I don't think the side is too bad, just always seem to be a couple of changes required whenever they pick a squad. Given the players available for selection right now, I think we should have gone for:
Jonathan Trott
Craig Kieswetter +
Ed Joyce
Kevin Pietersen
Paul Collingwood *
Eoin Morgan
Luke Wright
Graham Napier
Graeme Swann
Stuart Broad
James Tredwell
I'd actually be happy to stick with that top 6, even when Strauss is back too. Joyce was magnificent in OD cricket last year, and how he hasn't got a call-up to be in the squad at least I don't know. Strauss hasn't been great in ODi's, and I'd be happy to leave him out if Joyce and Trott score runs. With Jimmy and Fred both out, I've gone for James Tredwell and Graham Napier to boost the bowling. I'm still trying to work out why the 2nd spinner wasn't played on that surface for the first game, especially considering Fat Sid's looked terrible in ODi's for a long time. Prefer Napier to Shahzad and Sidebottom too, but wouldn't be too fussed if it was Plunkett that came in. Looks a much better side than the shambles that is the England ODi squad for this series.