Expert Cop Mafia 2 - Endgame Mafia win

[treva]

Thanks Colin

I investigated Hedger and got town result. So I'm either naive or normal.

 

[MaD]

Ok, I investigated hedger and got town aligned

 

[Haarithan]

Okay that just about clears me along with ARay, who was in the clear yesterday.

Hedger - normal/paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
treva - normal/naive/mafia (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Aray - normal/naive/insane (MaD as town)
Haari - paranoid/insane/mafia (treva as mafia, hedger as mafia)
MaD - normal/naive/mafia (Haari as town, hedger as town)

Haari as mafia:

Hedger - normal/paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
treva - normal/naive (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Aray - naive/normal (MaD as town)
MaD - normal/naive (Haari as town, hedger as town)

Not possible 'cause MaD has to be insane if I were really mafia. But it's already proven that he can only be normal/naive. Hence I'm in the clear.

So it's one of MaD/treva who's mafia.

----------

MaD - normal/naive (Haari as town, hedger as town)

This has to be MaD - naive if I were mafia. Either way, it does only lead to me being cleared. Because treva and ARay are normal/naive and naive/normal, so there cannot be a third possibility of a naive cop.

 

[Haarithan]

Oh wait, ARay isn't cleared yet. Damn!

Aray as mafia:

Hedger - paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
treva - naive (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Haari - insane/paranoid (treva as mafia, hedger as mafia)
MaD - normal/naive (Haari as town, hedger as town)

Possible with MaD being normal.

So as it stands, only I'm cleared.

 

[Gaurav_7]

What? Haari here as well?

 

[barmyarmy]

He replaced Highlander999.
He's modding rather than playing the other game.

 

[treva]

Okay, so I assume Haari is the paranoid cop with two results of mafia.

What's the next step then? Are we still waiting on ARay's 'investigation'?

 

[Haarithan]

I could well be insane too...
As for our next step, yeah, we'll be needing ARay's result overnight to figure out if we can narrow our suspect list down further. After which comes a no lynch.

 

[ARay]

Hmmm that does not clear anything out. I investigated Hedger and got town as well. I will be doing my analysis in a bit

 

[ARay]

Okay,
Hari as Mafia:

Treva: Normal/ Naive - (Investigated ARay, Hedger)
MaD: Naive - Investigated Hari, Hedger)
Me: Normal/ Naive (Investigated MaD/ Hedger)

This means Hari is clear.

Next given Hari's Role he came up as Paranoid cop. With the 3 of our investigation (Treva, MaD, Me). Neither of us are the insane cop.
This means that Hedger was the Insane cop.

Given that, MaD is cleared. Since Hedger got MaD as mafia on day 1

This leaves the choice between me and Treva. I know I am not mafia, thus the logical choice for me is treva.
Lynch Treva

----------

I could well be insane too...
As for our next step, yeah, we'll be needing ARay's result overnight to figure out if we can narrow our suspect list down further. After which comes a no lynch.

How are you insane with 2 mafia results?

 

[Haarithan]

Hedger - normal/paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
treva - normal/naive/mafia (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Aray - normal/naive/mafia (MaD as town, hedger as town)
Haari - paranoid/insane/mafia (treva as mafia, hedger as mafia)
MaD - normal/naive/mafia (Haari as town, hedger as town)


treva as mafia:

Hedger - paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
Aray - normal/naive (MaD as town, hedger as town)
Haari - paranoid (treva as mafia, hedger as mafia)
MaD - naive/normal (Haari as town, hedger as town)

Possible with hedger being insane.


Aray as mafia:

Hedger - paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
treva - naive (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Haari - paranoid/insane (treva as mafia, hedger as mafia)
MaD - normal/naive (Haari as town, hedger as town)

Possible with MaD being normal.


MaD as mafia:

Hedger - normal/paranoid (MaD as mafia)
treva - normal/naive (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Aray - normal/naive (MaD as town, hedger as town)
Haari - paranoid/insane (treva as mafia, hedger as mafia)

Not possible. MaD's in the clear.


Haari as mafia:

Hedger - paranoid/insane (MaD as mafia)
treva - normal/naive (Aray as town, hedger as town)
Aray - naive/normal (MaD as town, hedger as town)
MaD - naive (Haari as town, hedger as town)

Not possible. Haari's in the clear.

So it's either of Treva/ARay for the mafia.

----------

How are you insane with 2 mafia results?

Why not? hedger's confirmed town and if I got a mafia result on him, then I could well be insane too along with paranoid. I think you've confused 'naive' with 'insane'.

 

[ARay]

Why not? hedger's confirmed town and if I got a mafia result on him, then I could well be insane too along with paranoid. I think you've confused 'naive' with 'insane'.

Insane is someone who gets opposite results for an invetigation. That is what I believe. Paranoid is the finding "mafia" version of Naive for all results.
There is only 1 mafia in this game.
You cannot get 2 people as mafia. You are not insane, you are the paranoid cop.

 

[treva]

Would be a terrible mistake to lynch me over ARay. Remember, someone's been making up investigation results, and I believe it's been ARay. Especially as he's been one of the last to reveal his results on both nights.

Lynch: ARay

----------

Insane is someone who gets opposite results for an invetigation. That is what I believe. Paranoid is the finding "mafia" version of Naive for all results.
There is only 1 mafia in this game.
You cannot get 2 people as mafia. You are not insane, you are the paranoid cop.

Insane means you get the opposite result, so he can be insane, as it would mean both are town. Hedger is confirmed town and I know I'm town, therefore he can be insane.

 

[Haarithan]

You cannot get 2 people as mafia. You are not insane, you are the paranoid cop.

Insane cop is one who upon investigation gets opposite alignment as his result. So if I'd got 2 mafia results, then it just means I'm either paranoid for the same, or it could also be due to the fact that I might have investigated two townies and got opposite results.

 

[ARay]

Would be a terrible mistake to lynch me over ARay. Remember, someone's been making up investigation results, and I believe it's been ARay. Especially as he's been one of the last to reveal his results on both nights.

Lynch: ARay

I have been last to reveal because my time zone never matches up with any of you guys at anytime. To be fair, I have not seen you make any effort to clear anyone in this game. I have been vocal about every player that is a townie in this game.

I think as mafia that is what your intention has always been, ensure as less people are cleared as possible so that we can all remain confused. This is why you never cleared anyone.