Commonwealth Bank Series (Australia, India, Sri Lanka)

[aussie1st]

Looking at sniko it made a sound after clipping the pad imo.
What happened to hot spot though that would be perfect for this.

 

[SaiSrini]

It wasn't out but in this case I think it was a pretty tough call to make for the umpire, seeing as the pad was so close to the bat. Also, how Clarke finished in his follow-through might have had an influence on the umpire's decision.

It was OUT!

 

[angryangy]

thats a rubbish decision, clarke didnt get near it with his bat.

the two big queenslanders will put on 200 no worries.

Bad decision, but a forgiveable decision. The snick was loud for pad.

 

[The Majestic]

It wasn't out but in this case I think it was a pretty tough call to make for the umpire, seeing as the pad was so close to the bat. Also, how Clarke finished in his follow-through might have had an influence on the umpire's decision.

True.

You take the good with the bad, I heard the nick and thought it was out but saws the replay and saw it wasn't, but the old ump doesn't get the replay so we have to accept his decision.

 

[vaibhav mehta]

Well Hayden need to stick there for real long.Until he is there,there won't be any problem with Run rate..Aussis can't effort one more wicket..
Match is really getting his charm..

 

[aussie_ben91]

It was OUT!

Are you blind?

Sniko clearly shows it missed the bat and hit the front pad.

 

[k3nichi]

Clarke was GONE! The snicko showed clearly that there was a sound immediately when the ball passed the bat. IT WAS OUT!!!! DAMN SURE!!!!

replay shows it hit the pad

 

[SaiSrini]

Well Hayden need to stick there for real long.Until he is there,there won't be any problem with Run rate..Aussis can't effort one more wicket..
Match is really getting his charm..

Why worry abt Australia? they have their supporters who can worry for him... lets worry about india

 

[shravi]

It was OUT!

Trust me, I think everyone thought it was out at first sight; Snicko suggested otherwise. When Snicko was used, the noise was shown when the ball was a fair bit closer to his pad than it was to his bat.

 

[SaiSrini]

Are you blind?

Sniko clearly shows it missed the bat and hit the front pad.

No need to be that harsh here! According to me, it looked OUT! I too am watching the same game.

 

[The Majestic]

No need to be that harsh here! According to me, it looked OUT! I too am watching the same game.

In real time it looked out, slowed down in a replay it showed it wasn't out, but the umpire's decision stands, so he is out.

 

[vaibhav mehta]

Well it doesn't make difference now it was out or not?
Officials have given their decision which always could go anyway..
We have to live with these type of errors..

 

[SaiSrini]

Got to get Symonds out. He seems to have a good record in CB series finals (saw on cricinfo).

 

[Will_NA]

Well it doesn't make difference now it was out or not?
Officials have given their decision which always could go anyway..
We have to live with these type of errors..

Tell Steve Bucknor that.

 

[surendar]

Got to get Symonds out. He seems to have a good record in CB series finals (saw on cricinfo).

If I am right, one of the finals included, from 10/3 to Aussies ending up with a dominating total of 300+ because of the heroics from Symonds. ( Against Lankans ? )