Recess Mafia - Mafia (Hedger & IceAge) Win!

[Villain]

The above post was a reply to Loco.

 

[Varun]

There's no reason for a town to be doing that unless they're commenting on a claim but since nobody has claimed no reason to out those reads, especially towards the end of a day when mafia are about to have another shot to kill.

Really? There is a definite reason. If it's true, then themusketeer's FOS on El Loco would make some sense, would hint towards something. Do you think the mafia would be stupid enough to not see that possibility already, especially if El Loco was mafia? I'm sure that puts the doctor on alert as well. It kind of puzzles me why you of all can't figure it out hedger. Remember, we know nothing about this game. At least for now I don't. It's perfectly alright to reason things out. I don't really see how it puts themusketeer in danger. If I was mafia, I wouldn't think of targeting a new player like themusketeer at night irrespective of his role. It's more complicated than you think it is, unless you have more information about the game than me. Then I would like you to explain it all a bit more.

 

[Varun]

First of all and most important of all: Lynch: joejoe.

Nah, this was in my opinion always going to be a Joe lynch, specially with everything that has happened on this page.

What exactly has happened on this page? I'm not really getting you. Maybe you're town Sulaiman, at least you look like one right now, but I don't really see how joejoe was always going to be lynched despite him not being able to give any defence. It seems to me more like you're lynching off a newbie because well, we have to. At the most it's a shot in the dark. With all my experience, I can't really be sure about him being mafia. First of all and most important of all? Not really. I'll have to look back to see who instigated the lynch on joejoe, but if he's town, then it makes a lot of sense to get him lynched because the mafia would've better players to target at night.

 

[Sulaiman7]

What exactly has happened on this page? I'm not really getting you. Maybe you're town Sulaiman, at least you look like one right now, but I don't really see how joejoe was always going to be lynched despite him not being able to give any defence. It seems to me more like you're lynching off a newbie because well, we have to. At the most it's a shot in the dark. With all my experience, I can't really be sure about him being mafia. First of all and most important of all? Not really. I'll have to look back to see who instigated the lynch on joejoe, but if he's town, then it makes a lot of sense to get him lynched because the mafia would've better players to target at night.

The previous page, Joe was the only topic there so that's why I said and I believe that it's Joe who's getting lynched. Other than that, a no lynch is not going to help us so I don't see that coming unless a mafia gets the hammer? but then he would be exposed so can't happen. You guys (who have lynch on Musk) might switch to Joe but I'm sure that neither of us is going to switch the votes. You've your answer there already, he didn't defend himself, but Musk did - so it's pretty obvious who we're lynching. Are you in the mood of going for a no lynch? I don't get this - "It seems to me more like you're lynching off a newbie" - seems like you have other options? By the first of all line, I was bearing in mind the lynch and not the person.

Look, neither of us is too sure about who the mafia is from the two suspects I shall say since he still has some lynches on him, Musk, so, if either of them turns townie this doesn't mean that any of us was trying to defend the partner and switched the topic to the poor defenseless townie (which can be either of them). I've suspected and FOS'ed both of them and in my opinion, Musk has been a tad more convincing than Joe.

 

[Sulaiman7]

Really? There is a definite reason. If it's true, then themusketeer's FOS on El Loco would make some sense, would hint towards something. Do you think the mafia would be stupid enough to not see that possibility already, especially if El Loco was mafia? I'm sure that puts the doctor on alert as well. It kind of puzzles me why you of all can't figure it out hedger. Remember, we know nothing about this game. At least for now I don't. It's perfectly alright to reason things out. I don't really see how it puts themusketeer in danger. If I was mafia, I wouldn't think of targeting a new player like themusketeer at night irrespective of his role. It's more complicated than you think it is, unless you have more information about the game than me. Then I would like you to explain it all a bit more.

Makes sense. Either way, we'll have a mafia lynched or caught, right?

 

[Varun]

So um, I'm not really sure when the day ends. It's supposed to have been ended. Joejoe's one away from the hammer. I can do that, although I don't feel inclined to. No one else seems active..

 

[Sulaiman7]

I can do that, although I don't feel inclined to.

You mean you're forcing a no-lynch which never helps the town?

 

[SiriusBlack]

edited

 

[El Loco]

Can't say I'd be surprised if joejoe turned out to be Mafia but I still don't think I want to chip in with the hammer as I still maintain that Muskateer's play has been more scummy. Take issue with me if you must, but that's my view. I'll be more than happy to eat my words if I'm wrong.

Edit - Although I don't and can't have a full picture of who the Mafia are right now, it's easy for them to manipulate the lynch in their favour at this stage, so what I do now can't have much of a bearing at the moment, if it's not in line with the majority.
But as I said, I'm willing to accept my mistake if joejoe comes out as scum.

 

[IceAgeComing]

Are we on L-1 still, or was Simon's vote the sixth?

I agree with everything that El Loco said above: it is possible that he is scum but I just feel that themusketeer is much more likely to be mafia-aligned. For that reason, I'm not going to hammer since I'm not entirely convinced that it'd be a good thing for the town to do

 

[IceAgeComing]

Just done an quick vote check: I have us at six votes so unless I've missed an unvote somewhere the day is done. You usually can post in the twilight of a day although its not the time to have in depth discussions because you'll probably get interrupted by the night and the start of the next day will be shaped by both the lynch and the NK...

 

[Varun]

You mean you're forcing a no-lynch which never helps the town?

It isn't a rule. It always depends.[DOUBLEPOST=1420224885][/DOUBLEPOST]Okay, no point dabbling over it I think. User's not been online?

 

[joejoe018]

Lynch: themusketeer. I have to vote for someone and he is the only other person getting voted on.

 

[hedger_14]

Do you think the mafia would be stupid enough to not see that possibility already, especially if El Loco was mafia? I'm sure that puts the doctor on alert as well. It kind of puzzles me why you of all can't figure it out hedger.

Well certain players have different pr reads. It's not smart making it perfectly known. If he came out and said "I'm a vanilla townie", then I can see why you'd say that but not otherwise.

And not sure what I'm not figuring out? Although thinking about it, musk having a guilty report on loco could make sense, as loco has been more aggressive towards musk, rather than joejoe who has done even less that's townie than him.

I want a joejoe lynch today and I honestly think that's the best way to go. His defence has been non-existent and I'm sorry but unless he posts something of a strong contribution or has a solid claim, I'm keeping my vote up.

 

[thedon5]

The thing with new players is that it's never a big risk to lynch them off, especially in a bigger game like this. Unfortunately usually they aren't going to add much even when they're alive. So in other words it's worth the risk.

We'll see how it turns out, I think he's Mafia. If he isn't then we need a bigger push on day 3 as people such as myself are in the background doing nothing.