The Simpsons Mafia - Game Over : TOWN WIN > Player Reviews

BKB1991
Mark
Riz7khan12
Yudi
Aditya
User2010
Varun
Bevab
Meet
ARay
Abhas
Chewie
CG123

From the members left, really not much to decide on. With the numbers going down, Riz % of being a smart mafia player has gone up.
Abhas is a strong player, the fact that he has yet to be targeted gives me doubts in my mind.
The 1st write up was the clue. Mark did find the an evil soul till it disappeared. Because I switched it. It makes more sense.
Either way thats two strongly probable mafia players.
We will need to lynch either one today. We will get hit at night.
Need to hit the 2nd again. Another of us will be taken out.
Still one more anti-town is remaining. Two townies will remain in the end.

Last day townies need to lynch the right person.
Looks like we need to role claim now. There is no other way to win this game. If we mislynch today, game is up. We are hanging just by a thread at this point.
 
lol so you're actually going with Bevab? well this looks like that abhas might be right with his cult recruitment theory and you might be the head recruiter. btw i'm learning as i go (being my second game), how am i supposed to "lead" a lynch without experience? and btw isn't that something that a mafia member would try doing?... get the town confused then killed. which you pretty much did to yudi.

Unless you do not lead, you do not learn. I am certainly no head recruiter. I am Otto mann. Bus driver of the town.
My role has consecutively been shown at night phases. Anyways yudi lynch was done with a proper basis ( if you did read my reasonings earlier).

I should say though, you did play decent game. Its a pity because I think you would have been really a huge bonus as a townie to us.

----------

I can whine, right? Varun, feel like killing you! :mad

ahhhh well, new players will learn this way :p
Don't hint as strongly as a doc next time though. I mean you had done a superb job as a cop in the last game.
 
Don't hint as strongly as a doc next time though. I mean you had done a superb job as a cop in the last game.
Couldn't have saved myself after Varun revealed everything. I feel I was pretty safe till that time maybe. I hope town somehow wins this. Hit the right button!
 
My thoughts:

ARay - Bus Driver
Riz - Role Blocker
Abhas - ninja (cult)
Varun - mafia
Bevab - townie
Aditya - One of the top two mafia
Chewie - me

Good explanation over there, but Riz is a mafia and might be a roleblocker of Mafia. i feel Aditya is a townie because he has not been much hinting as a mafia guy.
lol so you're actually going with Bevab? well this looks like that abhas might be right with his cult recruitment theory and you might be the head recruiter. btw i'm learning as i go (being my second game), how am i supposed to "lead" a lynch without experience? and btw isn't that something that a mafia member would try doing?... get the town confused then killed. which you pretty much did to yudi.

now then i'll help as much as i can, i have a strong feeling that sideshow bob's wife tried killing lisa today and that member would be the cult and as for the ninja... bart was a ninja in one of the episodes but why try killing your sister.

Well done Riz, trying to divert attention to the Cult eh? We want a mafia member here first and that is you!!
My doubts on you has increased and now I'm 70% sure that you're mafia.
Even Abhas has been diverting attention to the Cult. So it makes me feel he is also a mafia member. And finally I don't think so Abhas is a cult guy given he is trying to attract attention for the cult.
 
Change the title Mad, it is not attracting attention.:p
 
Sick of telling everybody that I'm a townie. And what role does that Ninja offer to do? If I don't even know that.

Abhas says you were a townie, The cult recruits members from town to their group i.e. convert them into cult members. I've a strong feeling Aditya is the cult and Bevab's the new recruit.

My thoughts:

ARay - Bus Driver
Riz - Role Blocker
Abhas - ninja (cult)
Varun - mafia
Bevab - townie
Aditya - One of the top two mafia
Chewie - me

I think there are two role blockers - the town and mafia ones. Will have to go through the writeups again for any clue.

Well done Riz, trying to divert attention to the Cult eh? We want a mafia member here first and that is you!!
My doubts on you has increased and now I'm 70% sure that you're mafia.
Even Abhas has been diverting attention to the Cult. So it makes me feel he is also a mafia member. And finally I don't think so Abhas is a cult guy given he is trying to attract attention for the cult.

Bevab wants a mafia member first and not the cult. I feel Riz didn't try to divert attention but speculate.

But cult is as dangerous as mafia to us, why get the mafia first? Shouldn't we aim to get them both? Or are you trying to save yourself?

FOS : Bevab
 
My thoughts:

ARay - Bus Driver
Riz - Role Blocker
Abhas - ninja (cult)
Varun - mafia
Bevab - townie
Aditya - One of the top two mafia
Chewie - me

Any idea why you think that I am mafia? I mean any evidence?
 
Abhas says you were a townie, The cult recruits members from town to their group i.e. convert them into cult members. I've a strong feeling Aditya is the cult and Bevab's the new recruit.



I think there are two role blockers - the town and mafia ones. Will have to go through the writeups again for any clue.



