Cricket 19 General Discussion
- Thread starter Parcelmoose
- Start date
blockerdave
ICC Chairman
We can all agree this edges given not out is awesome and shouldn’t be changed right?
I’m yet to see one given wrongly out when it didn’t hit bat or glove yet. Hopefully that’s there too
I’m yet to see one given wrongly out when it didn’t hit bat or glove yet. Hopefully that’s there too
Short Leg Cricket
Associate Cricketer
- Joined
- Apr 21, 2019
- Profile Flag
- New Zealand
Yes don’t change it it’s great and a lot of fun! Plus, I’ve been really happy when I bowled mostly spin and taken a wicket LBW only for it to be overturned on review. It’s not ideal to me but it is realistically and really a good feature that the umpire can make mistakes like real life. Congrats Big Ant this game is very playable and I’m addicted!
Kiko_97
User Title Purchaser
- Joined
- Aug 5, 2007
- Profile Flag
- England
Yeah it's definitely not reported as a bug. I loved it happening to me.
blockerdave
ICC Chairman
I think in one post @DalePlaysSports referred to himself as being “apocalyptically angry” at a bad decision which I’ve definitely been too, but it’s still awesome
zafar_sheikh
Club Captain
- Joined
- Apr 12, 2019
It happened with me quite a few times while batting as well as while bowling
Ed Smith
Gaffer
i think even if its a clear edge we still need to press the appeal button if we dont appeal it goes not out most of the time.
DAP
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Mar 11, 2012
- Location
- India and Hong Kong
- Profile Flag
- India
- Online Cricket Games Owned
- Don Bradman Cricket 14 - Steam PC
Mine came at a really bad time, I did mention it here. If I had a review left, I would’ve got a hat-trick
[DOUBLEPOST=1564124245][/DOUBLEPOST]
I think it happened to me with a LBW as well, given out when it was missing the stumps. Kind of makes the game realistic.
blockerdave
ICC Chairman
Mine came at a really bad time, I did mention it here. If I had a review left, I would’ve got a hat-trick
[DOUBLEPOST=1564124245][/DOUBLEPOST]
I think it happened to me with a LBW as well, given out when it was missing the stumps. Kind of makes the game realistic.
I’m playing a test match league with 80s teams and rules so no reviews, and made custom umpires all with much lower stats so I’ve had both edges and lbws given wrong both when I’m batting and bowling.
It’s not that often, so it’s not detrimental it adds to the fun. Lbws I’ve had both ways - given not out when plumb or given out when missing, but edges I’ve only had given not out when edged, ever given out when missed or hit body etc.
Snowy
ICC Board Member
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2013
- Profile Flag
- Australia
Have you had the AI ever appeal when you’ve swung and missed?
Amritkhaira
School Cricketer
- Joined
- Jul 7, 2019
Cant delete the scenario after downloading scenario from community challenges.
There is only back option button no delete button option.Once we finish playing the scenario should have the option to delete it.
There is only back option button no delete button option.Once we finish playing the scenario should have the option to delete it.
blockerdave
ICC Chairman
Not sure if ever when I’ve completely missed, but definitely when I’ve missed and it’s hit the arm or body yes, though it’s never been given out
wasteyouryouth
Verified
You could try moving the sliders up half way in between Easy and Medium. I was playing half way between Medium and Hard and then I lost my settings, now I'm playing on Hard. The jumps between difficulties are not good, so it can help to move up slowly.
Similar threads
