Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[Chewie]

errr how did I defend Varun?

----------

oh that wasn't really defending him. And I was just pointing something out about Bevab.

 

[Near]

Mark's comment is quite suspicious.I mean he said if he was a mafia he would kill ARay as he is a more intense discussion-maker.But what about Chewie?He has more posts and is also in my opinion quite an intense discussion maker.So,why not mention Chewie,because he is a mafia with Mark?I know Papa Smurf has the same amount of posts as Chewie but Chewie has been much more on the edge than Papa Smurf.I will give Varun more time to give a better reason for not being active.

So,
FOS:Mark,Chewie
Reason:Possible Partners(then most probably Mafia)

 

[Aditya]

Can we stop making out who is mafia and who is not mafia based on the post counts. How does your post count make you a mafia? It makes sense, when someone is posting unnecessarily (or posting but still not being of any help like Matt) or not at all posting even though he is online, lynching him or being suspicious of him is fine but when someone is posting and taking part in the discussion whats the point of lynching that member.

 

[Varun]

Hmmm, I went through the whole game again and have made some (excellent) observations (it does seem).

Well theirs goes 1 mafia person. Yesssssss

Lynch Me, Lynch Me, Lynch Me please

I think all of the people who didn't lynch are mafia people.

Matt is the probably the toughguy or scotsman or bulletproof. That's why he wanted us to lynch him.
Now, if we look at the other side of the coin, and believe that Matt was just being himself, it's clear he isn't mafia aligned (may be an individual, can't say).
The first quote, and the third impart a belief in him to me. Plus if we go logically by his '13% chance of being mafia', he is less likely to be the mafia.

Also, I think the mafia feared he was a suicide bomber or someone who'd take down the hammer voter with him, thus they were reluctant to hammer lynch him. ARay?
But once exposed, he was silenced. (inferred from the night writeup)

Conclusion : That's not a credible theory altogether, but I've a slight belief there's some substance in it.

Yeah, there's not really much at all there for us to work from.

Firstly what sort of role what Hagrid have had?
Possibly a vanilla townie?

----------

Firstly what sort of role would* Hagrid have had?

Finding his role?

Oh no, not Hagrid! "You're a wizard, Harry". Love that line!

Anyway, I have a theory on his role. Since Hagrid was the keeper of keys, he would have access to every room in Hogwarts. Maybe he could move people around in the middle of the night. I think me might have been the bus-driver.

Thought Matt might have been a target - he is pretty annoying. The reasons they didn't went for him could have been:

1) He's Mafia
2) He causes so much confusion, it enhances their cause.

Either way, I can't think of any reason why he might be helpful to us.

Lynch: Matt121
Reason: Nuisance

This post's full of confusion. A townie would never post something which would be confusing for other townies.

Valid argument Chewie.

----------

I'll wait before my lynch, let other members moan at Hagrid's demise.

That justifies me, that I wanted to see how members react to Hagrid's demise, I was busy the yesterday and the day before yesterday, so I couldn't do a full assessment.

My thoughts regarding Matt are, that he wants us to lynch him. Therefore we will not.

But I'm just as suspicious of Bevab as p23456789. He's viewing the thread so hopefully he can come on and put some of his thoughts down.

Chewie is afraid of lynching Matt. 'We will not'. Who will not?

Ginny

Hey stop!
The post restriction was done by a mafia member on me. It wasn't in my role. It was done on Day 1 itself so its the reason why I can't post much. If you ask how much, well only Spin knows. He randomly generates for each phase. But if I'm close to my post limit, Spin will alert me.

My character is Professor Flitwick, Team Hogwarts aligned Tiny charms Teacher.
The reason why I was reluctant to role-claim was because it was my 1st game and also I had a cop role last time.

----------

Lynch:Matt121

Reason:Look at his funny posts recently.
Also his weird acts have been over the top.

I know I posted something in support of Bevab. On a second look at this post, it all seems Chewie and bevab are partners.
Chewie suggesting a 'quiet' character for Bevab's role, a townie. Trying to clear off his partner. Bevab's role-claim now seems suspicious, I'm not sure if Flitwick would be there in this game (with there being many other more important characters). Probably, Chewie helped him fabricating a role.

why dont you lynch Matt with us Chewie, just need the hammer vote.

So you expect me to just sit here watching while everyone goes and lynches someone without a proper investigation into what his role could be? Don't you think it is worth exploring all possible alternatives before lynching someone who wants to be lynched? He is obviously being annoying for a reason, and you guys are just gonna vote him off because he is annoying and not contributing, while his role may have something happen when he is lynched.

One other alternative to a jester is that he is a suicide bomber sort of role who takes the hammer voter with him.

Also, it is good to see that p23456789 is contributing, but all he is posting is what other people have posted, in a confusing way.