Bevab wants a mafia member first and not the cult. I feel Riz didn't try to divert attention but speculate.

But cult is as dangerous as mafia to us, why get the mafia first? Shouldn't we aim to get them both? Or are you trying to save yourself?

FOS : Bevab

There are only 2 cult guys here while there are nearly 3-4 mafia members here. So I think its better to lynch a mafia member.

Also Riz is not basically helping the town in terms of mafia area. What do you say about that?!.

And please don't expose more roles Varun. But I think with nearly all roles out there are no important roles here.

Riz is trapped, he can't role-claim doc, cop, tracker or even a townie. Lets squeeze him and get that mafia guy.
 
And please don't expose more roles Varun. But I think with nearly all roles out there are no important roles here.

You don't know my role yet. ;)

----------

Also Riz is not basically helping the town in terms of mafia area. What do you say about that?!.

It's his first game, and therefore he is probably trying to hold his tongue, but I don't really know. He needs to answer some questions now.

----------

Could you give us some justification of your behaviour, Riz?

----------

I am rather confused on Abhas and Aditya now. Both have played normally though, Abhas is an experienced one and Aditya is an inexperienced one.
So, according to the style of play, I suspect Bevab, Abhas or Aditya as mafia. Can't say about Chewie but I feel he is a townie.
 
Guys its time to character claim!
There is no point in discussing this any further than this.
We don't have a choice right now.
Riz is mafia. I am pretty sure of it by now. When the number of players go down.
The % chance of certain players shoot up.
But to be 100% sure, we need to character claim!
There is no point in keeping our role hidden anymore because if we lynch wrong today. The game is up.
I cannot stress enough the importance of mass character claim.

----------

Any idea why you think that I am mafia? I mean any evidence?

Its all probability now. You are the few unknown people in the game whom we have not been able to effectively clear out as townie.
Hence you being mafia is a possibility.
 
Possibility and being a mafia are two different things. Lynching me without any good reason will effect the townies only because I'm not mafia.
 
Possibility and being a mafia are two different things. Lynching me without any good reason will effect the townies only because I'm not mafia.

Character claim then if you really are townie.
I really don't think at this point you should be worried about dying at night. Because if you really are townie, we are losing the game by tonight if we dont lynch correctly.
 
I agree that today is the best time to role claim. We need to know all the information we can so that we can make informed decisions, and then hopefully it one of us dies, all this information doesn't go to waste. I wanted to wait until closer to the end of the day before doing so, to see if any of the arguments made by people would suggest themselves to be mafia. I don't really think they have but ARay might want to go back through the posts to check.

I think some people have guessed, but I am Lisa. I can send the name of one person in, and get a return of who they were seen around that night. This makes me pretty powerful, as combined with the night posts I can figure out who is who. I also had a 'bulletproof vest' which makes me immune to one killing, and hence the reason why I survived last night despite being attacked by the ninja. I hadn't role claimed earlier because I knew I would be safe until someone tried to kill me once. Now that someone has tried, that person knows who I am, and will probably attack me tonight, and so I have to role claim.

What I've done in my role as tracker:
First night I investigated Callum who didn't do anything.
Second night I investigated Riz who was seen around User2010
Third night I investigated Mark who did not use his role
Fourth night I investigated Abhas and he was seen around me.

What I found the second and fourth nights is interesting. Riz is the role blocker, and I have been trying to steer the votes in his direction for a while now, but without much success. He hasn't done anything in this thread that would be too suspicious, and it is only recently that we have been accusing him. Abhas I feel is the ninja, though I am rather confused about the write up. I don't understand the broken glass, but according to the write up he was the only one who was targeting me, and therefore this makes him ninja, and therefore cult.

This somewhat explains the following post I made:
My thoughts:

ARay - Bus Driver
Riz - Role Blocker
Abhas - ninja (cult)
Varun - mafia
Bevab - townie
Aditya - One of the top two mafia
Chewie - me

Wanted to throw a bit of stuff around to see what people said. Nothing really came out of it though. Varun and Aditya were just random guesses, but I think there are only three townies left, and it makes more sense that the bus driver is townie, and that Bevab is is townie too. Bevab posted that he was suspicious of both Riz and Abhas, who happened to be the two people I knew were anti-town, one being Mafia, and the other cult. Because of this I don't think he'd be on either of those two sides. It is entirely possible though that the mafia are planning to mislead us, and get rid of their least important character in Riz, but I feel that role-blocker is sufficiently important not to do this.

This has hopefully sparked a lot of thought into how this information can be used. I don't think I can be of much further help as I fear I will be killed tonight. With this I will Lynch: Riz and FOS: Aditya, Varun, Abhas, and would like Aditya and Varun to role claim if by chance there does happen to be a fourth townie.
 
One more vote for Riz to be out. Why don't you self lynch yourself Riz?:p

DO some justice to the town atleast now. For Bilal and Yudi lets lynch him.

According to Chewie's theory Abhas as a cult seems plausible.

Varun or Aditya lynch Riz right now.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top