max_dillon2007
School Cricketer
Warner>Tendulkar. Oh Basil.
Are u serious?
Anyway, it is true that a few failures are not enough to drop someone. But it is also true that few initial success gaurantee a great player. Here are 2 examples. Ever heard of Vinod Kambli and Shahi Afridi. These two have treid their best to waste their talent. Shahid afridi scored 37 ball hundred in his second ODI and Vinod Kambli Scored two double centuries in his debut test series at the age of 19. Now everyone knows what happened to these.
Also, it is not necessary that great players have great starts. Sachin and Ponting both are regarded as the best batsmen in world cricket. but it took 80 odd ODI's for tendulkar to score his first 100. And Ponting has peaked only after 2002 though he had debuted in 96 or 97.
I am not starting any comparison between players. All i am trying to say is that it is too early to draw any conclusion on Warner. Give him 2 years. After then we can see how he had performed,as by then he would have played against most of the oppositions.