----------

Matt121: 7 (p23456789, Aditya, Bevab, ARay, Papa Smurf, User2010, Mark)
Chewie: 1 (Abhas)
8 votes for a lynch

Because I want him to roleclaim. I also don't want to die in case he is a suicide bomber sort of role.

He's clearly afraid of dying and wants to find out if he isn't a suicide bomber. A townie won't be afraid of lynching a mafia-suicide bomber because someone has to die killing him.

Well, clearly we know why we wanted us to lynch him.
He is definitely not town aligned. If he is not lynchable, the he has to be vulnerable at night.
Either way, its time we concentrate on other members.

Can't make out much of this.

You guys have wasted a day already by voting on him :/

Trying to avoid commenting on his escape?

Hmmm, interesting. Went to the 'number of posts' link on the thread page to find all of Hedge's posts. And I noticed some of the users have hardly posted. Varun stood out, cos I thought he had been more active, but he only has 18 posts. Closer analysis, and he hasn't in fact lynched anyone yet. Very suspicious.

That's farcical reasoning.

Conclusion : Chewie's more probable to be the mafia, Bevab being one of his partner. Smurf and Matt might be his partners (if Matt isn't really a bulletproof, and has some other kind of role.) But since Matt has been silenced, I rule out the possibility of him being the mafia (I don't mean anti-town, he could be an individually aligned).

Lynch : Chewie

 

[Chewie]

lol this is quite amusing, how you are taking things out of thin air in some places to draw this conclusion.

I don't see how you think bevab and I are partners. I wanted to lynch him the other day, and me targeting him was making people think I was mafia. Someone had asked who would have a post restriction in the HP world and I suggested Ginny.

Wouldn't you be afraid of dying? Why would I want to die and therefore lose the game? The way he posted just made me wary enough of him not to want to hammer vote him.

 

[CG123]

Finding his role?

I've already been accused of mafia because I was asking about what role Hagrid would have had (read back where I answered a few questions in my defence). Also have you read the last two pages where people have been asking about Snape's role? Obviously not...

Feel free to ask any questions regarding me.

 

[Gaurav_7]

I'm completely confused. I really don't know who to lynch. There seem to be many people. I don't think Matt is town aligned. If he was, he wouldn't have done what he did. I feel mafia just shut their own mate, just to show Matt is a townie and to escape from people's suspect list. The one among the mafias could be Chewie given that he was suspected by many after I posted those things earlier.

I know I'm not sounding too good but, it is all confusion.

 

[CG123]

Yeah, I've got mixed feelings about a lot of people, and I think most of us do really.

Firstly I'd still like to get rid of some of the lesser contributing members though. ATM I don't want to name names, because as soon as I do I'll be the one getting questioned.

I'll take a look over things again tomorrow, as it's getting slightly late here.

----------

questioned was the wrong word, I should have said suspected

 

[Varun]

Also, I'm darn sure that Hedger was a miller.

 

[Chewie]

At this stage, there's not much point getting rid of people who don't post much - we should be focusing on those who are suspicious. It's only worth bothering to find the inactive members in the first round because there aren't any indications as to who could be mafia.

I don't really see why my name has come up so much in mafia discussions. The accusations people have made towards me are rather like they're trying to make a mountain out of a molehill.

----------

Also, I'm darn sure that Hedger was a miller.

of course he was

 

[Varun]

I'm completely confused. I really don't know who to lynch. There seem to be many people. I don't think Matt is town aligned. If he was, he wouldn't have done what he did. I feel mafia just shut their own mate, just to show Matt is a townie and to escape from people's suspect list. The one among the mafias could be Chewie given that he was suspected by many after I posted those things earlier.

I know I'm not sounding too good but, it is all confusion.

Actually I'm too. But me writing that post was inevitable considering that I'm being tricked into getting lynched. I've to vindicate myself.

----------

Wouldn't you be afraid of dying?

If I was sure Matt was sure that Matt was a mafia, and was unsure of him being a suicide bomber, I would have risked it. But I was offline at the time Matt was hammered.

 

[Chewie]

You can't win if you're dead. I knew that others were going to lynch him anyway, and I never felt it was a good idea to lynch him in the first place

 

[Gaurav_7]

How come you guys know he was a miller?

 

[Varun]

of course he was

Also that he had no other significant role.

----------

How come you guys know he was a miller?

Read the night writeup again.

----------

You can't win if you're dead. I knew that others were going to lynch him anyway, and I never felt it was a good idea to lynch him in the first place

So, what do you think of him as? Anti-town or pro-town? Have a glance at what I posted (his quotes)

----------

Many had thought this person was on the dark side. Clearly, they were mistaken.

For user.

 

[Chewie]

I just didn't think lynching was the right way to solve his problem