot to kill. That reply is forced and given the forced nature if you were trying to reply with all your thoughts surely you'd have more by this stage of the game.

I'm really tempted to flip my lynch to you but I still think joejoe is a better lynch, and the fact half of the game has ignored you means even if I wanted to lynch you it'd be hard to flip this at this stage but for the moment a strong:

FOS: Varun

Gotta agree on that as it definitely sounds scummy but it could also be a town letting people know Musk might be having a PR role?

Hedger's aggressiveness makes me pretty sure he's just a vanilla townie/no PR whatsoever. That's my gut feeling anyway.[DOUBLEPOST=1420101714][/DOUBLEPOST]I'd personally like to hear the reasons of @Simon for not lynching any of the two as he's reading the thread.

 

[Villain]

I don't run this what do you want me to do about the pace of the game?

Would you like to speak anything in your defense mate?

 

[Villain]

I also have a feeling of a possible mafia team consisting of Joe - Loco - IceAge.
Both Loco and Ice have been distracting town and taking Joe outta people's radar by lynching/adding a suspicion on Musk. They've quietly backed Joe too. Please don't get me wrong on this but I just went through the thread all over again and this is my final analysis. It could obviously be wrong.[DOUBLEPOST=1420102570][/DOUBLEPOST]This might just be clear if Joe comes out as a mafia.[DOUBLEPOST=1420102629][/DOUBLEPOST]* This might just get cleared if Joe comes out as a mafia.

 

[El Loco]

I also have a feeling of a possible mafia team consisting of Joe - Loco - IceAge.
Both Loco and Ice have been distracting town and taking Joe outta people's radar by lynching/adding a suspicion on Musk. They've quietly backed Joe too.

What a bizarre interpretation to make. I haven't found reason to fervently back anyone so far. I just find more things suspect in Muskateer's play than I do in joejoe's. I won't much care whose radar joejoe is on until I can find conclusive evidence to vouch for him being town, which I can't. Otherwise I'd be urging everybody to unlynch him.
I don't think you'd have reached this conclusion if the majority was leaning to lynch Muskateer.

If joejoe does get lynched and it is revealed that he is Mafia, I don't fear the egg on my face, but I will definitely be looking for Muskateer to contribute a lot more.

Edit - The forum is messing with the font size of my posts for some reason. Just letting you know in case emphasis is place on summat that shouldn't be.

 

[Sulaiman7]

First of all and most important of all: Lynch: joejoe.

Gotta agree on that as it definitely sounds scummy but it could also be a town letting people know Musk might be having a PR role?

Nah, this was in my opinion always going to be a Joe lynch, specially with everything that has happened on this page. How's letting town know that Musk might be a pr by first lynching him and then saying "Oh I forgot to unlynch him? unlynch him"? That's total nonsense. I was always on the go for lynching Joe as to be quite honest, Musk was giving me some kinda townie vibes but I wasn't too sure of it that's why I consider Joe as a better lynch than Musk and not someone else. Even if I believe that you did make a mistake there, Varun, why would you reveal your read that too in the end of the day as Hedger pointed out? you're scummy, no doubts.

FOS: Varun

 

[Villain]

Fair enough and as I said I could obviously be wrong. It's understandable that you shouldn't be the one we go after Joe's role is revealed as you might have had made a mistake which anyone of us could on having a better read on him. I also find your reason for not lynching him quite acceptable too.