The Silence Of The Lambs Mafia - Endgame - SK (Sulaiman7) WINS

[thedon5]

Which one, Don? I didn't get what you were referring to.

That I am suspicious of Zhuorb. He's not off my list, but the write-up does suggest that he is telling the truth and so are you. His play has been a bit off which is why I was suspicious of him earlier, but it is possible to play like that when you are town.

Colin is easily the one I'm most suspicious of.

If I had to pick a second, it would be Sulaiman. But the fact that Colin is after him in the way he is makes me a bit hesitant to lynch and I feel he should actually try to defend himself.

The thing is, only townies ever give up. When there are Mafia, especially a team, they'll never give up. If he was getting cues to soft claim, chances are his partner is the leader and there's no way his partner's going to let him go down like this. That was a loose lead I brought up about his soft claiming, and it was a hunch which isn't necessarily true looking at what has happened since.

What if he is Mafia and I am the one stopping him from being lynched? Bad luck, but not the end of the world as it's still 3 vs 2.

I think an extension would be appropriate @Varun with P Squared's situation. If he is back in a couple of days he will be ready for day 3.

 

[Varun]

I'll see..

 

[P Squared]

Well I was only gonna be gone for a day, I thought this (game)day would be over by then so I asked for a replacement. Guess it isnt though.

So

Lynch:Sulaiman

Reasons stated earlier.

 

[thedon5]

Interesting. I hope it's the right choice.

 

[ved_]

Btw If Sulaiman flips mafia this is pretty much an auto-win.

 

[thedon5]

Btw If Sulaiman flips mafia this is pretty much an auto-win.

How?

All we know is that if he flips town we've lost.

 

[ved_]

Yeah the game swings either way.
The write-up has clearly indicated the presence of Starling and Chilton, so surendar's report on either you or barmy will give away the remaining mafia.

 

[barmyarmy]

No talking after the hammer folks.

 

[Varun]

That's the hammer. Write up coming up.

 

[Varun]

Vote count:

Sulaiman7 (4) - surendar, barmyarmy, Zhuorb, P Squared
barmyarmy (1) - thedon5

Day 2
​

All throughout the town there were uproars for the public lynch of Sulaiman. For some reason he couldn't be killed though.

It's Night 2, send in your roles. You have 24 hours.

(day writeups are flavor)

 

[Varun]

Night 2​

Death loomed.

-X-

"I'm having an old friend for dinner."

-X-

"We're best friends, c'mon! Still you need to...?"

-X-

This wasn't supposed to end this way.

Day broke. It was a tragedy.

surendar is dead. He was:

Clarice Starling, Protagonist, Town Aligned

Zhuorb is dead. He was:

​

Dr. Frederick Chilton, Crime Doctor, Town Aligned

It hasn't ended yet. It shouldn't. It's Day 3. 3 for a lynch.

 

[surendar]

Damn! Told ya all!

 

[P Squared]

fearsome tweak. Probably an SK. And this means 1 mafia+1 SK.

Why couldn't Sulaiman be lynched though,to anyone who has watched the movie- does the character that he claimed have anything to do with this? Because if it doesn't then he's probably an unlynchable mafia, and there's nothing we can do about that. Or maybe he had a one time lynch immunity, but we can't be sure. Or maybe he is the SK. fearsome tweak, so many possibilities.

----------

Or this could be a town vigilante as well, in which case only 1 mafia, but that would be unbalanced imo

 

[thedon5]

Sulaiman's character is nothing special, it is the definition of vanilla. But he's not vanilla.

From the write-up it's clear that Hannibal killed Chilton and then you'd have to assume the Mafia killed Clarice. The best friends line suggests that Clarice investigated me, since my role is "Best Friend", and obviously verifies me as a townie.

P Squared is obviously 100% town, so the anti-town roles are Colin and Sulaiman as I expected. I still have a feeling the two of them are a team and Sulaiman had some sort of ability that meant he couldn't be lynched or something, hence why he didn't defend himself and hence why Colin jumped at the chance when surendar had a lynch on him.

I guess an SK is equally possible too, but that doesn't explain why Sulaiman wasn't killed.

Anyway, perhaps there's some sort of condition where Sulaiman can't be the first to be lynched out of anti-town roles?

Whatever it is, we know who to lynch now and to avoid the same thing happening again, we'll go for Colin like we should have yesterday.

Lynch: barmyarmy

 

[barmyarmy]

Damn it. I used my role to save Sulaiman and prove myself as town but looks like it led to an extra death.
Mafia team of Sulaiman and probably thedon5.

Lynch: Sulaiman

----------

Edit: "probably" because P Squared could still be mafia and playing a blinder but I think he's 95% town.