Harry Potter Mafia - The End! Abhas/Death Eaters win!

[CG123]

@ Varun in terms of that quote from the night two write-up - That could just be in terms of Snape in general, there was something like that in the night one write-up, but Chez said it was just coincidental.

 

[Varun]

Unlynch : Chewie

Un-lynching him for now, he always give you plausible reasons. Either a clever player, or really a townie. Can't tell.

 

[Gaurav_7]

Varun, that might have to do with the fact that we were suspicious of him and Smurf being together. But, it can also be the other way round. Yeah, can be a miller.

 

[Varun]

@ Varun in terms of that quote from the night two write-up - That could just be in terms of Snape in general, there was something like that in the night one write-up, but Chez said it was just coincidental.

That was not about Matt's character in general. Every wizard/witch can vanish with a spell.

----------

Varun, that might have to do with the fact that we were suspicious of him and Smurf being together. But, it can also be the other way round. Yeah, can be a miller.

But yet, he was Evil Looking Potions Professor. If we actually consider Snape in the book, miller suited him the most.

 

[BKB1991]

Snape seems to be the perfect miller, but its obvious to me that he probably atleast one good role other than that.

Varuns reasoning against Chewie is certainly interesting. Plus Marks post against ARay is pretty crucial too.

Cant really fingerpoint anyone in particular. Tbf I am not really sure about anyone right now.

Havent seen a post from Abhas for a while? Did he say he was busy or something, I cant quite recall it exactly.

 

[Varun]

He was flying to Australia.

 

[pcfan123]

And Mark's post is very funny, considering he is trying to help the mafia. He could be an individual.

I'm most deffo not an individual, there are at least 3-4 of me

@ p12345667

yea it could be Chewie as well, my point was simply that the mafia chose to kill two random members with low posts/not much discussion. Aray and Chewie are easily the best players and logic dictates that the mafia would want to knock them off first.

FOS Aray Chewie

 

[Papa_Smurf]

This post's full of confusion. A townie would never post something which would be confusing for other townies.

What?? How was anything in that poast confusing - I was just sharing my ideas. If the whole situation was confusing, I admitted it was, just like you and User have admitted it as well.

That's farcical reasoning.

Farcical enough for you to change your entire manner. You've suddenly become a lot more active than before your suspicion. Your over-defensiveness and sudden decision to lynch Chewie (who was the other suspicious member) has made me even more suspicious of you. I know you've un-lynched since then, but still pointing this fact to you.

And that huge post you posted, being suspicious of people from what they posted days apart and little fabrications of the discussions at the time, seems to me to be a desperate move.

In conclusion, you haven't convinced me to unlynch you.

 

[Near]

Hmmmm....Varun has suddenly become active which look quite suspicious to me too as Papa Smurf pointed out.But I haven't got any big suspects yet,so will go back a few pages and read the discussions to look for any clues.Bevab is also looking a bit suspicious with his post restriction claim.

Edit:Ignore the Silver part
and its looks

 

[ARay]

I'm most deffo not an individual, there are at least 3-4 of me

@ p12345667

yea it could be Chewie as well, my point was simply that the mafia chose to kill two random members with low posts/not much discussion. Aray and Chewie are easily the best players and logic dictates that the mafia would want to knock them off first.

FOS Aray Chewie

I really do not understand how can you deduce a logic as such. While I do agree, I help promote discussions. The mafia are clearly looking for members who most likely have power roles.
It might be helpful to knock out great discussion makers, but it would be unwise from them to have cops and doctors running around.

Also, I hope you have heard something called counter logic?
Counter logic can probably dictate that the mafia allow me to live, so that they can lynch me off during the day (with the very logic you have stated).
In the mean time, they can use their night role to finish up townies whom they think might have power roles.

On another note, I am going to have a busy few days. So forgive me if I am not active. But I have 2 assigments, 2 midterms, 2 problem sets, chem lab writeup and pop quizzs to study for.
I will try to take part in the discussion as much as possible.

 

[Near]

And a question:
What's a miller?What does he do?

 

[ARay]

And a question:
What's a miller?What does he do?

A miller is a role which comes up mafia when the cop investigates them at night.
But they are actually town-aligned.

 

[CG123]

Not really much discussion since I was last on here, so I still have no idea who to lynch.

I'm quite suspicious of Aditya, as none of his posts have really helped us remotely.

Ignoring his "I'm in" post, 8 out of his other 13 posts have been/were to do with Matt, so he could have know that Matt was unlynchable.

 

[Chewie]

FOS: p23456789

His first posts were bandwagon jumps and repeating what other people had said. Later when we were thinking about lynching him because he wasn't active and doing much, he suddenly starts posting much more, as if he were mafia trying to protect himself, now that he is under some suspicion. Still though, his posts contain nothing substantial, and are basically the same as what someone a few posts before him has said, or asking questions about mafia/harry potter.

 

[CG123]

With p23456789 I'd be leaning towards mega noob, but he still hasn't really contributed anything helpful.

* Waits for people to post; "CG being overprotective of p23456789?" *