Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[BKB1991]

damn we lost Hedger, and knowing Snape, I am pretty sure it was an important role.

On other thoughts epic mafia fail. Apparently there plan was to silence Matt and put the lynch on him. Apparently that doesnt make him mafia, and one that the mafia really fear.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Oh crud, not Snape! He would have had a very important role - spy even, considering what he did in the books. Big loss for us

Going to analyze some of Hedge's posts now. If he was a spy, he might have given us some clues.

This is only a theory btw. If he was a spy, I have no idea how the mafia caught on. Matt might have had a role in this, I don't know.

/confusion

----------

Just re-read my post. That spy thing sounds very similar to a cop. Huge loss for us, if that is indeed true.

----------

Hmmm, interesting. Went to the 'number of posts' link on the thread page to find all of Hedge's posts. And I noticed some of the users have hardly posted. Varun stood out, cos I thought he had been more active, but he only has 18 posts. Closer analysis, and he hasn't in fact lynched anyone yet. Very suspicious.

FOS: Varun
Reason: Not lynched anyone

 

[pcfan123]

if Hedger was the cop that should make our next lynch easy

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Did a quick read, but his posts didn't reveal anything substantial. After the lynch of paki007, he was suspicous of Bevab, and might have went for a lynch on him as well (can't remember now). But after Bevab's role-claim, he said that he thought it was legit, and suspected Matt.

 

[BKB1991]

Well if he was the cop, its possible he didnt fight anything on the first few nights, hence he didnt go for anyone aggresively? Or maybe we are mistaking Snape to be a cop. When me and LL were discussing about Snape we were thinking of giving him a really powerful role, like a Jack-of-all-trades or something.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

Hmm could be. Either way, he's a big loss. I'm guessing you were planning of starting one of your own HP mafias?

 

[Near]

Damn it,Hedger firstly was taking part in the discussion and with it had one of the most important roles.I mean if I remember correctly Snape was a double agent maybe Hedger was in the mafia team and one of the mafia found out?And the thing about Matt I have no idea what happened there.Still thinking.I don't think Snape had the role of a cop he might have but I think chances of him being a cop is low

 

[ARay]

If I was a mafia, I would have tried to kill off Aray, simply because he is very active in the discussions and good at analyzing the situation. Eventually he would figure out who the mafia are and thus he would be one of the first I would kill at night. Weird that they did not go for him, suspicious even

I presume, you are either trying to defend yourself by stating that you are not mafia or you are trying to imply I might possibly be mafia?

Anyways hedger is gone and probably an important role along with it.
Matt is definitely anti-town. If he was a pro-town with his unlynchable role, he would have been a huge help.
His attitude towards us shows he clearly does not give a rat's bottom about the town.
Since he has not gone down at night. It rules out the possibility that we might have a town killer. It also means that he is not unlynchable. An anti-town who is unlynchable and cannot be killed at night (as townies have no killer) would be super over-powered.
Ofcourse it could very well be that the town killer chose not to kill. But I am analyzing it based on the data in front of me.

A few people who really need to start posting more are
1) Varun
2) BKB
3) There might be more, but they really have not caught my attention yet.

Anyways, Matt being silenced might be a good thing in a way. He was being a pain anyways. But that is just my thoughts.
I guess I have to re-read the thread again and see if I can find something that will help me decide today's lynch.

 

[Papa_Smurf]

A few people who really need to start posting more are
1) Varun
2) BKB
3) There might be more, but they really have not caught my attention yet.

I agree, especially about Varun, for reasons I've already said. I don't suspect BKB, well not yet anyway, because of what was revealed during Day 1. Hmm, I'm going to kick-start this day.

Lynch: Varun
Reason: Has been quiet, well cleverly masking it well. Hasn't lynched anyone either.

----------

*while cleverly masking it well.

 

[Chewie]

Matt has been silenced. He cannot post at all.

Bevab claimed he had been placed under a post limit.

How likely is it that there is a silencer and another person who limits the amount one can post?

FOS: Bevab

 

[pcfan123]

can you direct me to that Bevab post where he claims a limit

 

[Chewie]

http://www.planetcricket.org/forums/2060475-post352.html

 

[pcfan123]

thanks

 

[Bevab]

Matt has been silenced. He cannot post at all.

Bevab claimed he had been placed under a post limit.

How likely is it that there is a silencer and another person who limits the amount one can post?

FOS: Bevab

Limiting, and silencing could be both the same person of mafia.
And your FOS'ing of me is rather suspicious.

FOS:Varun, Chewie

Varun has been not that much helpful. And Chewie's erratic decisions of FOS'ing puts him under my scanner.

Not a good sign that Matt was silenced, we should know what role he has.

Maybe some town member has the power of silencing. I think its that way because there can't be two powers in mafia.

 

[Chewie]

And you're saying you've been helpful? I fail to see how me throwing around my second FOS (iirc, could be my first) is erratic. I have a perfectly valid reason to suspect you, which you are trying to avoid and failing to do so.